preview

A Prayer For Owen Meany Analysis

Decent Essays
Open Document

In the pages of the bible one can find an early answer to an ancient debate. Jesus appears before Thomas whom had doubted Jesus’s existence and says, “Because you have seen me, have you believed? Blessed are they who do not see, and yet believed.”(John 20:29). Jesus reveres those who were able to accept his existence without proof, while scorning Thomas for his doubt. The struggle between belief and doubt is seen throughout the course of history. The novel A Prayer For Owen Meany by John Irving also attempts to address the battle between these seemingly mutually exclusive principles. The novel centers around a boy named Owen Meany, who believes his future is predetermined for him by God. The protagonist is a man named John Wheelwright, who …show more content…

After Owen kills his best friend’s mother he is only able to move on with his life by coming to believe that God had chosen to kill Tabitha Wheelwright and had used Owen as his instrument. It is from this point on that Owen chooses to put his life in God’s hands. Owen recalls the event to John saying, “"GOD HAS TAKEN YOUR MOTHER. MY HANDS WERE THE INSTRUMENT. GOD HAS TAKEN MY HANDS. I AM GOD'S INSTRUMENT." (Irving 198). Whilst playing the ghost of Christmas future in a Gravesend town production, Owen witnesses his own name on a tombstone accompanied by the exact date of his death. In addition to this haunting image, Owen is also subject to a reoccurring dream in which he is the savior to a group of young Vietnamese children. He tells his friends and family about the vision and his dream and deems that the prophetic events cannot be a coincidence. He then dedicates his life to assuring that he will be prepared for when God calls on him. He turns down scholarships to Ivy League schools and chooses to go to the state university instead because it will help him to train for his death. After choosing to go to the state university, Owen fails to continue his path of academic excellence and only does well in classes related to the military. He even lies his way into the army with the hopes of getting deployed to Vietnam which he believes to be the site of his dream. By having Owen die …show more content…

However, unlike Owen her death turns John away from God and the world of faith. John is angry with Owen for thinking that his mother’s death is God’s will. Likewise, John is mad at God for taking his mother away from him at such a young age. John decides that Owen’s faith is just a way for Owen to alleviate his guilt, and can’t believe that Owen thinks that God would want his mother to die. John is able to watch the entirety of Owen’s brief life unfold before him. However skeptical John is of Owen’s faith, seeing that Owen was right about his death turns John into a believer. John even feels Owen’s religious presence after his death, when he is “saved” by what is seemingly Owen’s ghost when in the cellar. John does finally does appreciate the miracle that is Owen Meany’s life, and realizes that his disbelief was unwarranted. Irving’s position on the debate of belief vs. doubt is made clear in the first sentence of the book when John says, “he is the reason I believe in God; I am a Christian because of Owen Meany.” (Irving 1). John struggles to find the faith that Owen possesses, and his life suffers because of it. However, while John looks back at the events of his youth and recalls Owen’s relationship with God he is able to find the spiritual peace that eluded him. Irving uses John’s initial doubt and eventual conversion to show that although it may be easier to doubt

Get Access