abcdbdij
.pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Bellevue University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
234
Subject
Philosophy
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
Pages
4
Uploaded by BrigadierDanger12223
Philosophers and Kings & Primary Sources
Use the documents provided in class to answer the questions below. Type your answers on the right side of
the table. The box will grow as you add more text. You may not know all the answers to some of the more rote
questions because we may not have addressed it. It's okay to look them up. However, the deeper questions
need to be your own thoughts and words. 6 points each.
Document 1
The Enlightenment also produced new ideas about
society and government. One example of this is
Leviathan
, a book by Englishman Thomas Hobbes
published in the 1600s. What do you know about it
and its importance?
Thoughts on society and its proper governance
underwent substantial changes throughout the
Enlightenment. It sought to supplant conventional
wisdom with a logical analysis of the best type of
government. In the seventeenth century, the concept
of the "divine right of kings" served as a rationale for
the establishment of dominant European kingdoms.
But in "Leviathan," the English philosopher Thomas
Hobbes made the case for "absolute monarchy" as
the only reasonable outcome of a perfectly rational
interpretation of human nature and natural rights.
Hobbes believed that in order to protect people's
rights and property, there had to be an all-powerful
state because humanity was inherently violent and
chaotic.
Leviathan
backs the idea generally of an
all-powerful ruler as the head of any government.
How do the details of this book’s cover reveal this
point of view?
In terms of the book cover for "Leviathan," it
graphically represents this viewpoint with an
arresting picture of a Leviathan, signifying the
necessity of a powerful and authoritative government
to regulate and control the innate aggressiveness and
self-interest present in human nature.
In the 1600s, many European monarchs were
increasing their power. They often claimed a right
to rule by “divine right.” What did this term mean?
Monarchs in Europe who asserted the "divine right"
in the 1600s felt that their power to rule was
mandated by God, giving their reign religious
justification.
But Hobbes did not base his views on religious
ideas such as the “divine right of kings.” He based
them, he believed, on reason alone. That is, his
reason told him human nature is basically selfish
and aggressive. Therefore, only an all-powerful
ruler can protect men’s rights and security. Do you
think this view is logical based solely on “reason”?
Why or why not?
Thomas Hobbes rejected theological foundations,
such as "divine right of kings," and based his beliefs
only on reason. He felt that human nature was
intrinsically selfish and aggressive. As a result, he
contended that an all-powerful ruler was required to
preserve individuals' rights and security. It is
debatable if this viewpoint is reasonable and based
exclusively on reason. Hobbes' viewpoint is logical in
its premise that a strong central authority can avert
the chaos that can result from human selfishness and
hostility. However, detractors claim that it
oversimplifies human nature and ignores the
possibility of such a ruler abusing power.
D0cument 2
Enlightenment ideas soon became popular with
many aristocrats and other wealthy people, as well
as several kings and queens. Illustration 2A shows
Prussia
one such king, Frederick II (or Frederick the
Great), in his library with a friend. What nation did
Frederick lead? (country name only)
Monarchs such as Frederick came to be called
“enlightened despots.” Can you name others who
were given this title? Why do you think
Enlightenment ideas appealed to such monarchs?
Other prominent recipients of this title are Joseph II
of Austria and Catherine the Great of Russia. These
kings were drawn to enlightenment principles
because they thought they would solidify their
authority and bring their countries up to date.
Aristocrats came to respect certain philosophes, a
group of powerful Enlightenment intellectuals who
were frequently courted by kings.
In Illustration 2B, what appears to be happening?
Several aristocrats have gathered specifically to
discuss Enlightenment ideas. What were these
gatherings called? Sometimes key thinkers like
Voltaire, called philosophes, would be invited to
such gatherings. Who were some other
philosophes? How do both illustrations make clear
who Enlightenment ideas appealed to? Some find
this surprising—why? Why do you think so many
wealthy, powerful people were attracted to
Enlightenment ideals?
Illustration 2B shows one such salon. These
assemblies o±ered a forum for the discussion of
ideas, and sometimes prominent intellectuals, known
as philosophers like Voltaire, were invited.
Document 3
Enlightenment thinkers asked many questions
about society. But they rarely agreed on the
answers. John Locke and Jean Jacques Rousseau did
agree that government exists to protect individual
rights. But they di±ered in many ways—as they do
here on the value of representative government.
Explain what “representative government” is and
how the two men di±ered over it.
"Representative government" is a system where
citizens elect individuals to act as their
representatives in decision-making processes,
essentially delegating the authority to make laws and
policies on their behalf. These representatives are
expected to reflect the will and interests of the people
who elected them. The key di±erence between Locke
and Rousseau regarding representative government
lies in their views on how the people's will is best
expressed and protected. Locke saw elected
representatives as a means to safeguard individual
rights and ensure a just and balanced government.
Rousseau, on the other hand, argued for direct
democracy, asserting that true liberty and the
common good could only be achieved through direct
involvement and decision-making by the citizens
themselves.
One of these two men had a huge influence on the
founders of the U.S. government. Which one? Why
do you think America’s founders were influenced
more by him than by the other?
John Locke had a more significant influence on the
founders of the U.S. government compared to
Jean-Jacques Rousseau. This influence can be
attributed to the philosophical alignment of Locke's
ideas with the principles of the American Revolution
and the formation of the United States. Locke's
emphasis on natural rights, property, and the
government's role in protecting individual liberties
closely resonated with the American colonists. His
social contract theory provided a theoretical
framework justifying the American colonies' quest
for independence and the establishment of a
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help