Final article review
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
York University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
2100
Subject
Economics
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
2
Uploaded by ChancellorLightningBeaver12
Citibank, Credit Cards, and the Local Politics of National Consumer Finance, 1968–1991
Sean H. Vanatta, the author of this article, holds a Ph.D. from Princeton University. He is currently a US Economic and Social History lecturer at the University of Glasglow. Vanatta provides a perspective on the rise of consumer finance after the postwar and draws attention toward the role of state-level regulatory and financial institutes' drive to gain power over restrictive federal policies. The article starts by providing an overview of the postwar bank regulatory regime and Citibank's position in that situation. Initially, Citibank Citibank optimized the lack of international regulation and expanded its market. It actively sought opportunities to bypass the limitation of charging a maximum interest rate fixed by the state to make a profit on credit cards. Citibank found a solution to its interest rate problem in the legal precedent of Marquette, which allowed the bank to set its credit card rates and transfer the laws of South
Dakota onto all Citi-card transactions across the country. This regional shift of Citibank brought economic prosperity to South Dakota, alluring other regions to lessen their restrictions on banks. Vanatta argues that although Citibank says the changes would contribute to more competition between banks, it was rather between states to make circumstances more favorable for them than consumers ( Vanatta,2015,44).
Vanatta's writing style is academic and has a chronological order of events making it easy to follow. Moreover, simple writing makes it accessible to academic and non-academic audiences. The research presented in the article is extensive and well-documented, with numerous studies and sources cited to support the author's arguments ranging from academic research papers to historical context by referencing key events such as the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956 and the growth of credit card usage. The author does a great job of weaving together the various strands of history, including the regulatory system, the financial conditions of banks, and the development of the credit card market. Moreover, the
author tried to present an opposing point of view, which is appreciated; for instance, admitting credit cards were made more available after the changes to underserved customers (Vandatta,2015,38).
Vandatta successfully conveys that Citibank was an opportunist by depicting historical events of capitalizing on international markets (Vanatta,2015,5), joining BankAmericard Inc. (NBI) after introducing Visa (Vanatta,2015,21), and moving to South Dacota (Vantta,2015,30). The author had a judgment toward banks that they only saw their benefit while ignoring the rights of Americans in the local political economy.
(Vanatta,2015,45).
One of the drawbacks of this article is that the author blames the banking sector's extraterritoriality for political and economic instability but fails to provide direct evidence showing its effects on the economy through any valid proof. The article merely states the events that lead to Citibank's freedom from state regulatory restrictions instead its
aftermath effect for rising consumer debt from 1980 to 2008, reaching over one trillion dollars (Vanatta,2015,42). There needs to be an in-depth analysis of policy changes' effect on consumers. Furthermore, the author is over-looking the point of view of the banks; these
institutions are prone to look for opportunities, especially when they are incurring a loss on the credit cards in order to survive and provide the service it brought a positive aspect to them and the customers by making it eventually more accessible to others. The author solely blames the financial institution for instability and weakened citizenship in America's age of finance but ignores the government's ability to regulate and wrong policy responses.
The article's conclusion draws attention to the political nature of financialization, highlighting the need to reassess the balance between credit access and consumer protection in the era of finance. Overall, the article provides a valuable contribution to understanding the impact of financialization on the American political and economic landscape. Overall, the article offers a thought-provoking analysis of the relationship between financial regulation and the political economy of consumer credit. However, it fails to hold Citibank's relocation accountable for the economic downturn due to insufficient direct linkage. The author failed to convince that Citibank's relocation led to the removal of interest rates and other pricing restrictions and severe economic consequences due to a lack of evidence. The article got deviated more from the history of the changes in the system rather than how the system led to the accumulation of debt.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Questions
SECTION B: ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS
Using an appropriate diagram(s), explain the concept of direct and indirect finance.
As a student of International Finance and Monetary Policy, explain the monetary policy approach the Central Bank should take when it wants to increase the GDP. Offer the tools that are available and the consequences, if any.
