Banning Contact Sports in High Schools
Jason Man
ENGL17889GD
Peter Grevstad
November 24, 2014
Banning Contact Sports in High Schools
Many individuals believe that high school contact sports should be prohibited because there are many student athletes that have suffered serious head injuries because of they take part in contact sports. This is a huge concern in terms of the safety of the students participating in these extra-curricular activities, because if the injuries are not treated correctly, it could result in serious brain damage or even death. Although there is one negative factor in participating in contact sports, there are many positive factors for the student athlete such as building life skills, staying away
…show more content…
Out of these five sports, soccer, baseball, and basketball are not contact sports, but there are still numerous cases where athletes still get injured with concussions. Dr. Bakhos, a researcher at Hasbro Children’s Hospital and Brown University, does not want parents to worry about how concussions can affect their child because their overall health and well-being is more important even though they may be at risk of getting a concussion. Dr. Bakhos believes that most concussions are mild and that it should not pose a threat to an individual’s life as long as it is treated properly (Thornton, 2010). The effects of not having a concussion treated properly could range between lapsing into a coma and eventually dying or waking up from a coma with permanent brain damage (American Association of Neurological Surgeons, 2012). The concern in many cases when an individual suffers a big hit in a sport, they continue to play on without getting the medical staff to check if they have suffered from a concussion. According to Jon Butler, from POP Warner football program, so much of it was a lack of awareness. It was like you got your bell rung, get back in the game (as cited in Head Injuries in kids Sports, 2013). The message that Jon Butler is trying to get across is that the coaches nowadays, are more …show more content…
This is a problem because according to Dr. Julian Bailes of the Northshore Neurological Institute, players who get a second, third, fourth concussion really can have detrimental effects and have degradation in their function (as stated in Head Injuries in Kids Sports, 2013). This may be a concern for many parents who allow their children to participate in contact sports because their health is on the line. In terms of the information provided by Dr. Julian Bailes, there is a valid argument in why some individuals would want to ban contact sports in high schools.
Concussions from contact sports is a very serious problem that concerns many student’s health and well-being and because of this factor, many believe contact sports should be banned. On the other hand, if the concussion is treated properly it does not pose a risk in the student’s health. Also, it is very common for an athlete to get a concussion playing a non-contact sport such as basketball, soccer, or baseball. Finally, being involved in these sports is a form of exercise which is important to everyone’s health and well-being. For these reasons, contact sports should not be banned in high
A nationwide epidemic is occurring throughout the United States and is on the rise. Although many know about it, they fail to realize the side effects and diseases that can that lay dormant, waiting to be awakened and devastate their lives and potentially end them. Concussions are increasing annually among athletes in contact sports. Children and adults participating in these particular sports are potential victims of concussions and the long lasting side effects. The concerns of athletes receiving concussions is rising because as studies progress, many are leading to the conclusion that concussions impose future health complications.
When it comes to subject that the public is concerned about, contact sports and the consequences that come from playing such sports is definitely high on the list. The one fact that one will notice by reading the following is the reasons why contact sports should be banned and the credible sources that have confirmed the harsh outcomes of playing such sports. Through the injuries, problems that come from concussions, and the fact that athletes are pushed beyond their limitations, one will see that playing contact sports is not at all what it is cracked up to be. The injuries tell it all and through the blood-soaked writing that has been typed below one will see that playing contact sports should be banned for good from public schools.
In medical terms, concussions are described as "a complex pathophysiologic process affecting the brain, induced by traumatic biomechanical forces" (Hunt, Paniccia, Reed, & Keightley, 2016, p. 749). Over the past couple of years, the number of concussions in athletics has increased drastically. According to the data released by the National High School Sports-Related Injury Surveillance Study, in the school year 2005-06 there were 133,000 concussions, which was much less than the recent data of the 2014-15 school year of 292,000 (Brzycki, 2016, p. 57). Not only are concussions becoming more prominent, but they accounted for 24.5% of all the injuries in 2014-15 (Brzycki, 2016, p. 57). Although many advances in concussion protocol have been
Head coming forcibly into contact with another and concussions caused by physically coming into contact with other players in sports are a swiftly escalating epidemic among young athletes. When debatable cases corresponding to CTE are left undetected, concussions can lead to the condition of long-term brain damage and may even prove untreatable. Athletes are left defenseless and useless without facts provided without hesitation accessible about their own health. Most concussions resolve with rest within a week to ten days; however, about 10% of concussions take longer to heal and some may have long-term consequences. While research is ongoing to help identify the best approach to changing the culture of concussion in sports, there are action steps that coaches, parents, health care providers, and school professionals can take now to help keep young athletes safe and supported as they pursue the sports they love to play. A shortened play clock might also make obese linemen lose weight, since there’d be less standing around and more hustling. And since all players would be more tired, they would have less strength when delivering hits. This will allow coaches would to control the basic strategy, but the players would control its application, communicating with one another more and engaging their otherwise static athletic
When someone is diagnosed with a sport related concussion, it not only affect them, but it also affects the people around them. While playing sports that involves high impact to one’s head the athletes should already know that they are putting them self’s at risk of having a sports related concussion. Concussions can happen in almost any sport. The most popular sports that are known for having concussions will have to be American football and lacrosse of both genders. In the past, concussions were rarely heard about in youth sports, however, with today’s knowledge doctors can see the symptoms rather than in the past when people barley knew what a concussion
I will impose my concerns on the research that has been done thus far between contact sports and concussions. The concepts of Saunder (2010) and Leuke (2011) will support to institute my credibility. C. Audience 1) My primary audience will be parents, coaches and teachers of school age athletic participants of contact sports. 2)
As a nation that loves competition, the United States has become obsessed with sports. This obsession has allowed professional sports leagues to generate billions of dollars of revenue each year. The one sport that stands on top is football generating around 13 billion dollars a year. This even surpasses “America’s Pastime,” baseball. One of the reasons the sport has been able to succeed so much is from the sport’s violent nature, which attracts many fans looking for big hits. But unfortunately with big hits come injuries, one of the most common injuries being a concussion (injury to the brain caused by a hard hit on the head). In the United States alone over 300,000 concussions occur annually. That includes high school and college athletes.
