Can people resist normative and informational social influence? Name: Emery Zhen Student ID: u5348471 Tutor’s Name: Sydney Kingstone Lab Time: Thursday 11-1pm Word Count: 2007 (include title page and references) Australian National University Can people resist to normative and informational social influence? There is a fundamental human need to belong to social groups especially if people were to live and work together, it is likely that they need to agree on common beliefs, values, attitudes and behaviours in order to get along and fit-in. Thus, we learnt to conform to rules of other people, the more people see others behaving in a particular way or making particular decisions, the more likely people will feel obliged to follow the suit. This is called conformity and can be defined in different ways, Aronson, Wilson & Akert (2014) stated it is the changing of one’s behavior due to the real or imagined influence of other people. According to Deutsch and Gerard (1955), social influence should be distinguished into two types, the informational social influence and normative social influence. The occurrence of social influence has implied to many real life events, which has drawn many researchers to attention. This has lead many researchers to design distinct experiments to try and understand the cause of the conformity, whether conformity is situation dependent, and whether we are able to resist social influences. The influence of others leads us to conform because we see
One subtle form of social influence is conformity. Conformity is a change in one’s behavior due to the real or imagined influence of other people. The aftermath of conforming ranges from heroism to tragedy. If we are uncertain about how to think or what do, we may rely on informational social influence. Informational social influence is the influence of other people that leads us to conform because we see them as a source of information to guide our behavior. We conform because we believe that others’ interpretations of an ambiguous situation is more correct than ours and will help us choose an appropriate course of action. Private acceptance is conforming to other people’s behavior out of a genuine belief that what they are doing or
Imagine a thirteen year old middle school girl, wearing Guess boots and an Abercrombie hood in order to fit in. Visualize a thirty five year old man listening to the top forty radio stations and watching American Idol, so he can have something to add to the discussion with his co-workers over coffee break. The various types of behaviours stated before are pertained to as conformity. Conformity refers to the process by which an individual's attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours are influenced by other individuals. Except, how do these necessities manipulate a being? Social psychologists have conducted an assortment of experiments and concluded that, through a range of forms of social influence, groups can alter their members’ personality.
Conformity is a type of social influence which involves a change in behaviour and belief of a minority to fit in with the group concerning real or imagined group pressures. This behaviour could be defined as the pressure to behave in ways that are viewed as acceptable by a particular group, brought about either by a desire to ‘fit in’ or be liked. The main factor that influences conformity are social norms. Social Norms are a pattern of expected behaviour in certain situations either implicitly or explicitly. Conformity exists in two categories, normative influence where the individual’s desire is to gain social approval and acceptance from the group to make a favourable impression. And informational social influence where a person is looking for guidance in an ambiguous situation as the individual listens to other member 's views and opinions to be guided to an answer. Conformity is distinguished in three different types; Compliance is the most superficial type of conformity. It refers to a person who conforms publicly with the views and attitudes expressed by the group but still continue to privately disagree. This temporary short term behavioural change which often results normative social influence. For example, It is a student 's first day of college, but has arrived late and missed the induction to which he doesn 't know where to go. He then sees a group of students filing off towards a corridor and
Conformity refers to the likelihood that an individual will follow the unspoken rules or behaviors of the social group to which they belong. In the short video clip titled “Asch Conformity Experiment”, we learned that people can feel pressured into abnormal behavior because of the unanimity of the majority.
Group conformity is defined as the way people change their behavior or character when influenced by other people or by a certain social environment. A basic example of it will be a teenager whom friends are all smirking a cigarette, fear of not being part of the group our teenager will at his turn light a cigarette. Conformity in a group is in way copying what other members are doing to integrate the group, one can act totally out of character just for the group conformity. In this essay we will analyze how people are affected by group conformity and what kind of changes some are willing to make in their characters or behavior. We will also analyze how can group conformity be expressed in our society. Finally we will analyze what statistics and scientific research is telling us about group conformity.
