Article Critique – Minimizing Deviant Behavior in Healthcare Organizations: The Effects of Supportive Leadership and Job Design
1. List all authors, the year, article title, journal name, volume number, issue number, and page numbers.
Minimizing Deviant Behavior in Healthcare Organizations: The Effects of Supportive Leadership and Job Design
C. Logan Chullen, Benjamin B. Dunford, Ingo Angermeier, R. Wayne Boss, and Alan D. Boss
Journal of Healthcare Management, November/December 2010, Volume 55, Number 6, Pages 381-398
2. Purpose of the study.
The purpose of the study was to show how supportive management practices and enriched work design
…show more content…
This is important for high job satisfaction as it can affect an organizations performance. Self-determination theory taps into an employee’s motivation, which increases their effort at work. An organization that has a high level of intrinsic motivation allows their employees opportunity for growth and to participate in management decisions; thus, increasing the incidence of employees being engaged. Whereas, organizations who do not promote an intrinsic motivation environment has employees who are less engaged with less regard for organizational policies. This addresses the third hypothesis of employees report lover levels of intrinsic motivation will more than likely engage in deviant behavior towards the organization.
Depersonalization occurs when employees become emotionally detached from those around them because of stress with limited or no resources available to assist the employee in coping. One of the biggest contributors to depersonalization is burnout by employees that leads to a decrease in job satisfaction, employee performance, and turnover. Conservation of resources theory (COR) addresses how burnout develops and the effects it has on an employee’s job performance. Burnout often develops because of limited work resources while attempting to keep up with work demands. This addresses the fourth hypothesis where employees with higher levels of depersonalization will more than likely engage
According to Frates (2014), Mr. Edwards understood that the physicians played a critical role in the organization and could possibly assist in the plan to control the hospitals cost. However, allowing the new COO to terminate the employment of Dr. Harris (hospitals radiologist) without calling on the physicians to analyze the problems and perhaps recommend any solutions that would be beneficial in cutting cost and did not show good leadership power (Frates, 2014). As evidenced within this study, the way that leaders and individuals in positions of responsibility handle themselves in turbulent times is crucial to any organization and leaders must understand how to use power judiciously when making decisions that would determine the organizations success (Frates,
source of information in the report, you give the name(s) of the author(s) and the date of
How can we ensure that effective healthcare leadership is incorporated in today’s organization? While continued reports exist of organizations struggling to stay afloat, research has indicated that healthcare organizations are lacking in effective styles of leaderships. With fast approaching changes with mergers and acquisitions, many healthcare organizations have chosen to restructure their facilities to accommodate the rapid growth in the industries crisis of inadequate leadership in organizations. In fact, numerous reports have surfaced depicting growing needs for organizations to change their current leader’s roles to help improve the potential success of developing effective leadership.
White, K., & Griffith, J. (2010). Operational leadership. In The well-managed healthcare organization (7th ed., p. 92). Chicago: Health Administration Press.
Burnout is a pattern of emotional, physical, and mental exhaustion in response to chronic job stressors. It is a disorder characterized by emotional exhaustion, depersonalization and a low level of personal accomplishments, which primarily affects people who are dealing with other people in their work (Maslach, 1982). Burnout develops due to the persistent emotional strain, which is the result of dealing with other people who cope with serious problems. Thus, burnout could be considered as a type of professional stress, which results from the social interaction between the person who provides
Quality improvement, patient safety, and cost containment are some of the key focuses of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) in 2010. Therefore, many Healthcare Organizations (HCOs) were confronted with the challenge of changing their organization behavior, so that they can deliver a safe care without compromising on qualities and increasing on expenditures with each care delivery (KPMG Healthcare & Pharmaceutical Institute, 2011). The purpose of the paper is to discuss a HCO’s transformation challenge, its subsystem within a larger system, its culture and climate, its leadership style, its assessment based on Collin’s Good to Great, and its readiness for change in today’s complex environment.