Explain the theory of money demand and its relation to inflation in the economy. Use an appropriate equation to demonstrate this.
Explain the concept of moral hazard in relation to financial systems.
arrow_forward
Monetary policy
For the first time since 2006, the Federal Reserve voted to raise interest rates by a one-quarter percentage point in December 2015. Prior to this increase, interest rates had remained between the 0.00% - 0.25% range, an area called “the zero lower bound.”
The Federal Reserve had driven interest rates down that low as a means of helping the economy get back on its feet after the Financial Crisis. The reasoning was that consumers and businesses needed access to loans so that production could turn around. (Consumers take out loans to buy high price items like cars and homes. Businesses use loans as a means of expanding their business. In both instance, more goods will be produced.)
The increase in 2015 moved rates to the 0.25% - 0.50% range. As of October 2018, interest rates have moved to 1.00% - 1.25% range.
For this discussion board, I want you to do some research into the “Financial Crisis.”
Why did it occur? Can you characterize the behavior of the…
arrow_forward
There is a growing concern among tax payers that ‘too big to fail’ (TBTF) creates moral hazard problems and leads to excessive risk-taking and reckless investment decisions by large financial institutions. This unfortunately exposes the tax payer and the economic system to excessive cost. What are the issues surrounding “too big to fail”? Is it possible for the legislative authority to simply “outlaw” TBTF institutions? Why or why not?
arrow_forward
From an economics standpoint, the main benefit of a healthy banking industry is the fact that
banks themselves make a tremendous profit, allowing the owners of banks as well as their employees to have high incomes.
banks force entrepreneurs to pay high interest rates, which contributes to solving the problem of wealth inequality.
banks are able to minimize asymmetric information and adverse selection problems, which allows them to transfer idle funds to more productive ends in a cost-efficient manner.
private banks help keep inflation under control.
arrow_forward
How are monetary and fiscal government policies being affected by this corona virus pandemic ? And give examples
arrow_forward
Below are given two cases showing the relationship between leverage growth and total assets growth drawn from the U.S. flow of funds data over the period 1963- 2006. Identify these two cases among the following alternatives: (1) households (2) non-financial, non-farm corporates (3) commercial banks (4) security brokers and dealers giving reasons for these relationships (negative, positive or no relationships) in both cases.
arrow_forward
In the 2017 UN working paper entitled "On the Role of Central Banks in Enhancing Green Finance," the UN stated that central banks would have what kind of role in addressing environmental concerns?
Central banks would need to develop sustainability targets and governments would create new policy tools to meet those targets.
Central banks would need to develop sustainability targets and create new policy tools to meet those targets
Central banks would need to develop sustainability targets as their new primary goal.
Central banks would need to enforce regulations at commercial banks regarding environmental goals
arrow_forward
Define “financial frictions” in your own terms
arrow_forward
To support economic growth, the Indonesian government is committed to making the Islamic economy a source of national economic growth, one of which is through Islamic banking. In general, the form of a sharia bank business consists of a Commercial Bank and a Sharia Rural Bank, with a number of main differences. Banks are basically entities that collect funds from the public in the form of financing or in other words carry out the function of financial intermediation. There are a number of differences between Islamic Commercial Banks and BPRS. Explain what you know the differences in the bank!
arrow_forward
What were the two previous central banks the United States had before the current Federal Reserve system? When was the Federal Reserve established? How old are some other central banks in other countries? Describe in detail how the Federal Reserve is structured and explain how it is mostly independent from political interference? Using ideas like supply and demand, explain how the Federal Reserve uses open-market operations to either raise or lower interest rates at the direction of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC). See if you can find what the most recent decision made by the FOMC was concerning interest rates and explain how that will be reflected in its open-market operations.
arrow_forward
Which of the following is a difference between "quantitative easing" and ordinary open-market operations?
Multiple Choice
O
There is no difference between the two policy tools.
