E. Cobham Brewer 18101897. Dictionary of Phrase and Fable. 1898.
Yeomen of the Guard in the royal household, appointed, in 1485, by Henry VII., to form part of the royal train in banquets and other grand occasions. The old theory was that the word means an attendant on the royal buffets, Anglicised into buffeters or buffeteers, and corrupted into Beefeaters; but Professor Skeat says no such word as buffeter has yet been found in any book; nor does buffetier exist in French.
A plausible reply to this objection is that the word may have got corrupted almost ab initio in those unlettered days; and the earliest quotation of Beefeater, already adduced, is above 150 years from the institution of the force, and even then the allusions are either satirical or humorous: as Begone, yee greedy beefe-eaters, y are best (Histriomastix, iii. 1; A.D. 1610); Bows, or Beefeaters, as the French were pleased to terme us (1628); You beef-eater, you saucy cur (1671). Not one of the quotations fixes the word on the Yeomen of the Guard, and that the English have been called Beefeaters none will deny. Even if the allusion given above could be certainly affixed to Yeomen of the Guard it would only prove that 150 or 160 years after their establishment in the palace they were so called (corruptly, humorously or otherwise).
Arguments in favour of the old derivation:
(1) Certainly Henry VII, himself did not call these yeomen beef-eaters. He was as much French as Welsh, and must have been familiar with the buffet (bu-fey); he had no spark of humour in his constitution, and it is extremely doubtful whether beef was a standing dish at the time, certainly it was not so in Wales. We have a good number of menus extant of the period, but beef does not appear in any of them.
(2) We have a host of similar corruptions in our language, as Andrew Macs (q.v.), Billy-ruffians (see BELLEROPHON), Bull and Mouth (q.v.), Charless Wain (q.v.), Bag-o-Nails, Goat and Compasses, Sparrow-grass (asparagus), ancient (ensign), lutestring (lustring, from lustre), Dog-cheap (god-kepe, i.e. a good bargain), and many more of the same sort.
(3) There can be no doubt that the beefeaters waited at the royal table, for in 1602 we read that the dishes were brought in by the halberdiers [beefeaters], who are fine, big fellows (quoted in Notes and Queries, February 4th, 1893, p. 86).
(4) If beef was a general food in the sixteenth century, which is extremely doubtful, it would be supremely ridiculous to call a few yeomen eaters of beef, unless beef was restricted to them. In the present Argentine Republic, beef dried, called jerked beef,
is the common diet, and it would be foolish indeed to restrict the phrase eaters of jerked beef to some half-score waiters at the Presidents table.
(5) That the word buffetcer or buffetier is not to be found (in the English sense) in any French author, does not prove that it was never used in Anglo-French. We have scores of perverted French words, with English meanings, unrecognised by the French; for example: encore, double entendre, surtout (a frock coat), epergne, and so on.
(6) Historic etymology has its value, but, like all other general rules, it requires to be narrowly watched, or it may not unfrequently over-ride the truth. Historically, Rome comes from Romulus, Scotland from Scota or Scotia, Britain from Brutus. All sorts of rubbishy etymology belong to the historic craze.
Beefeaters. Yeomen Extraordinary of the Guard appointed as warders of the Tower by Edward VI. They wear the same costume as the Yeomen of the Guard mentioned above. (See BUPHAGOS.)