Andrew Carnegie : A Hero Or A Hero?

Was Andrew Carnegie a Hero? Andrew Carnegie was known as one of Americas best business men and industrialist. Some could argue that Carnegie was either a hero or a villain. The legacy of Andrew Carnegie proves that he was a hero due to the plethora amounts of money he donated and daring yet intelligent business choices (Doc. 9+5).

Andrew Carnegie was one of the wealthiest men in America but his wealth didn’t come without hard work and dedication. Carnegie was born in “Dunfermline, Scotland on November 25, 1835” (Tyle). According to Laura B. Tyle, the invention of the weaving machine unfortunately pushed Carnegie’s family in to poverty “In 1848, Carnegie’s family left Scotland and moved to Allegheny City, Pennsylvania, where his father and eventually him worked in a cotton factory” (Tyle). After leaving the cotton factory “Carnegie became a messenger boy for the Pittsburgh telegraph office and eventually made his way up to telegraph operator” (Tyle). According to Laura B. Tyle “Thomas A. Scott, the superintendent of the western division of the Pennsylvania Railroad, made Carnegie his secretary at the age of eighteen.” Later, Carnegie took over Scott’s position of the railroad. Furthermore Carnegie “began to see that steel was going to replace iron and by 1873 he organized a steel rail company” (Tyle). According to Laura B. Tyle he continued to build his company when he “cut prices, drove out competitors,

Andrew Carnegie, the “King of Steel”, the benevolent employer, the giant of industry, was among the greatest influences of the second industrial revolution. It is sometimes questioned whether Carnegie was the ruthless, sneaky steel tyrant some made him out to be, or the generous, benevolent education benefactor he appeared to be. I believe him to be a combination of both, but more so the great giant of industry.

Andrew Carnegie, a tightfisted employer among many, but a good-hearted philanthropist among many more; however, does this really explain if he was or was not a hero? Andrew Carnegie was a scottish immigrant born in November 1835 who grew up in a poor and hard life, whose family made the tough decision to the Americas in 1848, started working at age 12 to appease his family’s financial trouble. He worked harder and harder, deciphering dot-dot-dash messages by ear, setting train schedules and untangling train wrecks, and saving Union soldiers, and finally, as a result, rose to become one of America’s richest and most integral heroes. However, we should ask ourselves this: Was Andrew Carnegie truly a hero? Well, to answer that question we need to look at the definition of a hero. Hero, a word defined as a person who holds amazing courage, or a person who possesses strong integrity, or a person who boasts a vast amount of intelligence or wisdom. Going by this interpretation, we could state that Andrew Carnegie was a hero in the business area because of his strategic intelligence; in the social area because of his honest integrity; and in the economic area because of his courageous work and investments.

Andrew Carnegie grew up in Dunfermline, Scotland and immigrated along with his family to the United States in the late 1800s. He worked his way up from being a poor Irish immigrant to become one of the most famous industrialists that helped transform the U.S steel industry in the late 19th century. Andrew Carnegie was a hero in many ways. One reason why Andrew Carnegie was a hero was because of his influences on renovating the American steel industry which helped create the U.S a world power. Secondly, Andrew Carnegie was a hero is because he helped create jobs that employed many Americans. Finally, Carnegie was a hero is because he was one of the most influential philanthropists.

Imagine having all the money you want and still having a ton left over. Andrew Carnegie was a poor boy who ended up becoming the richest man in america during 1901. He worked himself up in the Pennsylvania Railroad company and would have been successful there but he was unclear on what he wanted to do. So he decided to move to New York City where he met Henry Bessemer. Bessemer taught him how to make steel, so then Carnegie moved back to Pittsburg and set up a steel mill. There he became a steel king and it caused him to become extremely wealthy. A hero is someone who has courage, integrity, and a concern for others. There were three reasons Andrew Carnegie was not a hero and they are he was a hypocrite, did not care about others, and caused others to lose self respect.

     Let us first look at Mr. Andrew Carnegie. Carnegie was a mogul in the steel industry. Carnegie

Andrew Carnegie did amazing things with his money while and even after he was alive. He also had flaws and did some not so very good things. He used his fortune to do things like buying organs for churches, donating to colleges, and building public libraries. His Homestead steel mill, on the other hand experienced a strike and its workers were not very content, which Carnegie turned a blind eye to. So was Andrew Carnegie a hero?