Open-market operations are focused exclusively on U.S. government bonds; quantitative easing also includes the buying and
selling of debt issued by government agencies and government-sponsored entities.
Quantitative easing is done in order to lower interest rates; open-market operations are merely intended to increase bank
reserves
Open-market operations involve forward commitment, quantitative easing is intentionally vague to maintain flexibility
arrow_forward
In 2007-2009, The US experienced a serious housing and financial crisis that took almost 10 years to recover. In the first discussion forum, we will discuss the following questions.
1. What is a bank run? What is the purpose of the Glass-Steagall legislation?
arrow_forward
Note:-
Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism.
Answer completely.
You will get up vote for sure.
arrow_forward
1) https://openstax.org/books/principles-macroeconomics-2e/pages/15-1-the-federal-reserve-banking-system-and-central-banks
2) https://openstax.org/books/principles-macroeconomics-2e/pages/15-2-bank-regulation
3) https://openstax.org/books/principles-macroeconomics-2e/pages/15-3-how-a-central-bank-executes-monetary-policy
please I need a short summary for these articles.
arrow_forward
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/033115/how-does-law-supply-and-demand-affect-prices.asp#:~:text=There%20is%20an%20inverse%20relationship,quantity%20of%20goods%20and%20services.
review the following article found in Investopedia, Kramer, L. (April 29th, 2021). How does the law of supply and demand affect prices? Investopedia.
Most goods respond to the relationship between price, supply, and demand. What happens when price controls are put in place such as for gasoline in the 1970s? Why?
When does the Fed reduce interest rates and why? When does the Fed increase interest rates and why?
arrow_forward
b) discuss how monetarists and keynesians view the role of government in relation to market intervention.
arrow_forward
What factors may reduce the banks’ dominance in the future? Prove explanations in detail with an example
arrow_forward
Give True or False:
Credit rationing is quantitative credit control measure of Central bank.
arrow_forward
Most legal systems assume that it is better not to incarcerate a guilty individual than to incarcerate an
innocent person (i.e., if you are making a mistake, at least choose the least bad one). As central banks can
potentially make a mistake when bursting asset-price bubbles, which of the following support the
statement: "it is worse to burst a bubble when it was not necessary then not bursting a bubble when it was
needed to."
a)
because central banks have many policy tools to counteract the effect of a price bubble burst, it is usually
considered wiser to leave bubbles alone and eventually act if needed.
b)
The worst mistake would be to burst a bubble when it was not necessary because the central bank may
impose harm to the economy when it was not necessary.
c)
Most central banks are quite conservative with respect to taking actions against asset-price bubbles since
they cannot guarantee a price bubble has occurred.
d)
All of the above.
arrow_forward
"While the subprime mortgage market crisis triggered the GFC, the real cause was the Clinton administration repealing the Glass Steagall act." State True or False and justify your answer as a short essay answer.
