Introduction
This case study is about competition between American Airlines (AAL) and other airlines, as well as the way AAL behaved in the face of new entries of low cost carriers (LLC) at AAL’s Dallas Fort-Worth (DFW) hub. In this case study, economy of scope produced by a hub, the use of information technology (IT) as a competitive advantage, and the use of loyalty program are discussed. AAL’s use of predatory pricing to drive out existing competitors, its reputation for predation, and the arguments from both sides of the antitrust lawsuits are also studied.
Analysis
Background of American Airlines
American Airlines was founded on April 15, 1926, and grew to become the predominant carrier at the Dallas-Fort Worth (DFW) International
…show more content…
AAL considered them a serious threat to its revenues and decided to counteract the competition through matching prices and increasing capacity (Herb, 2007). Labaton and Zuckerman (1999) added that the low-cost carriers failed to sustain the operations and eventually moved away, after which American resumed its prior marketing strategy of reducing the number of flights and raising its prices to levels comparable to those before the low-fare competition. Over the period 1994-1999, AAL have higher profit margins on routes without Southwest Airlines or LCC competition, as it could raise prices slowly without worrying about competitor reactions.
Economies at the hub. Major airlines acquire and maintain large market shares at their hubs even with higher prices and higher costs than competitors. For example, AAL has a price 31 percent price premium in DFW, a 70 percent share of the non-stop passengers in DFW, and a higher cost per available seat-mile (ASM) due to union contracts. However, they achieve economies of scope and scale that are not captured in the measures of cost per ASM (Edlin, & Farrell, 2002). Economies of scope come flight sharing from passengers flying to another destination beyond the hub, such as from Wichita to Dallas then to Miami.
The Wichita-Dallas flight (known as upline) creates additional traffic and profits on AAL’s Dallas-Miami downline route, and as a result, AAL might sell the Wichita-Dallas at very low
Business Strategy – BAD 4013 – SUMMER 1999 Case Study Southwest Airlines I. Strategic Profile and Case Analysis Purpose The mission of Southwest Airlines is dedication to the highest quality of customer service delivered with a sense of warmth, friendliness, individual pride, and company spirit. Twenty-seven years ago, Rolling King, owner of floundering commuter airline, and Herb Kelleher, King’s lawyer, got together and decided to start a different kind of airline that would provide a short-haul, low-fair, high-frequency, point-to-point service in the United States. The company began service on June 18, 1971 with flights between Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio (“The Golden Triangle” as Herb called it). Southwest Airlines is the fourth
In 2010, Southwest Airlines purchased AirTran Airlines and received all the issues that come along with enormous overnight growth. This came in the form of inconsistent price and seat availability, confusing reward systems, delayed flights and very upset customers (McCartney, 2013). This
In the past three years the airline industry has faced an unparalleled list of challenges and American Airlines has certainly had more than the others. Year by year AA has tried to recover with a great deal of effort to turn the company around. The strategies they are applying to counteract the status are : Lower costs to compete, give to the customers the service they are expecting
American airline industry is steadily growing at an extremely strong rate. This growth comes with a number economic and social advantage. This contributes a great deal to the international inventory. The US airline industry is a major economic aspect in both the outcome on other related industries like tourism and manufacturing of aircraft and its own terms of operation. The airline industry is receiving massive media attention unlike other industries through participating and making of government policies. As Hoffman and Bateson (2011) show the major competitors include Southwest Airlines, Delta Airline, and United Airline.
1. There are a few trends in the US airline industry. One is consolidation, wherein existing players merge in an attempt to lower their costs and generate operating synergies. The most recent major merger was the United Continental merger, which is still an ongoing affair, but has created the largest airline in the United States by market share (Martin, 2012). Another trend is towards low-cost carriers. In the US, Southwest has been a long-running success and JetBlue a strong new competitor, but in other countries this business model has proven exceptionally successful. The third major trend is the upward trend in jet fuel prices, and the increasing importance that this puts on hedging fuel prices and capacity management (Hinton, 2011).
With the majority of American Airlines competitors in domestic industry, it is crucial for them to keep up to date with the latest business strategies their competitors are integrating in to their businesses. Depending on what strategy American Airlines Company decides on, it needs to be differentiated compared to their competitors in order to succeed in this airline industry.