The article Opinions and Social Pressure primarily focuses on answering the question “how strong is the urge toward social conformity” (Asch)? Asch answered this question through his own experiments. He put together a group of men to look at three straight lines on white cards and decide which two lines were the same. For several trials, all of the men were able to agree which lines were the same. During one of the later trials, one of the men differed from the consensus of the majority group. The purpose of the experiment was to see whether or not the actions of the differing individual would help others trust their own instincts and break out from social conformity. After conducting similar experiments, Asch came to the conclusion that
Conformity falls under the realm of Social Psychology as it deals with social interaction often exploring its roots, effects and influences. Conformity is an intriguing topic as it is not entirely visible but
In everyday life we are affected by social influence. Social influence happens whether intentional or unintentional, it affects our emotions, behaviours and opinions sometimes without us realising. There are many forms of social influence such as conformity and obedience. Conformity is when we match other people’s attitudes, opinions and beliefs in order to fit in with others around you. Obedience is when people take orders or instructions from someone they believe is an authority figure, even if they think it is not the right thing to do. Conformity happens when people obey social norms. Social norms are rules that people are expected to act upon in society or a give group. When someone does not act within the social norms they are considered to be abnormal.
Conformity is thought to be an important force in human evolution because it has the potential to stabilize cultural similarities between cultural diversity groups (Claidière, Bowler, Brookes, Brown, & Whiten, 2014). However, the effects of conformity can make us change the way we behave and think due to the individuals are around us. According to Myers and Twenge (2015), there are two varieties of conformity that happen when we are trying to adapt or change our behavior in order to feel socially accepted by society. The first type of conformity is acceptance, which is when we sincerely believe what others are telling us. The second type of conformity is compliance, which is when we conform to the expectations
In psychological terms, conformity refers to an individual`s urge to follow the rules or behaviours of a social group to which he belongs. Psychologists have put forward many theories to find out why people conform and obey and have completed studies to confirm their ideas. In this essay I will explain why people conform and obey.
Sherif (1936) conducted a study on conformity. This experiment tested how people were influenced by others in their perception and judgement of the autokinetic effect. Sherif concluded that people when judging an ambiguous stimulus will rely upon others to resolve uncertainty – shared norms were created. Participants tend to compromise and change their opinion to resemble others in the group. Similarly, Asch (1951) carried out an experiment with not ambiguous stimulus – with an apparent, correct answer to a line judgement task. However, this experiment reached the same conclusions – even though, the answer was obviously wrong, participants were influenced by other group members and tend to conform to a majority. 76.4% of naïve participants gave a wrong answer in at least one of the 12 trials. Asch (1951) concluded that people tend to conform because of the normative influence -
Conformity is a powerful force that can take the form of social pressure, or unconscious influence. The general concept of conformity refers to any change in behavior caused by another person or group. Conformity is limited to changes in behavior caused by other people, it does not affect internal concepts such as attitudes or beliefs (Breckler,Olson,Wiggins,2005, p. 29). Dr. Gregory Berns stated “the two leading theories of conformity are that people look to the group because they are unsure of what to do, and that people go along with the group because they are afraid of being different” (Why So Many Minds Think Alike, 2009, [Online]).
According to an article by Saul Mcleod in Simple Psychology, “conformity is a type of social influence involving a change in belief or
In 1951 Solomn Asch, a Polish psychologist, administered an experiment to consider the effect to which social pressures from a majority group would have on an individual to conform. Solomn had a staged group of nine people and a single real participant take a visual line comparison test, in which participants would choose which line out of three matched the comparison line best. After running twelve trials, Solomn found that around seventy-five percent of real participants would knowingly conform at least once to the majority group that would always pick the wrong line. Solomn was able to conclude that people conform for two main reasons: either to fit in, known as normative influence, or because they believe they are less informed than the
Social Psychology has always been a key element in our understanding of human behaviour. Conformity plays a big part in the history of social psychology; conformity (also known as Majority Influence) is a type of social influence that involves a person changing their thoughts and beliefs in order to fit into a group. An example of this is during WW2, in which Hitler used his dominating opinions and authority to influence the Nazis and obscure their views, which lead them to conform to the horrendous orders that were given during the war. Therefore social psychology can help us understand how a certain phrase, appearance, status, or opinion can influence different behaviours in different cultures. However, certain cultures are more susceptible to conform. This links to the idea of Gerard’s (1955) development of social theory, normative social influence, this consists of the desire to ‘fit in’ and obtain social approval, which results in avoiding punishment, exclusion and ridicule. Two important studies that have been conducted by Asch and Milgram are great examples of how conformity and normative social influence can affect people’s behaviours.