(REFEREED RESEARCH) A SUPPLIER SELECTION, EVALUATION AND RE-EVALUATION MODEL FOR TEXTILE RETAIL ORGANIZATIONS TEKSTİL PERAKENDE ORGANİZASYONLARINA YÖNELİK TEDARİKÇİ SEÇİM, DEĞERLENDİRME VE YENİDEN DEĞERLENDİRME MODELİ Aşkıner GÜNGÖR Pamukkale University Industrial Engineering Department e-mail: askiner@pau.edu.tr Semih COŞKUN Pamukkale University Industrial Engineering Department Güngör DURUR Pamukkale University Textile Engineering Department Hacer GÜNER GÖREN Pamukkale University Industrial Engineering Department ABSTRACT In general, supplier selection is a multi-criteria decision problem that contains tangible and intangible factors. This paper identifies and organizes these factors into a three-phase …show more content…
Since 1980s, some Turkish domestic firms especially located in the cities such as 181 Denizli, Bursa, Gaziantep, Kahramanmaraş, Kayseri in the home textile industry have found ways of connecting themselves to the global webs of manufacturing, distribution, and retailing of garments. Tokatli (2) stated two related developments that have occurred during the process. First, a number of manufacturing firms have acquired enough capability to develop and exercise their own strategies, have upgraded their operations, and, as original brandname manufacturers, have evolved into global competitors. Second, some large domestic manufacturers, which are the logistic partners of the global retailers, have also experienced a cautious and gradual transformation from industrial capital to commercial and financial capital. Overall, these aspects of textile industry, to be the selected one is still the most important management scope for all parts: Being a selected retailer by the customers, being a selected producer or distributer by retailers, being a selected raw materials supplier for producers in the global industry chain (3). This study focuses on the issue of “how to identify the best supplier”. The answer to this question provides some very valuable information to both manufacturers and retailers. This paper aims to find a practical answer to this question for home textiles sector.
In the case “Metalcraft Supplier Scorecard”, the author uses an example of a decision-making problem regarding to which supplier should Metalcraft choose to lead to the topic of the Metalcraft supplier scorecard. Metalcraft, as a component designer and manufacturer, supplies a few largest automobile manufacturers with vehicle parts all over the world. As one of the tier 1 suppliers, Metalcraft offers and ships finished parts and components using in the automobile production process to automakers.
All their suppliers range from small farming cooperatives to multinational corporations . They consider factors such as capacity, quality and cost when selecting companies to buy from. In addition, seek only to work with suppliers that can consistently meet standards and specifications and
The recommendations I would suggest for structuring the supplier relationship process for the Wolf Motors dealership network are Wolf Motors should consider a centralized corporate level Materials Management System to consolidate buying decisions for each of the 4 dealerships. This would facilitate greater leveraging with suppliers for consistent quality-control. They should study, calculate and make effective decisions on the materials that should be brought for each of the four dealerships instead of allowing each dealer to do it on their own. An automated
Second, always make sure there is an alternative source. As I mentioned before, this is much easier with single source procurement (but not sole source), since other similar suppliers could be able to supply similar products with more or less that same quality as the previous suppliers.
{Build the Supply Base: supplier selection1. supplier evaluation- find potential suppliers, supplier certification (qualification, education, certificationISO 9000,14000). 2. Supplier development- integrate supplier in system, quality require, product specs, schedule/delivery, procurement polices, training, engineer/production help, information transfer procedures. 3. Negotiation- significant element, strategies: Cost based price model (open books to supplier, based on time and materials) Market based price model (based on published, auction, index prices: commodities) Competitive bidding (most common, no longterm relationship, request for rfq). 4. Contracting- share risks, benefits, incentives. Centralized purchasing, E procurement (online catalogs/exchanges, online auctions).} Logistics MGT- obtain efficient operations through integration of all material acquisition, movement, and storage activities. Frequent for outsourcing, allow competitive advantage from reduce costs and improve customer service. 1.Shipping systems: truck(flexible, moves majority manufactured goods) rail( large loads, containers) Airfreight( fast/flexible light loads, expensive) water( used for bulky low value cargo, oldest way of transportation) Pipelines( transport oil, gas,
The supply chain management is considered as a management concept from past two decades as the customers are concerned about timely and safe delivery. The competitiveness has been increasing among the companies to deliver the products as quickly as possible to the customers all around the world. This has made the supply chain management as a vital tool for the management. This is also measured as a competitive parameter for the companies.
In this assignment I will be writing a formal report that will explain a typical procurement process, I will outline a variety of methods of supplier reimbursement and contract relationships; I will also outline the pros and cons of each contract type. As well as this, I will explain a typical supplier selection process through the use of Carters 10 C’s and a typical selection process model.
The three criteria that would apply to most projects include payment terms, on-time delivery performance, and reputation. It is important for a company to use the reputable supplier and the one who it has partnered in past projects. These criteria are essential in the project success because these could
2. What ten criteria might affect your selection of resource suppliers and your plans for
Various important approaches like engineering driven approaches and selection of supplier processes lead to the number of suppliers at premium prices. It reduces cost of
It is quite challenging to discuss about procurement management without stating the importance of its strategies. There are four main basic procurement strategies that serve different functions within a procurement management. To begin with, a “Partnership” strategy focuses mainly on constructing mutual commitment in long term relationship with suppliers. While a “Secure Supply” strategy aims to secure short and long term supply while reducing risk from suppliers. In addition, a “Category Management and E-Procurement solutions” serves as a tool to reduce logistic complexity, improve operational efficiency, and attempts to reduce the number of suppliers. Lastly, a “Competive Bidding” strategy emphasizes on obtaining the “Best Deal” for short term transactions with suppliers.(van weele) Each of these four strategies involves a unique purchasing methodology, which implies that the complexity is embedded in an individual strategic implication. Therefore, it requires different tools to accomplish the specific strategical characteristics. A business entity may need to support and execute procurement decisions with other strategic apparatus with analytical methods, including market analysis, uncertainty analysis, price forecasting, supplier relationship and along with others.(Harvard)
Blanchard (2009), “successful supplier relationships require two-way information, recommendations, metrics and incentives. Riordan Manufacturing must understand the cost and value of their entire supply chain. Without a detailed understanding of all costs, from raw materials through the end product or service, and the value provided by its supplier in the process, a supplier cannot be evaluated. Therefore, there are several things Riordan Manufacturing can do to improve their relationship with it suppliers. They can incorporate appropriate service levels and metrics into agreement, share critical information as early as possible, plan for major contingencies, expect and reward honesty and finally, make relationship meetings meaningful” (10 Strategies for Managing Suppliers).
Once you have figured out what type of supplier you need, it is time to source the right supplier within that category.
The primary objective for every enterprise is to maximise profit. According to the accounting equation, profit is obtained by subtracting expenses from the revenue. Thus, the analysis of power of supplier is essential as it directly influences the level of expense that a corporation faces. To understand the power of supplier, it is a good approach to first learning the components that manufacture the product sold, and then studying the market structure of each component as the prices are largely influenced by market structure.
It is known to us, “in each industry, the customer is god, is operator's food and clothing parents.” This tells us that customers are important to organizations. With the current intense competition in logistics nowadays, most companies can provide high quality goods, even are willing to cut down prices if reasonable. However, how can suppliers gain a competitive advantage when high quality is expected and price must be maintained at a level to generate a reasonable return? In our views, it is no doubt that how various supplier service activities are valued by customers, more specifically, that is, the ability of logistics