Plato uses the conversation between Socrates and Glaucon in “the Allegory of the Cave” to explain the process of getting knowledge is. The allegory presented a prisoner who was shackled in a cave and was forced to see only the shadows that were shown to him. Then Socrates presented a possibility of that prisoner breaking free and slowly finds the light source. At first he saw the fire and his eyes already hurts, and he raged at the person who dragged him outside of the cave. However, with some effort and time on his own, he was able to look at the sun. Through this allegory, we can prove that the only way to achieve something is through the motives of an individual, not through schooling or coaching.
The prisoner was able to see the sun only
…show more content…
However, Socrates added to the story by saying, “if someone, using force, were to pull him [who had been freed from his chains] away from there and to drag him up the cave’s rough and steep ascent and not to let go of him until he had dragged him out into the light of the sun…” (Plato Stage 2) Socrates then continued on to describe the prisoner’s thoughts throughout the situation as “pain and rage”. This relates to my argument because the prisoner was unwilling to see the light to begin with. He already looked away from the fire, so if someone were to drag him into the sun, he of course would feel pain and rage since he is not accustomed to the bright light. Or in other words, no matter how strong the outside force that forces you to achieve your goal will not be beneficial because the mind is not ready for the change. The individual has to think of his own ways to achieve that goal. Later on in the text, Socrates shows the prisoner getting accustomed to the light by first looking at the shadows, then the reflections in the water, and then to the actual beings itself. After getting accustomed to the light, the prisoner now is able to look at the sun. Socrates stated, “And having all that, by this time he would also be able to gather the following about the sun: (1)
The process of apprehending true knowledge is a task unfit for those who cannot overcome the concepts that the truth is associated with. This task of discovering knowledge tests an individual and their dedication to the process. However, this process is grueling and does not always yield the expected or desired result. According to philosophers, such as Socrates and Plato, humans are born with innate knowledge that becomes accessible through reasoning and life experiences. Plato’s The Allegory of the Cave describes of a group of people, in a cave, that have been shielded from society for their entire lives and were given an alternate and limited education. One man is forced out of the cave and into the light of the real world, where he
As we know, Socrates chose to never write or have his ideas published. We learned of his outlook and ideas through the writing and dialogues of a student whom admired everything about him, Plato. In the “Allegory of the Cave,” we read a dialogue that occurs between Socrates and another student, Glaucon. Socrates describes chained human beings living in an underground cave, which has a mouth open towards the light. Due to being chained, these people cannot see the light of day, nor can they see anything that is not directly in front of them. There is a fire burning behind them, which casts a shadow on the wall they are facing. “To them, I said, the truth would be literally nothing but the shadows of the images” (Plato, 3). Because the shadows are all they see, they are all that is real to them. If one of these prisoners were to be freed to the world above, their neck would be stiff, the light would shock their eyes and they would no longer be able to see the realities they once saw in the shadows. Once the person adjusts to the light, they will be able to understand that the sun is the cause of everything
In Socrates’ mind education is not simply an information exchange; rather it is a painful experience, since all that one had previously believed is typically wrong. This painful experience can be seen as the “philosopher” turns around and stares into the light and eventually learning that everything he had experienced in life were just shadows.
The path from ignorance to knowledge can look different for each individual. The pursuit of truth emerges as a fundamental aspect that guides our journey towards enlightenment. This pursuit not only leads people to truth, but to a broader understanding of how things work. This involves an individual to pursue the truth, question authority, and transform once one has finally broken from ignorance. These themes are explored through Sophocle’s play Antigone, Plato’s Allegory of the Cave, and the biblical passage Sermon on the Mount.
In the Allegory of the Cave Plato argues for enlightenment, but he also presents why choosing enlightenment can be dangerous and painful. The people who live in the cave believe that what they see is reality. Plato explains, that when a person is taken out of the cave that they will be "pained and irritated." Normally when some one is in pain they try and stop the pain in any way they no how whatever the cost is. The sun in this case is the source of the pain.
In his Allegory Plato shows us how a man ascends from the darkness of a cave to the light of the outside world. In this ascent Plato’s man passes through four distinct stages of cognition: from imagination, to belief, understanding, and finally knowledge.
Socrates tells the story and describes four prisoners living in a underground cell with their neck chained to a board and feet chained to the ground with all the prisoners facing the wall. Every so often the prisoners see shadows or what they think are shadows. One of the prisoners gets forced to leave the cave by a guard, and he goes out into the world, he's forced to stare into the sun and then return to the cave to make his decision of forcing the other prisoners out. Should he show the others reality or let them stay as a prisoner in the dark and continue to have a misperception of the shadows. The symbolism and elements shown are through the prisoners, chains and the cave itself.
