preview

What Is Shared Authority?

Better Essays

INTRODUCTION
Originated from the Latin word “auctoritatem” with connotations of “invention, advice, opinion, influence, command” (McCormack, 2001), the concept of “authority” prescribes the normative rules of correct and incorrect ways to do certain things in the sphere of social control, and describes a person as being an authority regarding his or her proficiency, training and wisdom in the sphere of knowledge (Peters, 1966). Teachers are responsible for promulgating, maintaining and perpetuating the authority of social control, and positioned as authorities on the knowledge that they are required to transmit. This is why Peters (1966) insists his stance that “the teacher is an authority figure in both the above senses” (p.240). …show more content…

Teacher authority is generally considered to be a necessary and sufficient condition for carrying out a teacher-centred pedagogy, while proponents of child-centred progressive movements advocate the practice of “shared authority” with students (Gore, 1993; Olyer, 1996). More specifically, “shared authority” rejects the traditional form of “teacher authority” with an attempt to advocate an ethos in which teacher dominance is less likely to appear. Personally, however, it is inherently contradictory to speak about “shared authority” since the extent of “sharing” is also decided by the teacher. Thereby, it remains ambiguous and unclear what kind of authority should be adopted in the previous research.
Identifying authority as the nucleus of any educational relationships, and the construction of authority as a crisis in modern education (Arendt, 2006), this article is geared towards providing a critical review of the construction of “teacher authority”. The essential nature and notable features of “teacher as an authority”, “teacher in authority” will be scrutinized respectively. What the review unveiled is that neither of them is an emancipatory practice. Firstly, teacher as a legitimate and competent authority” has the potential danger to become authoritarian, and exercise power as a consequence of the unequal intelligence between the teacher and students. Secondly,

Get Access