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Economics (MindTap Course List)
Economics
ISBN:9781337617383
Author:Roger A. Arnold
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Related Questions
- SECTION B: ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS Using an appropriate diagram(s), explain the concept of direct and indirect finance. As a student of International Finance and Monetary Policy, explain the monetary policy approach the Central Bank should take when it wants to increase the GDP. Offer the tools that are available and the consequences, if any. Explain the theory of money demand and its relation to inflation in the economy. Use an appropriate equation to demonstrate this. Explain the concept of moral hazard in relation to financial systems.arrow_forwardMonetary policy For the first time since 2006, the Federal Reserve voted to raise interest rates by a one-quarter percentage point in December 2015. Prior to this increase, interest rates had remained between the 0.00% - 0.25% range, an area called “the zero lower bound.” The Federal Reserve had driven interest rates down that low as a means of helping the economy get back on its feet after the Financial Crisis. The reasoning was that consumers and businesses needed access to loans so that production could turn around. (Consumers take out loans to buy high price items like cars and homes. Businesses use loans as a means of expanding their business. In both instance, more goods will be produced.) The increase in 2015 moved rates to the 0.25% - 0.50% range. As of October 2018, interest rates have moved to 1.00% - 1.25% range. For this discussion board, I want you to do some research into the “Financial Crisis.” Why did it occur? Can you characterize the behavior of the…arrow_forwardThere is a growing concern among tax payers that ‘too big to fail’ (TBTF) creates moral hazard problems and leads to excessive risk-taking and reckless investment decisions by large financial institutions. This unfortunately exposes the tax payer and the economic system to excessive cost. What are the issues surrounding “too big to fail”? Is it possible for the legislative authority to simply “outlaw” TBTF institutions? Why or why not?arrow_forward
- From an economics standpoint, the main benefit of a healthy banking industry is the fact that banks themselves make a tremendous profit, allowing the owners of banks as well as their employees to have high incomes. banks force entrepreneurs to pay high interest rates, which contributes to solving the problem of wealth inequality. banks are able to minimize asymmetric information and adverse selection problems, which allows them to transfer idle funds to more productive ends in a cost-efficient manner. private banks help keep inflation under control.arrow_forwardHow are monetary and fiscal government policies being affected by this corona virus pandemic ? And give examplesarrow_forwardBelow are given two cases showing the relationship between leverage growth and total assets growth drawn from the U.S. flow of funds data over the period 1963- 2006. Identify these two cases among the following alternatives: (1) households (2) non-financial, non-farm corporates (3) commercial banks (4) security brokers and dealers giving reasons for these relationships (negative, positive or no relationships) in both cases.arrow_forward
- In the 2017 UN working paper entitled "On the Role of Central Banks in Enhancing Green Finance," the UN stated that central banks would have what kind of role in addressing environmental concerns? Central banks would need to develop sustainability targets and governments would create new policy tools to meet those targets. Central banks would need to develop sustainability targets and create new policy tools to meet those targets Central banks would need to develop sustainability targets as their new primary goal. Central banks would need to enforce regulations at commercial banks regarding environmental goalsarrow_forwardDefine “financial frictions” in your own termsarrow_forwardTo support economic growth, the Indonesian government is committed to making the Islamic economy a source of national economic growth, one of which is through Islamic banking. In general, the form of a sharia bank business consists of a Commercial Bank and a Sharia Rural Bank, with a number of main differences. Banks are basically entities that collect funds from the public in the form of financing or in other words carry out the function of financial intermediation. There are a number of differences between Islamic Commercial Banks and BPRS. Explain what you know the differences in the bank!arrow_forward
- What were the two previous central banks the United States had before the current Federal Reserve system? When was the Federal Reserve established? How old are some other central banks in other countries? Describe in detail how the Federal Reserve is structured and explain how it is mostly independent from political interference? Using ideas like supply and demand, explain how the Federal Reserve uses open-market operations to either raise or lower interest rates at the direction of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC). See if you can find what the most recent decision made by the FOMC was concerning interest rates and explain how that will be reflected in its open-market operations.arrow_forwardWhich of the following is a difference between "quantitative easing" and ordinary open-market operations? Multiple Choice O There is no difference between the two policy tools. Open-market operations are focused exclusively on U.S. government bonds; quantitative easing also includes the buying and selling of debt issued by government agencies and government-sponsored entities. Quantitative easing is done in order to lower interest rates; open-market operations are merely intended to increase bank reserves Open-market operations involve forward commitment, quantitative easing is intentionally vague to maintain flexibilityarrow_forwardIn 2007-2009, The US experienced a serious housing and financial crisis that took almost 10 years to recover. In the first discussion forum, we will discuss the following questions. 1. What is a bank run? What is the purpose of the Glass-Steagall legislation?arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Economics (MindTap Course List)EconomicsISBN:9781337617383Author:Roger A. ArnoldPublisher:Cengage Learning
Economics (MindTap Course List)
Economics
ISBN:9781337617383
Author:Roger A. Arnold
Publisher:Cengage Learning