The cave allegory also proves that the role of education is not to teach in the sense of feeding people information they do not have, but rather to shed light on things they already know. Education "isn't the craft of putting sight into the soul. Education takes for granted that sight is there but that it isn't turned the right way or looking where it ought to look, and it tries to redirect it properly." (2)
The final phase Socrates says the prisoner will go through will be his studying of the heavens by this point he believes the prisoner will be able to himself come up with conclusions regard the sun as “the source of the seasons and the years” (516c) and simply the cause for all he now sees and all he once saw. According to Socrates the prisoner will eventually recall the lifestyle and the people he left behind and began to feel a sense of pity for them but will cherish experience he has received on the surface. He says that if the prisoner were to ever return to the cave he would face the pain of having to readjust to the light in the cave and the ridicule of the prisoner who will see him as someone who has lost sight of the truth instead of the newly enlightened soul he is.
At the last stage of learning, In the story, “Allegory of the Cave”, Socrates mentions, “But I think that finally, he would be in the condition to look at the sun itself, not just at its reflection whether in water or wherever else it might appear, but at the sun itself, as it is in and of itself and the place proper to it and to contemplate of what sort it is” (19). Eventually, the prisoner could see things easily through the shadows under the sunlight. He would try to understand the structure of the objects and at the end, he would start to begin to look for the real objects when his eyes no longer in pain under the sunlight. Socrates also says, “And then what? If he again recalled his first dwelling, and the “knowing” that passes as the
In this allegorical lesson, Plato discusses the way in which acquiring knowledge that was previously absent changes the way a human views the world, as well as the concepts of ignorance and the effects of an uneven disbursement of understanding among people in a similar environment. The Plato’s cave , there are multiple men who have been chained up against a wall, and thus their vision is fixed upon a certain setting, and they are unable to look away from that scene. There is a fire behind the men chained up, which casts shadows against the wall as people move in front of it. The shadows are what the men deem to be real, and is their only reality.
The freed prisoner after looking at the sun will not be able to see in the dark because their eyes have re adjusted. Shackled prisoners see that the freed prisoners eyes are damaged because they can not see in the dark.in the passage plat states “and would they not let him know that he had gone up but only in order to come back down to the cave with his eyes ruined-- and thus it certainly does not pay to go up.” The freed prisoner can not see in the dark because they have left the cave and explored the outside world . in this part of the passage plato is showing that once we see events that happen to us or others from different points of view, we may see them completely different than
Socrates’s anecdote of the cave presents a ghastly image: people who “are in it from childhood with their legs and necks in bonds so that they are fixed, seeing only in front of them, unable because of the bond to turn their heads all the way around” (193). Also inside the cave is a “fire burning” which allows certain objects (out of sight and controlled by others) to project shadows (193). Consequently, the prisoners believe that the shadows are the most real things. When a prisoner is released, he experiences pain due to the light of the fire. In time, he recognizes the truth and becomes accustomed to it. He is then “dragged out into the light of the sun” (194). After a few moments, he tolerates its rays. Most importantly though, he grasps “the sun itself” (195). Finally, the escapee is not content with keeping this
In the Allegory of the Cave, Plato presents his philosophy on hidden knowledge and its effect on the human mind. The word ''allegory'' in the title refers to his theory as a story that can be interpreted to expose the truth behind its hidden meaning. In this essay Plato tells a story about three prisoners who know nothing about the real world and all they could see is people shadows who were walking by the cave, while the prisoners couldn't turn their heads to see what is behind them. The main idea in the story is about knowledge and how it can't be transferred instantly from one person to another, but it can used to guide people through life and see the real world as it being seen by enlightened individuals. As Plato introduces the main idea
Once the prisoner climbs out of the cave and is fully immersed in the sun's rays, Socrates continues to explain the prisoner's bewilderment, fear, and blindness to the objects he was now being told were real. The natural reaction of the prisoner would be to recognize shadows and reflections. After his eyes adjust to the sunlight, he begins to see items and people in their own existence, outside of the cave. When the prisoner looks up to the sky and looks into the Sun, and recognizes it as the cause of all that is around himhe has perceived the "Form of the Good!" This point in the passage marks the climax, as the prisoner, who not long ago was blind to the "Form of the Good" (as well as the basic Forms in general), now is aware of reality and truth. When this has occurred, the ultimate stage of thought has been achieved, and that is