Roget's Int'l Thesaurus
Fowler's King's English
The King James Bible
Brewer's Phrase & Fable
Frazer's Golden Bough
Shelf of Fiction
> 20. The Equality of Inertial and Gravitational Mass as an Argument for the General Postulate of Relativity
Relativity: The Special and General Theory.
The Equality of Inertial and Gravitational Mass as an Argument for the General Postulate of Relativity
imagine a large portion of empty space, so far removed from stars and other appreciable masses that we have before us approximately the conditions required by the fundamental law of Galilei. It is then possible to choose a Galileian reference-body for this part of space (world), relative to which points at rest remain at rest and points in motion continue permanently in uniform rectilinear motion. As reference-body let us imagine a spacious chest resembling a room with an observer inside who is equipped with apparatus. Gravitation naturally does not exist for this observer. He must fasten himself with strings to the floor, otherwise the slightest impact against the floor will cause him to rise slowly towards the ceiling of the room.
To the middle of the lid of the chest is fixed externally a hook with rope attached, and now a being (what kind of a being is immaterial to us) begins pulling at this with a constant force. The chest together with the observer then begin to move upwards with a uniformly accelerated motion. In course of time their velocity will reach unheard-of valuesprovided that we are viewing all this from another reference-body which is not being pulled with a rope.
But how does the man in the chest regard the process? The acceleration of the chest will be transmitted to him by the reaction of the floor of the chest. He must therefore take up this pressure by means of his legs if he does not wish to be laid out full length on the floor. He is then standing in the chest in exactly the same way as anyone stands in a room of a house on our earth. If he release a body which he previously had in his hand, the acceleration of the chest will no longer be transmitted to this body, and for this reason the body will approach the floor of the chest with an accelerated relative motion. The observer will further convince himself
that the acceleration of the body towards the floor of the chest is always of the same magnitude, whatever kind of body he may happen to use for the experiment.
Relying on his knowledge of the gravitational field (as it was discussed in the preceding section), the man in the chest will thus come to the conclusion that he and the chest are in a gravitational field which is constant with regard to time. Of course he will be puzzled for a moment as to why the chest does not fall in this gravitational field. Just then, however, he discovers the hook in the middle of the lid of the chest and the rope which is attached to it, and he consequently comes to the conclusion that the chest is suspended at rest in the gravitational field.
Ought we to smile at the man and say that he errs in his conclusion? I do not believe we ought if we wish to remain consistent; we must rather admit that his mode of grasping the situation violates neither reason nor known mechanical laws. Even though it is being accelerated with respect to the Galileian space first considered, we can nevertheless regard the chest as being at rest. We have thus good grounds for extending the principle of relativity to include bodies of reference which are accelerated with respect to each other, and as a result we have gained a powerful argument for a generalised postulate of relativity.
We must note carefully that the possibility of this mode of interpretation rests on the fundamental property of the gravitational field of giving all bodies the same acceleration, or, what comes to the same thing, on the law of the equality of inertial and gravitational mass. If this natural law did not exist, the man in the accelerated chest would not be able to interpret the behaviour of the bodies around him on the supposition of a gravitational field, and he would not be justified on the grounds of experience in supposing his reference-body to be at rest.
Suppose that the man in the chest fixes a rope to the inner side of the lid, and that he attaches a body to the free end of the rope. The result of this will be to stretch the rope so that it will hang vertically downwards. If we ask for an opinion of the cause of tension in the rope, the man in the chest will say: The suspended body experiences a downward force in the gravitational field, and this is neutralised by the tension of the rope; what determines the magnitude of the tension of the rope is the
of the suspended body. On the other hand, an observer who is poised freely in space will interpret the condition of things thus: The rope must perforce take part in the accelerated motion of the chest, and it transmits this motion to the body attached to it. The tension of the rope is just large enough to effect the acceleration of the body. That which determines the magnitude of the tension of the rope is the
of the body. Guided by this example, we see that our extension of the principle of relativity implies the
of the law of the equality of inertial and gravitational mass. Thus we have obtained a physical interpretation of this law.
From our consideration of the accelerated chest we see that a general theory of relativity must yield important results on the laws of gravitation. In point of fact, the systematic pursuit of the general idea of relativity has supplied the laws satisfied by the gravitational field. Before proceeding farther, however, I must warn the reader against a misconception suggested by these considerations. A gravitational field exists for the man in the chest, despite the fact that there was no such field for the co-ordinate system first chosen. Now we might easily suppose that the existence of a gravitational field is always only an
one. We might also think that, regardless of the kind of gravitational field which may be present, we could always choose another reference-body such that
gravitational field exists with reference to it. This is by no means true for all gravitational fields, but only for those of quite special form. It is, for instance, impossible to choose a body of reference such that, as judged from it, the gravitational field of the earth (in its entirety) vanishes.
We can now appreciate why that argument is not convincing, which we brought forward against the general principle of relativity at the end of
. It is certainly true that the observer in the railway carriage experiences a jerk forwards as a result of the application of the brake, and that he recognises in this the non-uniformity of motion (retardation) of the carriage. But he is compelled by nobody to refer this jerk to a real acceleration (retardation) of the carriage. He might also interpret his experience thus: My body of reference (the carriage) remains permanently at rest. With reference to it, however, there exists (during the period of application of the brakes) a gravitational field which is directed forwards and which is variable with respect to time. Under the influence of this field, the embankment together with the earth moves non-uniformly in such a manner that their original velocity in the backwards direction is continuously reduced.
