Compare and Contrast the Play “A Doll’s House” To the Movie
Introduction
The play “A Doll's House” by Henrik Ibsen was written in 1879. Joseph Losey and Patrick garland in 1973 used the play to adopt a movie version of the play going by the same name. The cast in the movies depicted the characters in the play as described by Henrik Ibsen. This essay will analyze the similarities and the differences between the play by Henrik Ibsen and the films adopted from the play by Joseph Losey and Patrick garland.
Comparison
The main similarity between the play and the movie is the theme of the role of women in the society especially in marriage. Throughout the different periods of the past generations, pieces of art such as plays and films have
…show more content…
Rank who confesses his love to Nora and Nora herself was portrayed differently in the both the play and the two films. This is because according to Garland's film portrayal of the play; it shows this act to some extent more inelegantly than it was showed in Losey's film, as well as Henrik's imaginative work on the play. This makes one notable difference from what a leader of play will just explain to another person. If one watches these movies they will not be sure which explains the play. Garland's translation of the scene went further in explaining more of what is not in the play. I believe that the movie settler of this Film Company wanted to explain further of what would have happened in the play. Watching this play in a movie sometimes makes me feel humiliated for the Dr. Rank, the reason being he was so straight and forward. Losey's Film according to my understanding and opinion, in this scene closely followed what is in the play A Doll's House. Dr. Rank was claiming that he was in love with Nora, but it was somehow slightly. Another alteration to note is at the end of the scene between Nora and Torvald. This is the time when the character Torvald found that Nora was dishonest. Henrik Ibsen has the norms reasons of why she had acted differently and why she had to leave Torvald and the children. When one watches the movie by Losey's film the character Nora left Torvald whose is a fiction actor, real name is David Warner and the kids without further
Nora is eager to please her husband by objectifying herself and subjecting herself to his belittlement. As the play progresses, however, the tree falls into disrepair, reflecting Nora’s abandonment of preserving the façade in favor of gaining her freedom.The image of the masquerade costumes is also used by the author to reflect Nora’s faith on the control from social norms.
Although Nora is secretive about the crime she committed, which is forging her father’s name in order to borrow money; she does it to save her husband. During Act I when Nora is speaking to Mrs. Linde about someday revealing to Torvald about the secret loan Nora exclaims: “One day I might, yes. Many years from now, when I’ve lost my looks a little. Don’t laugh. I mean, of course, a time will come when Torvald is not as devoted to me, not quite so happy when I dance for him, and dress for him, and play with him.” (Act I, pg. 12). This quotation shows that even early on in the play Nora understands the reality of her marriage, and her existence to Torvald. Therefore, Act I is merely an introduction to the overall overarching theme of independence. Act I shows the obedient side of Nora, until later scenes when she reveals her independence. Torvald attempts to oppress his wife, but his actions do not stop Nora’s independent thoughts from forming.
The similarities between the play and the movie are both show the struggles of being a lower class in an upper-class world (at the time). The movie expresses
In the play, when Nora speaks to her children as if they were dolls, it represents the child side of Nora. Nora is being treated as Torvald’s doll; therefore she treats the children in a similar way. During the movie, without Nora talking to her children this way, it takes away from the child side of her. For example, when Nora is talking to her children she says, “My sweet little dolly! What? Shall we play a game? What shall we play at? Hide-and-seek? Yes, let’s play hide-and-seek.” (Ibsen 1078). When Nora speaks to her children this way it sounds like she is really talking to dolls instead of her own children. During the movie, the audience loses this side of Nora and a certain connection with her as
Henrik Ibsen’s “A Doll’s House” is a controversial play focusing on the marriage of Nora and Torvald Helmer. The play is filled with symbols that represent abstract ideas and concepts. These symbols effectively illustrate the inner conflicts that are going on between the characters. Henrik Ibsen’s use of symbolism such as the Christmas tree, the locked mailbox, the Tarantella, Dr. Rank’s calling cards, and the letters allows him to give a powerful portrayal to symbolize aspects of characters and their relationship to each other.
A Doll’s House, by Henrik Ibsen, creates a peephole into the lives of a family in the Victorian Era. The play portrays a female viewpoint in a male-dominated society. The values of the society are described using the actions of a woman, Nora, who rebels against the injustices inflicted upon her gender. Women’s equality with men was not recognized by society in the late 1800’s. Rather, a woman was considered a doll, a child, and a servant. Nora’s alienation reveals society’s assumptions and values about gender.
