Sample PS Analysis

.docx

School

Pennsylvania State University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

Subject

English

Date

Apr 3, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

Uploaded by CountUniverse24933

ESL 15 Sample PS Analysis Problem-Solution Argumentative Research Paper Analysis This Sample Analysis serves as your last Reading Response of the semester. Mark your responses in blue . No late work will be accepted. You may work on your own or with one peer of your choice. In the latter case, only one peer should submit the document. Put your name and your peer’s name on this document. Your grades will be the same in the case of group work. Name: VEDANT AGARWAL A. Addressing the Required Components on the Assignment Sheet Read the Sample Paper and the Module 3-Part Three Task Overview, Deadlines, and Requirements Page. Has the Sample Paper addressed all the requirements? B. Topic and Argument 1. In your own words, what’s the author’s argument (Thesis Statement)? The claim made by the author, or thesis statement, is that music therapy works best in treating teenage mental health issues in the United States. In contrast to traditional medicine and physical exercise, music therapy has been shown to have positive impacts on patients' emotions and behaviors. The essay provides evidence and justification for this assertion, arguing that music therapy is a more practical and

ESL 15 Sample PS Analysis adaptable kind of treatment. 2. Do you think that this argument is clear and convincing enough? In other words, are you convinced by it? Why or why not? The essay makes a strong case for music therapy as a successful treatment for teen mental health issues, and it does it in a fairly understandable manner. The author provides examples and relevant research findings to support her claims. However, individual viewpoints and the quality of the evidence offered may have an impact on the overall persuasiveness. To make the argument more compelling overall, it would be helpful to investigate any counterarguments or limitations of music therapy in more detail and respond to them. 3. What is your comment on the overall quality of this argumentative research paper? Be specific. The reasoning seems pretty compelling to me. The author provides evidence of the influence of music therapy on emotions and behaviors, supporting their claim with significant research papers. To improve persuasiveness, the argument could be strengthened even more by addressing any counterarguments or admitting music therapy's limitations. The argumentative research paper is of great overall quality. The essay has a well-defined framework with an introduction, a body, and a conclusion. References to reliable sources support the assertions. The argument is made more understandable by the use of concrete examples and simple language.

ESL 15 Sample PS Analysis 4. If you could provide the author with one comment to better this paper, what would your advice be? In my opinion, to improve the paper's overall quality, a more thorough examination of the opposing views and a little stronger conclusion that highlights the most important issues would be beneficial. Addressing potential objections or admitting the limitations of music therapy could also strengthen the case overall and increase persuasiveness. C. Introduction 1. What is the purpose of introducing the statistics from Moreh and O’lawrence (2016) at the beginning of the paper? The purpose of the paper's introduction, which includes statistics from Moreh and O'lawrence (2016), is to establish the prevalence and significance of mental health problems among American teenagers. The author uses these figures to illustrate how common the problem is, pointing out that 5 percent of people between the ages of 9 and 17 meet the criteria for major depressive disorder, and that 10 to 15 percent of young adults may experience depression at any given time. This statistical basis establishes the topic's importance and urgency, laying the groundwork for the discussion of potential solutions that follows.

ESL 15 Sample PS Analysis 2. Do you think that this purpose has been accomplished successfully? Why or why not? Indeed, the goal of presenting the data from Moreh and O'lawrence (2016) has been effectively achieved. The data persuasively illustrates the seriousness and prevalence of mental health issues among American youth, setting the stage for the discussion of potential remedies that follows. The author effectively conveys the importance and urgency of the problem by drawing attention to the high number of young adults who suffer from depression, which raises the research paper's relevance. This statistical basis draws the reader in and lays the groundwork for an argument that is persuasive enough to support music therapy as the best course of action. Overall, the introduction successfully accomplishes its goal of presenting the topic of teenage mental health issues in a way that highlights the demand for workable solutions. 3. What is the purpose of the paragraph that begins with “In this research paper”? The beginning of the paragraph "In this research paper" outlines the essay's focus and organization. It gives the reader a road map by outlining the main topics that will be discussed. The author states that they will discuss the causes and consequences of mental health issues in American teenagers, assess different approaches, and then make the case that, according to their research, music therapy is the most successful approach. As a guide, this paragraph explains to readers what to expect in terms of content and argumentation as well as the paper's scope. It establishes a precise framework for the sections that follow, allowing information to flow naturally and supporting the research paper's overall structure.

ESL 15 Sample PS Analysis D. Solutions 1. In your own words, what are the three solutions that the author reviews for dealing with mental problems among teenagers? i) Music Therapy: The author argues that music therapy is the most effective solution. The benefits of music therapy for controlling emotions and behaviors are covered in detail, along with its adaptability as a therapeutic approach. The author provides numerous research studies to back up this solution. ii) Conventional Medicine: The essay provides a brief overview of conventional medicine as a potential treatment for adolescent mental health issues. It states that employing traditional medicine—specifically, prescription drugs—is a typical strategy. The disadvantages of this approach are also discussed, though, including the possibility of unfavorable physical reactions and distractions from regular tasks. iii) Physical Activity: As a potential remedy, physical activity is mentioned in passing in the essay. Its methodology is comparable to that of conventional medicine in that it reports potential benefits objectively while critically assessing its disadvantages. Nevertheless, the excerpt omits a thorough examination of physical activity.

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help