+ see more popular essays
- hide popular essays
Analysis Of Langston Hughes ' Writing
Psychology : Cognitive Psychology And Psychology
Drug Use On Young College Students
The Yellow Emperor Of Shan Jing, A Great Chinese Culture Creator
Teaching Courses For Advanced Schooling
The Revolution Of Sentiments And The American Revolution
Concussions On High School Football
Differences Between Prokaryotic And Eukaryotic Organisms
World War I Was The First Major War
Different Changes Within Organisations And How It Has Made An Impact
Pulmonary Fibrosis Research Enhancement Act ( Pfrea )
The Roman Empire And The Romans
The House Of Usher, By Edgar Allan Poe
The Cause And Effect Of Deafness
U.s. State Of New Jersey
A Career That I Am Interested
Language, The, And The Glass Broke
The Legal System Of The United States
Analysis Of ' Starry Night '
Why Are Citizens Holding Congress?
Schizophreni A Mental Disorder
Cyber Bully And What Do Cyber Bullies Look For A Target?
What Makes A Worldview?
Ancient Chinese Compass And Its Effects On Civilization
The Ethics Of An Ethical Code
The Geriatric Population Is Surging Across The World
Peaceful Solutions And Conflicting Nations After World War II
U.s. Honors Pre Wwi
Cultural Values And Health Care
Descartes ' Proof That The Mind And The Body
Becoming The Gospel Michael Gorman
Exploring The Four Principles Of Natural Selection Are Variation, And Descent With Modification
Media Vs. Body Image
Video Games And Its Effects On The World Of The Gaming Community
Engineering & Architects Impacted Our Life Today
Indigenous Australians Face Within The Criminal Justice System
My Grandmother - Original Writing
The Grail As A Symbol Of Divine Grace
A Brief Note On The World Book Encyclopedia
The Principle Of Utility Explicit That Actions Or Behaviors Are Right
Access Of Mental Health Services
The Facts And Benefits Of Animal Testing
The Role Of Government For The General Welfare Of Citizens
The Importance Of Women During The Slave Exchange
Native American Traditions And Traditions Of Clothing, Shelter, And Food
My Own Personal Views On The Christian Spectrum
Business Environment, Innovation And Entrepreneurship : Health Care Industry Swot Analysis
Nazi Book Burning Of 1933
A Close Reading Of Oedipus Rex
The Role Of Socialization And Its Effect On Society
Analysis Of Claude Mckay 's Harlem
Othello, By William Shakespeare
Personal Statement On Emotional Distress
Biography Of Zella Rannul 's ' The Kael '
Depression : Mental And Physical Illnesses
Kill A Mockingbird By Harper Lee
The Effect Of Fine Motor Skill ( Or Finger Dexterity )
Gender And Sex Are Kindred, But They 're Not
Questions On Bacon 's Rebellion
Comparing The Bactericidal Efficiency Of Domestic Cleaning Products
Narrative Of The Life Of Frederick Douglass, An American Slave
The Rabid Dog By Harper Lee
The Mexican Health Care System
Substance Abuse Prevention On Adolescents
Theu.s. B. Du Bois
The Affordable Care Act : A Catalyst For Payment And Delivery System Reform
Experimental Research And Experimental Methods
Humanistic Theories Debate On Abraham Maslow And Carl Rogers
Howard Zinn 's The Vietnam War
Death 's Life Span By Robert Feldman
The Books : A Most Holy War By Mark Pegg And The Teutonic Knights
21st Century Spin On Literature
Nutrition And Motivational Interviewing : The Health And Healing
How Dreams Help Us Grow And Prepare For Life
The Media 's Influence On Girl 's Self Image
The Grandmother Of O ' Connor 's Story Is A Religious Woman
Marriage : A Right Or Privilege?
Film Analysis : ' Sunrise '
Academic Learning Problems Developing From The Stress
The Killer Whale Exhibitions, Blackfish Is An Effective Documentary By Film Maker, Gabriela Cowperthwaite
The Yellow Wallpaper By Charlotte Perkins Gilman
Robotic Milking Is Becoming A Huge Part Of The Dairy Industry
Process Of Replacing Traditional And Emotional Thought With Reason And Practicality
Managing Millennials Today 's Workforce
What I Attempted Into Antisocial Attitudes And Behaviors
The Health Benefits Of Blood Transfusions
The Smoking Of Public Areas Should Be Absolutely Forbidden
How Can Anyone Ever Changed On You?
Slavery And The Making Of American Capitalism
The Effects Of Milk On The Human Body And Will Provide Evidence That Cow Milk
The Fall During The Dark Ages
Wisdom And The Quality Of Being Wise
American Militia Success During The American Revolution
The Tortilla Curtain, By. Boyle
Domestic Violence : Policing Coercive Control
Different Policies And Government Authority
Adolescence : An Exciting Milestone For Any Individual
Research Paper On Child Labor
The, Tolerance, And Cultural Differences
Education Is Not Equally Distributed
Functional Perspective On Group Decision Making
The Internet Can Make People Smarter And Their Lives Easier
Should Marijuana Be Legalized?
The Theory Of The Final Behaviourist Therapy
The Effects Of Childhood Sexual Abuse On Adults Sexual Behavior
Self Determination Theory ( Sdt ) Is A Macro Theory Of Human Motivation
Capital Punishment As A Form Of Retribution
Slavery From The Slave 's Point Of View
Why Or Not Parents Should Be Allowed? Manipulate The Genes Of Their Embryos?
The Sociological Theory Of A Gang Membership And Gang Violence
The World Order 's And Private Institution
The Constitution Of The United States
Frederick Douglass 's Speech Was An Important Speech
Child Marriage Is A Global Issue
The Crime Of The Criminal Justice System
Ender 's Game By Orson Scott Card
Sexual Assault Awareness By K 12 Curriculum
A Outlook On Student Debt
Effects Of Marijuana On The Body
I Know Roseanne Through My Aunt 's Best Friend