preview

Arguments Against Compulsory Voting

Decent Essays

Compulsory voting is a system where citizens are required to register to vote and attend a polling place on election day (Rosenburg, Matt). Compulsory voting is not the most virtuous solution to the problem of low voter turnout and political disengagement due to its disregard of the peoples’ rights as well as citizens’ opinions and the quality of the their votes. As Theodore Roosevelt once said “A vote is like a rifle; its usefulness depends upon the character of the user” (Roosevelt, Theodore). Without a doubt, compulsory voting is an infringement of liberty as stated in the U.S. Constitution. Voting is not an imperative obligation and forcing it would contravene the first five basic freedoms of U.S. citizens guaranteed by the First Amendment. …show more content…

What are voters to do when they do not like the options put in front of them? The answer is put into words in the following, “But I believe that not having an opinion is an opinion, that being indifferent to the outcome of an election and disliking all of the options put before one are both opinions. If people don't turn out to vote, they’re definitely stating their opinions, many of which are both strongly held and a well thought through…” (Text 4, Lines 29-32). In addition, those citizens believe that their “right to vote also implies the right not to vote” (Text 3, Line 26). As said in the previous information, it takes a politician who can motivate the public to get out and vote. Only then will the voters feel confident that the candidate they chose is best for the job. The right to choose our representatives is something we all hold and can choose to do, but it should never be statutory especially considering the saying “quality rather than …show more content…

Text 2 Lines 27-30 explains the idea of random voting, “Voters who are voting against their free will may check off a candidate at random, particularly the top candidate on the ballot paper. The voter does not care whom they vote for as long as the government is satisfied that they have fulfilled their civic duty”. Forcing a population to vote has been proved to result in blank and invalid votes (text 2, lines 25-26), which happens to contradict the purpose of the compulsory voting. If the motive for the mandatory voting is to produce an accurate representation of the country’s political opinion then the invalid and blank votes prove that it is an inadequate way to go about tackling the problem of political

Get Access