preview

African Adolescents: A Brief Summary

Better Essays
Open Document

Introduction Abdelmalek Bayout was an Algerian citizen living in Italy since the early 90’s. In 2007, he pled guilty to the first degree murder of Walter Felipe Novoa Perez, who had insulted him for the kohl eye make-up (worn for religious reasons) the Algerian had on. Bayout’s lawyer in turn filed an insanity plea, which resulted in a series of psychiatric tests and a final reduction in the sentence from twelve to nine years. However, two years later, an interesting turn of events lead to a further reduction in sentencing . Using brain imaging scans, a group of Italian researchers led by Pietro Pietrini were able to label several genes linked to violent behaviours—including a gene encoding a neurotransmitter-metabolizing enzyme: monoamine …show more content…

Does the fact that a disproportionate amount of African American youths come from a lower socioeconomic status have any bearing on the racial implications of the study? Consider that 67 percent of African American children grow up in single parent families, how would this contribute to a predisposition to violence ? Perhaps they are more likely to be involved in violent behaviors and risk taking as a means of survival. Would this mean that African American males should be tried differently in court proceedings, and if so, who could be considered an African American? In his book The Spirit Level: Why Greater Equality Makes Societies Stronger, Richard Wilkinson assesses the incidence of income inequality of the world’s 23 richest nations and its implications for homicides, anxiety, life expectancy, teenage pregnancies, social mobility and higher rates of imprisonment. He notes that in the USA, the income discrepancy between the upper and lower class (predominantly in states with higher African American populations) is the highest compared to other developed countries such as Sweden and Japan (which have the smallest income gap between their upper and lower classes, and, consequently the happiest populations). A 1990’s study of 282 metropolitan areas in the USA found that a greater income gap was directly correlated with higher rates of crime, suicides, high school …show more content…

It is a controversial topic which yields disagreement not just in terms of the science, but also in terms of the social, legal and therapeutic implications. Given the evidence, it would seem that possessing any of the variants for MAOA-L in tandem with any exposure to childhood trauma and abuse as forensic psychiatrist William Bernet states “increases one’s chances of being convicted of a violent offense by more than 400 percent” . My belief is that in the case of violent crime—genes, childhood traumas, and low socioeconomic status are a dangerous cocktail. While race does seem to play a role in the incidence of criminality, I would reserve judgment to base it solely on genetics despite the studies noted, solely because there are many other factors to consider. If race was an acceptable alibi for violent crime, it would propose mixed strategies in terms of corrections i.e. if the defendant is of African ancestry, how his particular genotype relates to his personal behavior. To date there exist several treatments for MAOA-L, including Pregnenolone which converts to progesterone—which acts to increase MAO (figure 2) , as well as estrogen, which reduces aggression . In my opinion, just as an individual does not choose to be abused as a child, he doesn’t choose to have a particular gene in his genetic makeup, and in

Get Access