preview

Authority Of Tutors And Learning Process

Decent Essays

Authority of tutors and learning process of student intermingle in the acquirement of knowledge and experience. Rabelais portrays authority in Gargantua and Pantagruel as several reflective and thought-provoking learning processes in regard of Panurge’s inquiry. Pantagruel and various experts in their own fields, including theologian, physician, and philosopher, provide their own comprehensions with the topics Panurge concerns. Similarly, Montaigne depicts tutor in the Essays as a role to offer guidance and help pupil to build their judgements. Collectively, both authors dismiss the necessity for tutor to form a conclusion in a discussion and force pupils to embrace their opinions due to their authority. Based on the understanding of both authors, learning achieves its optimal efficiency when authority accepts unconventional ideas by their pupils and performs least guidance by leaving freedom of thinking.
Authority should advocate the expression of unconventional ideas with plausible reasons supporting them. In Gargantua and Pantagruel, after Pantagruel gives Panurge the lordship of Salmagundi, Panurge “governs (Salmagundi) so well, and so prudently, that in less than two weeks he had squandered all of the revenue” (p. 250). However, Panurge, not feeling ashamed, states that his spending is in accord with the four cardinal virtues (p. 251). In this situation, neither Pantagruel gets angry nor Panurge feels abashed. Although Panurge seems to spend revenue in an

Get Access