The similarity between the film and the story is that when Victor died and when Thomas try to help him out with money. Victor dad died and he couldn't go to Arizona and his childhood friend Thomas is trying to help him out with financial but asked him to take him with him. The second similarity between the short story and the movie is when Thomas went to the fall and while he while sitting there Thomas dad got him and took him to deenyś and buy him food then drop him to his house. The third similarity
night lighter. This same fire claimed the lives of Thomas’s parents and would have even claimed the life of Thomas, if Victor’s father had not been present. An intense scene like this can snatch a viewer’s attention with ease. The film, Smoke Signals, used this exact scene to great effect. The short story “This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona” by Sherman Alexie tells a similar story with some major differences. Even though both the movie and book follow a similar plot, the movie is far superior
used short stories in order to have their prophecies and outlooks heard. In Liam O’Flaherty’s “The Sniper” and Theodore L. Thomas’s “The Test”, both short stories comment on certain social issues through the description of their settings; however, each author does so using different forms of reality. This essay will examine how both short stories accomplish the inclusion of their criticisms of their current social realities. This inclusion will be examined with a comparison of the short stories’ themes
In the story This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona by Sherman Alexie readers follow the characters Victor and Thomas as they travel to claim the ashes of Victors deceased father. The trip will take them from their Native American reservation in Washington state to Arizona. This trip is long and with Thomas the Story Teller it’s even longer. Life on the reservation is hard due to all the poverty, alcoholism and other problems that modern Native Americans face. This trip is a way for the two
Alexie’s short story” This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” describes the journey of Victor to retrieve his father’s ashes in Arizona. Accompanying Victor on his heart filled journey, will be Thomas Builds-the-Fire. Thomas only agrees to help Victor because of a promise he made to Victor’s father at the age of thirteen. Despite the rocky relationship they’ve had in the past, the short story provides cultural context of how Native Americans can be greatly affected by poverty. Alexie’s story supports
down throughout history. In the short story “This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” the narrator explains how Thomas Builds-the-Fire’s story’s are needed but not appreciated. Through a maim revelation Thomas understands the importance of storytelling. Conflicts between the community and the the main characters are present through the story. Before explaining this story and its meaning, the theme must be recognized. First to say, the theme of this story is a little bit tricky to completely
Through the course we read and learned many different types of literature such as poems, short stories, play, and also novels. Literature restores the past, stimulates the imagination, glorifies the commonplace, evokes emotions and links feeling to thinking, upholds a vision of the ideal and reveals human nature by exploring significant human questions. Literature can defined in many different ways and has grown and changed throughout time. Every type of literature writing has a theme associated
Sherman Alexie is a Native American short story author who really puts what it is like to be a Native American into perspective. Alexie wrote the short story “What it means to say Phoenix, Arizona”, which eventually became a film called “Smoke Signals”, both these stories tell the same story but have some major similarities and differences. The theme of prejudice towards Native Americans and the struggles the race deals with on a daily basis. Sherman Alexie’s other story “War Dances” tell the same struggles
Washington, as he goes to Phoenix, Arizona to claim his father’s remains and his savings account. While on this journey, Victor learns about himself, his father, and his Indian culture with the help of his estranged friend, Thomas Builds-the–Fire. The author, Sherman Alexie, plays on the stereotypes of Native Americans through the characters of Victor and Thomas. While Thomas is portrayed as the more traditional and “good” Native American, Victor comes across as the “bad” Native American. Through the use
There are many different types of stories being read or told in the world: some can be enjoyable, boring and even unrealistic. For example, in the film, Smoke, directed by Wayne Wong, and the short story, “Auggie Wren’s Christmas Story,” directed by Paul Auster, Paul a character in both the film and short story begins telling a story a wager between Sir Walter and Queen Elizabeth I. The wager, between both, was about “the weight of Smoke” (Wayne) and how it can be calculated. Although, Paul had his