The production of any theatrical performance is an assembly of creativity, interpretation, and collaboration. Typically, the task of imagining and guiding the integration of all these elements belongs to the director. One of the toughest tasks of a director is to reinvigorate a socially important and renowned production while maintaining its original message and composition. Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll House is a socially important realistic play that portrays the gender dynamics that plagued the nineteenth century and questions the expectations held for women in a household and society. The play is still incredibly influential because the issues it addresses are still prevalent decades later. The original play is so accredited and well known that directors face a tough challenge of trying to reconstruct it in a memorable way. One director, Lee Breuer, attempted to do so in his Mabou Mines DollHouse production. In agreement with Elinor Fuchs’ review, through creative directorial decisions on setting, casting, and music, Breuer uniquely reignited the fire in Ibsen’s play without drifting from the original message.
Ibsen's drama "A Doll's House", serves as an example of the kind of issue-based drama that distinguishes Ibsen from many of his contemporaries. The play's dialogue is not poetic, but very naturalistic, and the characters are recognizable people. Given the sense of modernity which the play possesses it seems unusual to compare it to a Greek tragedy produced more than two-thousand years previously.
Cracknell’s portrayal of Nora in the play is one of the clearest portrayals of betrayal. The role of her character and her interactions with other characters gives the audience an insight to what her character is like. Nora’s close relationship with Doctor Rank is shown multiple times through the show, such as this scene in act 2. Nora and Doctor Rank are left alone in the loungeroom, initially they speak about his declining health and then progress to flirting with each other. Nora passes him her new stockings, which is soon followed by Doctor Rank confessing his love for Nora. This interaction between the two alone clearly shows the betrayal that Nora has committed on her husband as she
In his play, 'A Doll?s House,' Henrik Ibsen shows a marriage built only on appearances, and not love. Both Nora the wife, and Torvald the husband, pretend they are in love throughout the story. However, love should be patient and kind, and their love is anything but that. Nora treats her husband as a father figure. Her feelings towards Torvald are more about dependence than love. Torvald treats Nora like a child or a pet. He gets very angry and frustrated with Nora, and he does not truly love her. True love is perfect, not angry, controlling, and dependent as Nora and Torvald are to each other.
In preparation for Nora's dance at the party, we again see Ibsen showing us Torvald's and Nora's roles. "I can't get anywhere without your help."(Ibsen 91) "Direct me. Teach me, the way you always have."(Ibsen 91) Nora's lines reflect the "costume" that Torvald expects her to wear (and which she wears obligingly), that of the meek, subservient, childlike wife.
The character of Nora goes through the dramatic transformation of a kind and loving housewife, to a desperate and bewildered woman, whom will ultimately leave her husband and everything she has known. Ibsen uses both the characters of Torvald and Nora to represent the tones and beliefs of 19th century society. By doing this, Ibsen effectively creates a dramatic argument that continues to this day; that of feminism.
In Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll House, the play is framed around symbolism and its irony.
In “A Doll House” by Henrik Ibsen was created during 1800s time period. This play helps shine a light on the gender roles of the 1800s while also creating a twist that was uncommon for this period. During this time period, women were left home to oversee the domestic duties, while men went to commuted to work (Hughes). Men were seen as physically superior but morally inferior to women; which is also portrayed within this book (Hughes). This play marks the beginning of Henrik Ibsen’s realist period, which he explored the ordinary lives of small-town people (Kirszner and Mandell 881). This “modern tragedy” helped make Ibsen famous internationally because of the real-life story it captured (Kirszner and Mandell 882). Henrik Ibsen uses an array of literary devices to help keep the reader captivated from beginning to end. Three of the most prominent literary devices used by Henrik Ibsen are symbolism, foreshadowing, and an array of themes. These literary devices help transform a basic play into a complex story of lies and deception.
It is human nature that when first meeting someone that you remain cautious or reserved. It is not until you are comfortable with that new person until your guard comes down and you really get to know someone. After becoming friends, a person will usually let you in on some secrets or stories of their past but when a person feels threaten the first defense is to lie. In Henrik Ibsen’s play “A doll’s House” we learn all about Mrs. Nora Helmer. As the play begins she is looking forward to Christmas with her family but with money being tight she looks for a way to “help” the family with finances only to end up in a bigger mess. Nora finds out that secrets and lies shape a person into who they are and affect how they are treated.