preview

Beowulf's Heroism - Virtue or Flaw? Essay

Better Essays

Beowulf's fight with the dragon is a puzzle. On the surface, it appears to be the hero's final victory, and a fitting end to his noble life. Yet, the circumstances surrounding the battle – Beowulf's disregard for his thanes' advice and the Geats' bleak future without their king – raise pointed questions about Beowulf and his motivations. No where else in the poem are the hero's actions portrayed as anything but right and good.ǂ Not surprisingly, this issue has drawn considerable critical attention. Some critics insist that Beowulf's decisions regarding the dragon are entirely in accord with the heroic ideal.1 Others argue that Beowulf sought out the dragon for selfish and prideful reasons.2 In a way, the puzzle of the dragon-battle is the …show more content…

Even a critic such as Alfred Murtagh, who purports to “generally agree” with Niles, admits that “there is a great deal in the poem that provokes the sort of reading [Niles] opposes, and somehow one must account for this.”4 The negative view of Beowulf's heroism, as first pronounced by John Lyerle in 1965, accounts for the juxtaposition of Beowulf's triumph and his people's woe by postulating a causal relationship between the two. That is, Leyerle argues that Beowulf's “heroic susceptibility” leads him to choose his own glory over the security of his people.5 Leyerle characterizes Beowulf as a man of magnificence, whose understandable, almost inevitable pride commits him to individual, heroic action and leads to a national calamity by leaving his race without mature leadership at a time of extreme crisis.6

To Leyerle, Beowulf is emblematic of the fatal contradiction at the core of heroic society. The hero follows a code that exalts indomitable will and valour in the individual, but society requires a king who acts for the common good, not for his own glory.7

Leyerle makes a strong case, but I find the causal link he draws between Beowulf's heroic action and his people's suffering problematic. There is no doubt that Beowulf's kingship kept the Geats' enemies in check, but the fact remains that those enemies were always there, nursing their grievances and waiting for a chance to strike. Beowulf

Get Access