preview

A Secret Lost In The Water Figurative Language

Decent Essays

Synthesis Essay Emma The short story “A Secret Lost in the Water” by Roch Carrier and the poem “My Father Is a Simple Man” by Luis Omar Salinas both explores the relationship between their fathers and examines the theme of the differences between generations. “A Secret Lost in the Water” examines more about the narrator’s regret to losing the traditional skills and knowledge in the modern society. Conversely, the poem “My Father Is a Simple Man” explores the gratitude felt by young generations towards their parents. Figurative language played an important role in both of the story and poem. As shown above, both of the pome and short story used the first person point of view. There are many symbolisms …show more content…

“Water” in the title symbolized the flow of time, the filming of the documentary symbolized the process of how the world changed. The alder branch was the most important symbol to the whole story. Narrator used “Pious care” to describe the process of his father to choose the branch to find the water. “Pious care” is a kind of religious words, the narrator used religious word to portrayed the father’s faith, the faith though centuries, and wanted to deliver that faith to his son as well. The alder branch represented the thing connect the father and son generations. This is shown by the quote, “’You see,’ he said, ‘the branch has two arms. Now take one in each hand. And squeeze them’” (Carrier 1). The alder branch had two arms, father hold one and son hold one, that connected father and son together, inherited the things that may lost and showed the different emotions between generations. However, the narrator didn’t understand what his father was doing at that time, he just wants to focused on …show more content…

Unlike the father in the poem, the father in the short story was dead, so the emotions of the sons were different. The speaker in the poem was really love his father and appreciate his father’s way of living. The excerpt “I can always remember that here was a man who was a worker and provider, who learned the simple facts in life and lived by them, who held no pretense. And when he leaves without benefit of fanfare or applause” (Salinas 28) shown speaker adored and respected his father, he wanted to learn from his father. In the contrast, the narrator in the short story was regret that he lost the gift his father gave to him this is shown by the quote “Somewhere along the roads I’d taken since the village of my childhood I had forgotten my father’s knowledge” (Carrier 3). The narrator regretted his lost of the link which connect his father and he, but there is no way to regain. So the narrator was happy when someone wanted to filming the documentary of the town. The narrator wanted to use modern ways to let next generation to remember the lost

Get Access