Animal Farm Vs Animal Farm Essay

The three themes of utopia, the good life, and power and control are common ideas explored throughout two seemingly different texts, the movie The Truman Show by Peter Weir, and the novel Animal Farm by George Orwell. Whilst the settings and characters are quite different, their views on these three themes are strikingly similar.

What makes the perfect Utopia? What is needed for a good life? These questions are so important when it comes to human’s view on power and control and how it should be used. In both stories, ‘Animal Farm’ (written by George Orwell) and ‘The Truman Show’ (directed by Peter Weir), the author and director explore these themes. Power and control, the good life, utopia. These three themes are key to living the full life. To have a utopia you must have a good life and to have a good life you must have your own power and your own control.

George Orwell shows similar views on what a Utopia looks like but in contrast, Animal Farm starts off with awful conditions that are enforced by Farmer Jones which then change when the animals overthrow him. The text shows a utopia functioning perfectly early on in the novel, with everyone working together to collect an abundance of food. George Orwell also helps us see how perfect the animals society is by make it contrast against the living conditions from earlier. The animals put together simple laws to keep them in check and overall, they lead a perfect life together. And just like in The Truman Show, the perfect society falls apart just as fast as it was put together. But what goes wrong in both texts? Could these texts be telling us that a utopia simply isn 't possible to create? No they aren 't. Both Utopias

The prompt is asking for us to compare and contrast how the truman show and animal farm are similar but also how they are different in the categories of power and control, the good life and a good society. Peter Weir explores the idea of power and control with Christof and Truman. The good life in truman show is shown with sea haven. A good society is shown in the Truman Show with the perfect job and the perfect life. In animal farm George Orwell scrutinizes the idea of power and control this is shown with the animals controlling the farm. In Animal Farm George Orwell uses real events like the russian revolution to influence him with the themes a good life and a good society, how they can be corrupt but also how they can be good.

Christof is a crucial example of the immorality which represented throughout the film to Truman in his daily life. During the television show, Christof continuously disregards the personal moments and individual feeling of Truman by presenting this to the viewers of the show. This is established when Christof organises the dramatic death of Truman's father, ending with Truman being traumatically scarred for life, just for the entertainment of the audience. This shows the

“When a person places the proper value on freedom, there is nothing under the sun that he will not do to acquire that freedom.”

Animal Farm by George Orwell and The Truman Show directed by Peter Weir are two different texts that explore similar themes. Some of these are: the good life for an individual, the good life for a society, and power. Animal Farm is novel about a group of animals who overthrow their farms human leader, Mr. Jones, for independence. In The Truman Show, Truman Burbank is a boy who grows up in a reality TV show set, unaware of this fact. This essay will explore the similarities and differences between these two texts.

The Novel Animal Farm is a fictional story about animals escaping their life of slavery and taking control of their lives, but just to be slowly tricked into slavery by the pigs. The movie Truman show directed by peter weir (real life director) is about a man named Truman who was raised up in a fake world were his every move is broadcasted to the world as a TV show, but Truman doesn’t actually know he is in a fake world. After reading/watching both text we start to ask what the good life is to them, what makes a good society and how much power is justified?

Mr Jones, the farmer in the book was seen as the most evil to the animals. The animals viewed Mr. Jones as evil because they explained that Mr. Jones made them work too hard and did not feed the animals as much as they should have been fed.. So Old Major , the original and oldest leader of Animal Farm introduced the idea to take over Mr. Jones farm and make the farm theirs. “There Comrades, is the answer to all our problems. It is summed up in a single word-man. Man is the only real enemy we have”(Orwell 6). Old major was saying the only enemy the animals has between them and freedom, was man which the man Old Major was referring to was Mr Jones, the animal's owner. After Old Major died, a pig named snowball took over for Old Major and led the animals to rebellion. The animals first battle against the humans, (Mr. Jones and his men) “The Battle of the Cowshed” showed the humans and the animals that the animals want to control themselves and they are capable of doing so.Snowball said, “War is war. The only good human being is a dead one”(Orwell 31). During the first battle, Boxer, the horse killed a human on accident. He felt very bad about it, but snowball and the rest of the animals reminded Boxer that it was better to kill a human than be controlled by one. The animals had to do what was the best for them to stay on

The Truman Show directed by Peter Weir and Animal Farm written by George Orwell are two very different texts, but they both explore the same themes: power, good life and utopia. Truman Burbank is the protagonist of The Truman Show, the movie is about Truman thinking he’s just living his normal, ordinary life, but really his whole life is set-up and he's a star of his own TV show. Animal Farm is about animals rebelling against their farm owner Mr Jones, so the animals can own the farm and have rights and equality. But Napoleon and the pigs end up taking control and making everything the opposite of equal. Weir and Orwell both show throughout their texts: power not achieving good, do they need freedom to have a good life and what is a good society/utopia.

Jones mistreats, abuses and starves the animals, forcing them to work day after day, striving to make the farm a success. This is because he is in debt and fears the possibility of losing the farm. Unfortunately, his hard work didn't pay off, and Jones was faced with more disappointment. The

A quote from Wayne Dyer, a late American author and motivational speaker, says that “[f]reedom means you are unobstructed in living your life as you choose. Anything less is a form of slavery.” This promotes the idea that ultimate freedom to control one’s life is the only way to live. One way to achieve this freedom, if not given, is to stage a revolution against authority. In Animal Farm, a novel by George Orwell, parallels are drawn between his characters and the major figures of the Communist movement. On the Manor Farm, a group of animals long for a break from the oppression of the farmer, Mr. Jones. Lead by the wise boar Old Major, the farm animals stage a revolt and overthrow all humans, taking control and renaming their land “Animal Farm.” Although at first the society free from humans seems utopian, soon a group of pigs takes harsh control of the others, manipulating them into thinking that life is still perfect. By the end, the power struggle has gone full circle; pigs and humans are no longer distinguishable. Throughout this novella, the literary elements of irony, symbolism, personification and conflict are present, which convey ideas about Communism, language, and utopian societies.

While under the rule of Mr. Jones, the treatment for the animals is less than ideal. Jones doesn’t feed the animals which causes them to revolt. The animals go wild on Jones and his men until they flee the farm, leaving the animals on their own. Once Jones and his men escape, the pigs on the farm use this opportunity to gain

Animal Farm was written by George Orwell, and though the novel conveys many examples of comparing and contrasting characters, the two bests are Napoleon and Snowball. Since pigs were seen as the cleverest of animals, the responsibilities fell on the two boars Snowball and Napoleon (Orwell 15). They immediately differ in appearance, as Napoleon is very large and is a Berkshire boar, while Snowball is described for his creativity, but not as much as a developed character. Though they have many differences, it is Snowball that is the better leader due to the fact that he incorporates the thoughts and ideas of everyone, is kind and is not selfish.

Power, the good life and utopia are all connected, without one you can't have another. But what is power, the good life and utopia? And how is each of these topics viewed by different people? Peter Weir; the director of the Truman Show, and George Orwell; the writer of animal farm have almost the same views on each topic and make that clear in their work. In each of these topics it is clear that Weir and Orwell are in agreement.