Animal Research : Is It Human Or Inhuman?

1100 WordsSep 29, 20175 Pages
Animal research in psychology is a controversial issue that has raised many questions on whether it should be allowed Is it human or inhuman? Peter Singer, a bioethicist, views animal research as a form of discrimination and for the most part useless in findings. Singer believes that animals and humans are not very different from each other; hence, asking why not test on humans too if it is okay on animals? On the other hand, R.G. Frey, a professor of philosophy, argues that animal research should be allowed since their meaning of life differs from ours. Also, Frey states that animal testing had led to significant research. So, who is right? Singer, in his book Animal Liberation (Ecco,2002), states the concept of speciesism. Speciesism…show more content…
For example, Singer illustrates an example of a dog undergoing varies shock from jumping to floors that each had the shock. Eventually, the dog stopped resisting, and thus researchers stated that the experiment should how to eliminate jumping in dogs. Singer saw this as up scoured and unnecessary. This example can be seen as psychological since it determines the behavior of dogs after an experiment. Now many people may agree with Singer and find this inhumane but will agree with the medical animal research. Frey, in "Justifying Animal Experiments: The Starting Point" in Ellen Frankel Paul and Jeffery Paul, eds., Why Animal Experimentation Matters: The Use of Animals in Medical Reseach (Transaction, 2001), states "Genetic research involving animals promises new treatments for diseases that previously were thought to be intractable defects in the human condition". Many people would agree that these animals testing to be useful since it helps medical issues, yet do not realize the hypocrisies of agreeing with animal testing that benefits them while disagreeing with animal testing when it hurts them in psychological. Frey 's argument that animals cannot be distinguished from humans can be true. For example, Frey, in "Justifying Animal Experiments: The Starting Point" in Ellen Frankel Paul and Jeffery Paul, eds., Why Animal Experimentation Matters: The Use of Animals in Medical Reseach (Transaction, 2001), says "...we do not know what an animal 's quality of life is may well
Open Document