No man of business drew more attention than the king of steel, Andrew Carnegie. Carnegie grew up very poor in Scotland and immigrated to the United States. He worked very hard in Pittsburgh and became one of the three people in the country that could decode telegraph messages by ear. Later in England, Carnegie saw Henry Bessemer develop steel and decided to build a steel mill in America. Many thought Carnegie was a hero in America. A few traits that represent a hero could be integrity, a concern for others, and charisma. Some people may think that Carnegie only spent his wealth on himself but he actually donated to cities to better society. He donated money to build a library in Pittsburgh and donated to Scotland. Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he had a concern for others and he achieved financial success.

Andrew Carnegie was a hero amongst a few people but it can be debatable towards others. Andrew Carnegie was born in November 1835, in the attic of a weaver’s cottage in Dunfermline, Scotland. While he was growing up, his family was poor, so his family decided to move to the United States, he started working at the age of twelve. As he got older he got promoted into different positions and because of this he was able to build up his own business and bought out his competition. Could Andrew Carnegie be considered a hero? A hero is a person that does something astonishing such as provide courage, integrity and intelligence. Andrew Carnegie was not considered a hero in three areas of his life: business, money and social.

It is illustrated in document 1 that he started from being super poor to being a millionaire over the course of about 30 years. This shows how hard Carnegie had worked during those years. (Doc 1) Another illustration of Carnegie’s achievement is a graph by an artist named, Robert Nedronida. The graph depicts a map of all the properties that Carnegie purchased with description of each of every one of them. This demonstrates Carnegie as a hero because all the companies he owned serves a purpose of helping people utilize sources that we use today. For instance, one of his companies called Carnegie’s Oliver Iron Mining Co. has influenced how we use oil to pave the roads, to make things, and to heat our homes. In addition, he gave people jobs and opportunities by owning all these companies. (Doc

(Henle 1) His favorite type of donation was the construction of a new library. There are few things that can be a more positive influence than the construction of several hundred libraries. Andrew Carnegie was a man unlike any other. He work hard not to benefit himself and his family, he didn't strive to leave his kids the rich children in the world. He worked and climbed mountain with all of his might so that one day the world would be a better place because of his effort. Andrew Carnegie has made this world a much better place through his stand against harsh labor problem, his expansion and monopolization of the steel industry and his always generous Philanthropic work. Andrew Carnegie is with out a doubt the most influential person in the Twentieth

Andrew Carnegie is known for being a captain of industry, or a business person who is especially powerful and successful. Through his work on the development of the prosperous American steel industry, he soon became one of the richest entrepreneurs of his time. Carnegie started work in a cotton factory as bobbin boy after leaving Scotland and arriving in America, earning merely $1.20 per week. Eventually, after working diligently for his entire life, Carnegie was able to build his steel company into one of the biggest empires, leading to his immense success. Andrew Carnegie was a captain of industry because he was able to turn a small idea into something of great magnitude which benefited society in a substantial way.

Born on November 25, 1835, in Dunfermline, Scotland, Andrew Carnegie started his life in the United States working at a telegraph office. During his time in the work of telegraphs, he started his life of going from poor and low class to rich and high class (known as “rags to riches”). In the 1860’s carnegie began investing into many things finding great outcomes in return. In the 1870’s he began his work with steel. By consulting with, leading steel producer in Great Britain, Henry Bessemer he was able to learn how to manufacture high quality steel that would require the least amount of money for production (McGuire, William, and Leslie Wheeler). He created the Carnegie Steel Corporation soon to become one of the wealthiest men in America in the 19th century. Because of his company and steel production, Carnegie brought the United States up as the leading steel producer, exceeding Great Britain (McGuire, William, and Leslie Wheeler). His company completely changed the way steel was produced in America by providing a easier, quicker, and more effective way of

What characteristics should a person have to be called hero? Andrew Carnegie was born into a poor family in 1835 in Scotland worked his way up the railroad industry, he eventually became the supervisor of the Pennsy's entire western division. He was earning about $1500. A kid that from that super poor family to the very rich person in just 30 years. By the time he was super rich he made a good decision by giving away all his money for the sake of good for the people and putting a lot of funds to different organizations. Although giving his money for the sake of good that does not mean that he is a hero.