preview

An Analysis Of Billy Collins And Once More To The Lake

Good Essays

In one’s lifetime, there are moments where one may have feelings of youth or old age. The two texts, “Forgetfulness” a poem by Billy Collins and “Once More to the Lake” a passage by E.B. White both share a similar purpose and theme about aging in one’s life. Between the troubles of a middle-aged father who revisits his childhood and one who often struggles with forgetfulness, the reader will understand the shared concept of both texts. Altogether, the authors both use concise syntax and pleasurable diction in order to address the common theme of aging in life. First and foremost, Billy Collins and E.B. White both develop the theme of coming of age and also touch the topic of man vs. self in their writing through the use of metaphors, imagery, and more. Initially, E.B. White introduces dual existence when he writes about a father who revisits his childhood with his son. The man says, “I looked at the boy, who was silently watching his fly, and it was my hands that held his rod, my eyes watching. I felt dizzy and didn’t know which rod I was at the end of” (White 2). This quote suggests that when the father is participating in activities with his son, he feels as if he is the young boy, a child once again. Additionally, he states, “Everywhere we went I had trouble making out which was I, the one walking at my side, the one walking in my pants” (White 5), which shows that the father was having trouble recognizing if he was walking as his son or himself. Also, this shows that the father is still holding on to his childhood memories and his younger self, when in reality he is a middle-aged man. Therefore, man vs. self is displayed because it is the character’s internal conflict of denying his age as a father and believing that he is still young. However, in the end he mentions, “As he buckled the swollen belt suddenly my groin felt the chill of death” (White 5), which breaks the internal conflict of man vs. self and suggests that the father finally realizes that he is no longer a child and his son’s maturation is a sign that he is reaching closer to death, also known as aging. Overall, E.B. White clearly comes across the topics of man vs. self and coming of age in the text. Similarly, Billy Collins develops

Get Access