Managing Corporate Capital Investment and Capital Structure
Case 5
American Home Products Corporation
Assess American Home Products ' (AHP) business risk.
THE BUSINESS RISK OF A COMPANY INCLUDES ΒR WHICH IS RELATED TO ITS REVENUE AND OPERATING LEVERAGE WHICH ARISES FROM FIXED COSTS OF PRODUCTION. IN GENERAL, THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY HAS A VERY HIGH BUSINESS RISK DUE TO HIGH RISKS AND COSTS THAT ARE ASSOCIATED WITH THE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT OF NEW PRODUCTS. AMERICAN HOME PRODUCTS HAS A LOW BUSINESS RISK IN COMPARISON TO THE INDUSTRY. THIS IS BECAUSE OF THE UNIQUE NATURE OF MIMICKING COMPETITOR 'S PRODUCTS AND MARKETING THEM IN A SUPERIOR MANNER, AHP AVOIDS LARGE R&D EXPENDITURES. BECAUSE THE R&D REPRESENTS A LARGE AMOUNT OF FIXED
…show more content…
THIS IS DUE TO THE INTEREST TAX SHIELD OF THE DEBT.
BECAUSE OF THE DIFFERENCE IN TAX RATES FOR INTEREST PAYMENTS (ORDINARY INCOME) AND DIVIDENDS (15% - 25%) AS DEBT IS ADDED TO THE STRUCTURE THE PAYMENTS ARE MADE TO INVESTORS IN THE FORM OF INTEREST PAYMENTS. INTEREST PAYMENTS ARE TAXED AT ORDINARY INCOME WHICH SHOULD BE HIGHER THAN 25%. THE VALUE OF THE FIRM WILL DECREASE UNDER THIS SCENARIO.
4. What capital structure would you recommend as appropriate for AHP? Are there any other sources of value, (other than the tax benefits), to AHP 's shareholders from a leverage increase? What are the advantages and disadvantages of levering this company?
A 30% DEBT LEVEL WOULD INCREASE THE VALUE AND IS APPROPRIATE CONSIDERING THE CULTURE OF THE FIRM. WE FEEL THAT A DRASTIC INCREASE IN DEBT WILL HAVE AN ADVERSE AFFECT ON THE CORPORATE CULTURE AND RECOMMEND A MODERATE CHANGE, RATHER THAN A DRASTIC ONE. AN EXTREME CHANGE SUCH AS 50% OR 70% INCREASE IN DEBT WILL ENHANCE THE VALUE BUT IS LESS LIKELY TO BE ACCEPTED BY CONSERVATIVE MANAGEMENT. THE INCREASE IN STOCK PRICE ASSUMES THAT AHP IS PURCHASING OUTSTANDING SHARES WITH THE NEWLY ISSUED DEBT. WE CAN SOLVE FOR THIS INCREASE BY DIVIDING THE AGGREGATE MARKET VALUE OF COMMON STOCK, AS MEASURED IN
In debt financing the interest expense is allowable expense resulting in low tax expense, where as in case of equity finance the cost of equity is dividend, and no advantage can be availed in tax.
3) The interest resulting from the debt also will cost to the company even it is taxable. The interest is fixed base on the level of the debt even the company does not generate profit. This would need to be careful when take on the debt comparing to use its own capital. And the creditor may come to intervene on the business when the company has difficulty to service its debt.
The firm has decided to increase the debt finance component portion from 20% to 30% which is a good decision since the interest payments are 100% tax deductible. The appropriate capital structure would be to
Higher leverage is very likely to create value for a firm considering capital structure change by exerting financial discipline and more efficient corporate strategy changes.
Higher leverage is very likely to create value for a firm considering capital structure change by exerting financial discipline and more efficient corporate strategy changes.
Target Corporation is having a very stable financial policy and dividend policy. From the historical financial data, Target had debt $11,044M, $11,202M, $10,599M, $17,471M, and $19,882M in the year of 2005,2006,2007,2008, and 2009 respectively. The long-term debt/equity ratio rises from 69.34% to 108%.
In general, the lower the company's reliance on debt for asset formation, the less risky the company is since excessive debt can lead to a very heavy interest and principal repayment burden. This is demonstrated through statistics such as high financial risk, low interest coverage ratios, and high debt ratios. However, when a company chooses to forgo debt and rely largely on equity, as in the case of AHP, the company does so at the expense of a tax reduction effect supplied by interest payments. Thus, a company has to consider both risk and tax issues when deciding on an optimal debt ratio.
Dividends are subjected to higher tax rate compare to capital gain increased due to share buy-back. This discourages shareholders from desire to receive high dividends in place of higher capital gain as share values increase. A comparison is made below between the proposed capital structure and dividend policy.
According to the Equilibrium Theory, a company has reached its optimal capital structure when it minimizes the total sum of taxes paid and the cost of financial distress. Taxes paid and the costs of financial distress develop in opposite directions as the interest coverage ratio (EBIT/interest) changes. While the tax shield effect and thus the amount of taxes paid at different coverage ratios can easily be calculated using the marginal tax rate (in the case of Diageo 27%), the cost of financial distress has to be approximated using sophisticated financial models (e.g. Monte Carlo Analysis) that take into account probabilities of different direct and indirect costs of financial distress.
G plc is about to pay a dividend of £50m in total. When G plc first
From this set of problems, we can see that leverage is good for the firm. Leverage has increased the value of the firm as a whole and increased the price per share. Although the cost of debt increases the firm's risk because it increases the probability of default and bankruptcy, therefore shareholders will require higher rates of return on the equity they provide, debt also provides tax savings. And we can see that in table 4, where we calculated the total value of the firm as the pure business cash flows plus the tax savings. Another reason why debt increases firm value is the fact that it reduces WACC, because the cost of debt is generally lower than the cost of equity. Another option that shareholders can do is using homemade leverage. Shareholders should pay a premium for the shares of a levered firm when the addition of debt increases value.
MCI is the second-largest long-distance provider in the telecom industry of United States after AT&T. First of all, in this case we estimate external financing MCI requires until the end of 1987. Exhibit 9A provides the projected capital investment needs for the following year, so our group plug those data in Exhibit 3 corresponds to Funds from Operations and Use of Funds, then come up with the External Financing MCI needs from 1984 to 1987 by deducting the total Source from the total Use. By looking at each year’s needs, we noticed that the external
The relationship between capital structure and firm value has been discussed frequently in the literature by different researcher accordingly, in both theoretical and empirical studies. It has also been discussed that whether the firm has any optimal capital structure that has been adopted by an individual firm, or whether the proportions of debt usage is completely irrelevant to the individual firm value.
ACME Home Improvements Inc. has made the decision to take their business internationally to Mexico City, Mexico. In doing so they will need to ensure they have a reliable and safe Information System Management plan or ISM. The headquarters office for ACME along with the Information Technology (IT) team for ACME Mexico City will consider an ISM plan that is suitable for the ACME Mexico City employees, the Mexican government and the stakeholders. The ISM plan must be able to ensure the assessment of the company’s information and provide solutions, must be able to address strengths and weaknesses that currently exist in the system and it should be able to control daily operations of the company. There are various
Already in 1958, Modigliani and Miller have pointed the discussion of capital structure towards the cost of debt and equity. According to their first proposition, in a world of no corporate taxes and with perfect markets, financial leverage has no effect on a firm’s value. In their second proposition, they state that the cost of equity equals a linear function defined by the required return on assets and the cost of debt (Modigliani and Miller, 1958).