In the opinion of Dr. Grace S. Thomson, “a heterogeneous mix of long and short-haul in very thing segments, passenger, density, and per capita income at end points gives [Southwest Airlines] competitive advantage. The way to establish a company in such a market as the airline industry would be to strategically expand in to airports with less competition. Southwest Airline capitalized on this fact to become a national airline (Keller 2008). Southwest Airlines satisfies what were once negligible markets. Southwest serves “64 cities in 411 non-stop city pairs” (Thompson 2008). Saturating these markets has allowed Southwest Airlines to expand without putting a strain on its pocket book (Keller
American Airlines was form by the acquisition of 80 small airline companies, named American Airway Inc. The first job that this airline had was distributing mail to different parts of the United Stets. In 1934, America Airway Inc. changed their name to American Airlines. With the help of Donald Douglas, America Airlines was able to build the DC-3 airplane, which allowed this company to be first ones to make profit from only transporting passengers, unlike other airlines, who had too transport passengers and mail. In 1942, American Airlines provided international flights to the public. In 1973 Bonnie Tiburzi was hire by American Airlines, which made them the first airline to hire female pilots. In addition, the airline was the first one to
On August 18, 1993, a fare war erupted. To initiate its new service between Cleveland and Baltimore, Southwest announced a $49 fare (a sizeable reduction from the then-standard rate of $300). Its rivals, Continental and US Air, retaliated. Before long, the price was $19, not much more than the tank of gas it would take to drive between the two cities-and the airlines also supplied a free soft drink. Evaluate he implications of such a price war for three airlines. Due to the fact that Southwest was smart in their operation they were able to outwit their rivals. They were able to take the business of their opponents and offering them fares at a valued price. The big airlines could not afford to keep up with the legal battles as they were already losing money from not enough passenger capacity.
When they didn’t, the airline retaliated by offering deep cuts in fares on several routes flown by its competitors. Northwest airline responded with a $198 round-trip fares with connections on routes for which American airline’s average fare was $1,600. American’s response was to offer $99 one way fairs in 10 markets flown by each of the other competitors except that of Continental Airlines which had followed and matched the leader’s (American Airline) original changes in all markets. With respect to the concept of strategic behavior exhibited by firms in an oligopolistic setting, some firms may try to achieve a dominant strategy that yields them better results and do not flip-flop, no matter what strategies other industry participant follow. This was illustrated in the case, when, in 2004, Continental Airlines raised its fares to mitigate rising cost of aviation fuel. Firms in an oligopoly may differ in terms of their cost structure and the airline industry is no exception and participants do exhibit strategies that enable them not to follow price increases driven by aviation fuel cost.
American Airlines had been the largest airline in the United States for a long time. In 1990 and 1991 due to a recession and the Gulf War, demand for air travel dropped drastically, for this reason, fare wars started and all the airlines incurred massive losses.
There have been few inventions to change how people live and experience the world considerably as the creation of the airplane. Today, traveling by air has become the norm and it would be difficult to imagine life without it. Air travel has improved the way people are able to conduct business by shortening travel time and changing their thought of distance. The companies within the airline industry exist in a very competitive market. One of those companies, Southwest Airlines, features low-fare, no-frills air service with frequent flights of mostly short routes. Costs are kept down by the exclusive use of Boeing 737 aircraft, which allows for low maintenance costs and quicker turnaround times for flights, and by an emphasis on ticketless travel (Encyclopedia Britannica). This paper will address two segments of the general environment and how they affect Southwest and the airline industry; evaluate how Southwest has addressed two forces of competition; predict what Southwest might do to improve its ability to addresses these forces; assess the external threats affecting Southwest; discuss Southwest’s greatest strengths and most significant weaknesses; determine Southwest’s resources, capabilities, and core competencies; and analyze their value chain.
The Airline Industry is in an interesting situation. Simply adding a low cost alternative is not enough in the industry. The Internet has made the power of buyers grow with the transparency of ticket prices. This is not something that will change any time soon. Because of this profitability is predominately reserved for low-cost yet distinctive carriers. No consumer wants to ride what they consider a “lesser” airline. Airlines need a way to distinguish themselves from one another while also acknowledging the increased power of buyers.
We 'd think that this would have helped AA but in 2011, they filed bankruptcy. On December 9, 2013, the American Airlines Group was formed. This was a merger between American Airlines and US Airways. This instantly doubled the flights a day and increased the number of airports which gave it an average of about 6,700 flights a day and a little over 300 locations along with adding 968 operated aircraft 's The merger aimed to yield $1.5 billion in terms of added revenue and costs savings a year.
With 1988 operating income of $801 million on a revenue of $8.55 billion, American Airlines, Inc. (American), principal subsidiary of Dallas/Fort Worth-based AMR Corporation, was the largest airline in the United States. At year-end 1988 American operated 468 aircraft on 2,200 flights daily to 151 destinations in the United States, Bermuda, Canada, Mexico, the Caribbean, France, Great Britain, Japan, Mexico, Puerto Rico, Spain, Switzerland, Venezuela, and West Germany.