preview

Analysis Of The Book ' The Joy Luck Club '

Good Essays

Jessica Chen
Ms. Churchill
English 2 Honors, Period 0
6 September 2015
Reconciliation
Swan feathers. Hopes and dreams. Broken relationships and healing. Though these concepts might initially appear incongruous, they are all depicted in the book The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan and The Joy Luck Club film directed by Wayne Wang. Both modes of interpretation show how the mothers help their daughters solve their problems by explaining the formers’ pasts. However, while the book leaves each of the daughters’ stories open ended, the film boldly creates a ‘happy ever after’ ending for the daughters. In both the movie and book, there are powerful bonds between the mothers and daughters. As shown by these examples, there are many similarities as well as differences between the movie and the book The Joy Luck Club, but both mediums ultimately seek to portray the same themes.
To begin with, many events in the film are similar to those in the book. For example, toward the beginning of both the book and the film, the mothers are astonished when June reveals to them that she does not know what to say to her sisters about her deceased mother, Suyuan Woo. In the book, the mothers frantically list out what qualities of her mother June should tell her sisters, such as her mother’s “kindness… smartness… dutiful nature to family… hopes, things that matter to her… the excellent dishes she cooked…” (Tan 31). Just so in the movie, during the same scene, the mothers appear

Get Access