Alienation is a concept that describes an isolated and separated circumstance in the workplace. Browne (2011:380) notes “Alienation is the condition where workers have no job satisfaction or fulfillment from their work”. Alienation could cause some severe consequences. In 2010, thirteen employees, who worked for a Chinese company—Foxconn, committed suicided. (BBC) In this case, it is possible that the suicide event is due to that Foxconn is the assembly line of Apple, which means it is technology employed. Mitra (2010:11) points out that as the technology becomes more sophisticated, the level of alienation, which results from technology, becomes higher. The main purpose of this essay is to examine how far the complexity of the technology …show more content…
The data of questionnaire showed that printers had a low level of alienation, which means they were satisfied with their jobs and were non-alienated workers. (Haralambos, 2004) This might be due to that printing—craft, needed a high level of skill by using hand, and abilities of creativity and judgment. Thus, printers had the sense of responsibility of the whole process of the production. (Browne, 2011) Moreover, printers could move around and talk to others when they are working, which means they had not undergone self-estrangement from their work. (Haralambos, 2004) The second industry to be analysed was textiles—machine-tending industry. The data indicated that the level of alienation was much higher than printing industry. It seems due to the technology that was applied in the textiles industry. The degree of powerlessness, social isolation and self-estrangement were high, because there were supervisors to control and manage them. The level of meaninglessness also was high, because the workers were not taking part in all of the process of the production. However, the textile workers always had a close-knit relationship with each other. This might because they lived together or had same religion. (Haralambos, 2004) The workers of the cars—assembly-line production got the highest degree of alienation. This mainly due to the fact that the environment of the workplace was extremely isolated, separated and supervised. Thus, the level of powerlessness, social
According to Karl Marx, alienation is the transformation of individual`s own labor into a power that rules by supra-human laws. In his theory he believed that alienation brought distinction of substances that were harmoniously put together. It brought social divisions of people from the aspect of their “human nature’’ which referred to the range of behavior shared by all human beings. Under capitalism, origin of alienation is commodity fetishism. Marx highlights four calibers of alienation in labor. The worker was alienated from the work he produced. The manner in which something was produced was not by its actual producer nor by its consumers but by capitalist class. It is the capitalist class who appropriated labor and endeavored to determine consumer’s taste for him to maximize profits.
In the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Karl Marx identifies a dichotomy that is created and bolstered by the capitalist mode of production. In this mode of production, the dichotomy presents itself in a division of labor that forms of two kinds of people: capitalists, the owners of the means of production, and laborers, those who work under the domain of the capitalist. Marx harshly criticizes this mode of production, arguing that it exploits the laborer and estranges him from himself and his fellow man. According to Marx, this large-scale estrangement is achieved through a causal chain of effects that results in multiple types of alienation, each contingent upon the other. First, Marx asserts that under capitalism, the laborer is alienated from his product of labor. Second, because of this alienation from his product, man is also alienated then from the act of production. Third, man, in being alienated both from his product and act of production, is alienated from his species essence, which Marx believes to be the ability to create and build up an objective world. Finally, after this series of alienations, Marx arrives at his grand conclusion that capitalist labor causes man to be alienated from his fellow man. In this paper, I will argue in support of Marx’s chain of alienations, arriving at the conclusion that laborers, under the capitalist mode of production, cannot retain their species essence and thus cannot connect with one another, and exist in a world
There are also varying degrees of alienation depending on the particular work environment. Some workers subject to particular tasks may feel 'distant' from their co-workers. Without this sense of belonging, these workers let their work related alienation penetrate their personal spheres which is seen in the struggle they have maintaining personal relationships, as a result of the feelings of isolation that they harbour. This in turn can lead to problems of drug and alcohol abuse, mental illness such as depression and violent behaviour stemming from underdeveloped social interactions. (Macionis: Chapter 4)
Man no longer exercises his essence as a species-being in productive labour for the good of others, but on the contrary, he becomes detached from his essence and the product of his labour is abstracted as a means to produce for the sake of capital. In this sense man becomes reduced to nothing but a machine; the more capital the product of his labour acquires, the more the worker will be encouraged to produce through the influence of wages. The appeal of this profit for the worker sustains his alienated state by further sacrificing his ‘body and spirit’ for the sake of his wages;
One of the greatest economic theorist Karl Marx whose ideas were once used in the Soviet Union and other countries that failed to success makes human beings think of the type of economy that they are living in. Karl Marx was born in 1818 in Trier, Germany. He witnessed the rise of the industrial revolution and the beginning of capitalism. Marx was the strongest capitalist critic who analyzed the ills of the capitalism. Marx wrote lots of books and they were mostly about the capitalism. And Capitalism is one type of economy. The United States is a capitalist country. One of his writings that this paper will focus on is “Alienated Labor” and it talks about different types of Alienation that the workers of capitalism experienced. Alienation
was how workers in capitalism are alienated from their work .It covers 4 forms of
When critically analyzing the some of the themes discussed in the course with respect to my volunteering experience and majority of positions held by the working class. creates an environment of concern such as the feeling of being alienated which is defined as an “estrangement, or separation in feeling or affection; to be alienated is to be withdrawn or cut-off in feeling or affection, to feel separated from others or oneself. “ that slowly builds within the work environment, the reasons is due to lack of job enrichment or more specifically when the job becomes monotonous without much change. For example while volunteering reporting at 8:30am to open the office and start my shift from 9:00am created an atmosphere of enthusiasm which slowly diminished over a period of time as it was the same task I executed for 2 years. This when related to an individual who works in a car factory feels dehumanized and more like a machine when the carry our the same task in a factory of line production. Due to lack of change the employee becomes less productive and hence a cost to the firm therefore ends up being laid-off. Furthermore in a capitalist environment the inability to contribute in decision making and the operation of the firm significantly contributes to the alienation of workers. Creating a more involving firm such as the Body Shop that accepts a more open response from its employees allowing a greater enrichment and growth of employees and the business its self. In addition
Marx’s theory of alienation is concerned primarily with social interaction and production; he believes that we are able to overcome our alienation through human emancipation.
