preview

Altruism Vs Altruism

Decent Essays

1. Describe the problem As products of evolution, humans appear to be simply animals. However, we appear to be more than animals because of our complex emotions and intelligence. So people wonder what role our evolutionary history should play in understanding our identity as humans.
2. Present the Positions Edward Wilson argues that biology is the key to understanding human nature. He explains how, as products of evolution, we are simply physical beings and a study of our biology will reveal everything about human nature. Wilson then provides a number of examples of how our biology affects us. For example, he explains how altruism, a trait that seems unintuitive for natural selection, could arise through natural selection by the trait passing through relatives that benefit from the altruism. His argument in standard form is:
If we are products of evolution, then biology is the key to human nature.
We are products of evolution.
Therefore biology is the key to human nature.

Ruth Benedict offers an different view. Benedict argues that culture plays a very important part in human nature. Benedict first explains how culture is not biologically transmitted. Her main evidence that culture is not biologically transmitted is how a …show more content…

Wilson’s first premise appears to be strong because if we are creatures created through biological processes, then studying those processes should reveal human nature. However, Benedict’s argument opposes this by saying that a study of culture will give information on understanding human nature that just biology could not provide. Wilson’s second premise relies on evolution and so does not mesh with beliefs of creationism. Even evolution mixed with creationism, like intelligent design, means that the first premise will not lead to the conclusion because the higher power guiding evolution may have different goals than what results from unmodified natural

Get Access