My article covers the very important impact that sports and concussions have on an individual and their families. Head injuries are a very serious problem as described in this article, and to make sure that this problem is understood, we must educate our coaches, and athletes as well as parents, of signs of concussions and head trauma. Throughout this paper I’m going to summarize the article, and then approach it from the stand point of whether or not I agree with what the author is saying, or if I disagree with what the author is saying.
Concussions I. Introduction: Concussions and the ongoing treatments thereafter have been the source of much scrutiny throughout the history of organized athletics, and recently the attention on professional sports organization’s handlings of such issues has increased and a call to action is underway. There is new talk going on about how to manage the issue of concussions and questions being raised about who is at fault for the prevention and supervision of such injuries. Now that it’s known a solution is required, the struggle is on whether the right choice is to make the players more aware and informed of the problems, or whether putting the responsibility into the organizations hands to protect their players and establish the limits is the
Over the past couple of years, the severity of concussions has risen in many different sports, including hockey, soccer and football, specifically. With the increased development in technology, epidemiologists have noticed trends in how they occur and who is being impacted. Through these studies, it’s found that high school and college athletes in the U.S. are those most affected, with higher rates amongst girls. With this, the need for proper protocol and management is going to have to become more important to ensure the health and welfare of the athlete both short-term and long-term. While the number of athletes is increasing from high school to professionals, a big responsibility falls upon the shoulders of many people.
A 2011 study of U.S. high schools with at least one athletic trainer on staff found that concussions accounted for nearly 15% of all sports related injuries reported to athletic trainers. More than 248,000 children visited hospital emergency departments in 2009 for concussions and other traumatic brain injuries related to sports and recreation. Injuries associated with participation in sports and recreational activities account for 21% of all traumatic brain injuries among children in the United States. These statistics, all gathered by and coming from SWATA (Southwest Athletic Trainers’ Association), a branch of the NATA (National Athletic Trainers’ Association) are all reputable facts that were analyzed by healthcare professionals in the field of sports and that deal with athletes everyday. No argument for why a child should become one of these statistics is needed, given the gross number of cases and the severity of them
A concussion is a mild type of traumatic brain injury, caused by a blow to the head. A Concussion is a common injury in high school sports. Doctors consider them to be a mild injury, because they are rarely life threatening. However, a concussion can range in severity and it can be difficult to determine how serious the injury is, even with a CT scan. The student 's ability to recover is greatly impacted by the severity of the injury. Each student 's recovery is different, and often students are cleared to practice before they have fully recovered. Alarmingly, if a concussed student athlete returns to their sport without fully recovering, they are at risk for life threatening second-impact syndrome. Head injuries are finally being addressed on the news, and getting the attention they deserve. Now is not the time for naivety, the health of student athletes needs to be priority. What exactly is second-impact syndrome and how is it being prevented in high school sports? Every coach, player, and parent needs to be aware of the risk involved in making hasty return to play decisions.
Their epidemiological study of concussions incurred in high school sports over the span of 11 years found that cases of concussion resulting in loss of consciousness (r=0.98) correlated closely with the increases in concussion cases, leading the authors to conclude that the increases in concussion cases are more likely to be due to increased awareness as opposed to an increase in the intensity or aggressiveness of sports. This is drawn, however, with the assumption that an increase in aggressiveness would be expected to cause a disproportionate increase in the number of loss of consciousness cases of concussion; an assumption which could be flawed as the exact mechanisms of “aggressiveness” by players was not explicitly defined.
Concussion injuries frequently occur in the United States affecting young children, teens, collegiate, and professional athletes. According to the Journal of School Health, “Concussions remain a serious public health concern as approximately 1.6 to 3.8 million sports-related concussions are estimated to occur each year” (Covassin, Elbin, and Sarmiento, 2012). Public health is bringing
High school sport injuries have become such a common incident. Precautions are not taken as