“The organization as a whole can provide a more or less stressful work environment depending on whether all organizational members share a sense of excitement and strong purpose and clear goal and objectives.” (Lewis, Packard & Lewis, 2010)
Effective leader experiment and take risks regardless of small failure, error or mistake to make a change (Kouzes & Posner 2011). They must ensure that all the staffs get chance to improve and upgrade their existing knowledge, skill and improving their competencies to provide evidence based care (Nicol 2012). This ultimately lead to a greater accomplish, development and progress in a health organization through incremental steps and small wins (Careau et al. 2014). They must have feedback session with staff, patients and family members regarding organization. So that they can identify good and bad things that are hindering success of an organization and act accordingly and minimize negative things (Teixeira et al. 2012). Leader must create a culture to recognize reward and praise risk takers. So that members can be motivated towards progressive activities in an organization. This all leads towards progression, development of health organization resulting high standard qualitative healthcare (Sarto& Veronesi
It is not uncommon for some leaders to have their personal goals overshadow the goals of the organization, and at the end of the leader’s tenure, there are often negative consequences for both the employees and the organization (Harvey, et al., 2007). Certainly, this reversal of objectives can be seen in the political arena as well, where leaders seek a leadership position to promote their own personal ambitions, which often generate substantial material gains (Harvey, et al., 2007). In addition, leaders who have negative and destructive leadership tendencies by taking advantage of their positions tend to take their organizations toward destruction (Reed, 2004; Pelletier, 2010). On the other hand, followers’ behaviors can cause the creation of toxic leaders when they attribute divine powers to leaders due to their desperation and hope that this leader will act like a therapist and alleviate their concerns (Lipman-Blumen, 2005b).
All organizations aspire to be successful in this era of rapid development where the market is very competitive. Therefore, there is a need for them to motivate their employees since they are a critical strategic asset for dealing with such competition. Employees’ motivation can be described as the psychological process that causes workers to behave in a positive manner thus improving their performance behavior (Townsend, 2002). Companies irrespective of their size and market should strive to retain their best workers, acknowledging their significant role and influence to the organizational effectiveness. To achieve this, firms should create a strong and positive relationship with the workers. From the data obtained from various researches, it is apparent that employee motivation improves performance through reducing absenteeism as well as increasing renovation among workers (Norsworthy &Zabala, 1990). The relationship between motivation and performance is clearly depicted in Southwest Airlines Company where the firm invests on its human resource to improve its productivity.
Motivation in the workplace is one of the major concerns that managers face when trying to encourage their employees to work harder and do what is expected of them on a day-to-day basis. According to Organizational Behavior by John R. Schermerhorn, James G. Hunt and Richard N. Osborn the definition of motivation is "the individual forces that account for the direction, level, and persistence of a person's effort expended at work." They go on to say that "motivation is a key concern in firms across the globe." Through the years there have been several theories as to what motivates employees to do their best at work. In order to better understand these theories we will apply them to a fictitious organization that has the following
v When authors number eight or more, include the first six authors’ names in the reference,
Industrial/Organizational (I/O) Psychology is devoted to the study of employee behavior in the workplace and understanding the issues facing organizations and employees in today’s complex and ever changing environment. Motivation refers to the set of forces that influence people to choose various behaviors among several alternatives available to them. An organization depends on the ability of management to provide a positive, fostering and motivating environment for its employees in order to increase profits, productivity and lower turnover rates of its employees. The purpose of this paper is to discuss and compare six academic journal articles and explore the behavior, job, and need based theories of motivation that can aid management in motivating and understanding their employees. Finding that delicate balance to can sometimes be elusive so effectively learning how to motivate by understanding, controlling and influencing factors to manipulate behavior and choices that are available to employees can produce the desired outcome.
Kahn, 1990; Lawler, 1986). This paper analyzes motivation theory and identifies solutions to questions such as...(1) what is motivation and/or employee involvement, (2) how does motivation affect employment involvement, (3) what affect does employee involvement have towards increasing organizational effectiveness, and finally (4) what needs to happen to change the trajectory of low motivation and employee involvement.
Motivation can be described as the level of influence that the employees or workers bring to the businesses relevant to their specific jobs. In connection to the above it is of crucial significance to note that employee motivation is majorly influenced by three main factors. The factors comprise of the energy, creativity as well as commitment that such employees or workers bring to the jobs. These factors contribute greatly towards the realization of success in the business. Therefore, it is important to note that in order to realize success, it is very important to ensure that such factors are greatly observed. Professionalism should always be employed in ensuring that the issue of employee motivation is not compromised in any other way. This is because compromising employees in any way may occasion revolts, withdrawal as well as laxity in their practices. This may precipitate such issues involving poor employee performance, thereby leading to failure of such businesses.