preview

Essay on An Argument Against Cloning

Decent Essays

An Argument Against Cloning

Increase in genetic knowledge has created challenges in our society. Daniel Callahan focuses on these challenges and expresses his worry about the society (soil) on which this genetic knowledge is growing. Callahan asks the question of what kind of society (soil) is most likely be hazardous and introduces three patterns: 1) societies that demonize death and illness; 2) those societies that want to find biological solutions to social problems; and 3) societies with postmodern theory that there is no common social good, only a plurality of individual goods. In his essay Callahan is concerned about what kind of society we out to be and become before genetic technology can be used. I will use Callahans argument …show more content…

What makes this argument so strong is Callahans ability to bring to light this important issue which people seem to forget in their excitement of increasing genetic knowledge. Although I agree with Callahan, I want to point out that genetic knowledge in itself must not be made out to be pure, holy and without fault, but that genetic knowledge in itself can cause a society to become racist and discriminatory. What if it is found that aggressive behavior is found to genetically exist in African Americans? Won’t that make society a bit more racist to African Americans? I understand Callahans worry of the kind of society we want to become and how that affects the use of genetic knowledge, but I also think that Callahan needs to address the faults in genetic knowledge because of the racism and discrimination it can bring to a society.
Callahan asks the question of what kind of society (soil) is most likely be hazardous and introduces three patterns: 1) societies that demonize death and illness; 2) those societies that want to find biological solutions to social problems; and 3) societies with postmodern theory that there is no common social good, only a plurality of individual goods. Why are these patterns hazardous? First, with fear of death and disease and turning it into the greatest human enemy comes the temptation to do whatever we can to root them out. Death and illness becomes so unacceptable to the ambitious science that we

Get Access