As human beings, one of the most fundamental aspects of our existence, according to philosopher Karl Marx, is the act of work. More specifically, it is the idea that work fulfills human being’s essence. Work, for Marx, is a great source of joy, but only when the worker can see themselves in the work they do, and when said worker wants to partake in the work they are performing. In the capitalist identity, workers are “a class of labourers, who live only so long as they find work, and who find work only so long as their labour increases capital” (Marx and Engel, 1946, pg. 116). Labourers were simply described as “a commodity” (Marx and Engel, 1946, pg. 117) by the ruling class; they are but pieces of a large, intricate gear system, all for the profit of those above them. In this, the worker loses touch with their essence. This concept is referred to, more or less, as alienation. Alienation is a form of separation of how one sees themselves, and how one sees themselves in what they do. Alienation, in many ways, relates to the idea of false consciousness. False consciousness, for Marx, revolves around the idea of misleading society; It is an ideological way of thinking in which no true perception of the world can be achieved. Both alienation and false consciousness delve into the notion of what constitutes true reality. Alienation describes how those that are controlled by the ruling class are subject to a form of disconnect, and false consciousness is a hierarchal idea in
Among four types of alienation that Marx provides; alienation from the product, alienation from labour process, alienation from one another, and alienation from species-being, the first one explains that what the workers made does not actually belong to them but capitalists (Marx, 1932, p. 325, 326). Furthermore, the process of activities of workers are also estranged from them because workers externalize their ability to work, labour power, to the object, but that labour power is controlled by capitalist and exists outside of workers (Marx, 1932, p. 324). As we saw in the movie, those are workers that who spend 10 hours a day at the workplace and devote themselves producing productions; however, those productions end up belonging to capitalists. For example, trains cars, clothes, and those other commodities are made by hands but it is head that who actually uses them. Consequently, in the capitalist society,
Alienation, a term used to describe the feeling of no connection with others or the separation from former attachment. When it comes to sociologist aspect, especially on Marxism, this term describes the stage of losing one’s identity. To Karl Marx’s belief, Alienation means the loss of control over the process and product of work (Bell, 1959). Thus, under the capitalism, workers are alienated by the production system.
The concept of alienation plays a significant role in Marx's early political writing, especially in the Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1848, but it is rarely mentioned in his later works. This implies that while Marx found alienation useful in investigating certain basic aspects of the development of capitalist society, it is less useful in putting forward the predictions of the collapse of capitalism. The aim of this essay is to explain alienation, and show how it fits into the pattern of Marx's thought. It will be concluded that alienation is a useful tool in explaining the affect of capitalism on human existence. In Marx's thought, however, the usefulness of alienation it is limited to explanation. It does not help in
Alienation of literary characters became more popular in the 19th century writings. An era recognized by sudden and unforeseen disruptions with the traditional ways of how people were interacting in society. Individualism became a virtue; where in the past days were downcast. “Karl Marx explained in his study of "alienated" or "estranged labor" that, under the capitalist mode of production, workers are alienated from the products of their labor and from their own labor power (which they sell for a wage), but they are also alienated from their human essence, effectively becoming machines in the mechanical system of production.” (Tally par.4) Today we live in a world that encourages individuals to be who they want to be. However when they do not fit
Topic: One of the essential elements to Marx’s alienation concept is that of people or workers being alienated from each other under capitalism, it is still relevant in explaining the problems of the modern world.
The theory of alienation developed by Karl Marx depicts the estrangement of people due to living in a capitalist system of production. Through the manuscript “Estranged Labor” from his Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Marx describes his theory of alienation and specifies on the four types of ways in which the worker is alienated. A vivid example of Marx’s theory of alienation can be seen through Charlie Chaplin’s comedy film Modern Times. In his film, the central idea of the theory of labor alienation and how the worker is affected by the alienation are depicted. The notion of alienation depicted in Marx’s “Estranged Labor” is also depicted in Chaplin’s Modern Times.