Best Practice and Recommendation #4:
Program Evaluations
Historic and Current Practices
Dave Koch became Executive Director of Inter-Faith Food Shuttle less than two years ago. Since he joining the organization Koch has promoted Performance Management and Sustainability Strategies. Utilizing skills learned in his Masters of Public Administration program and gained through educational and for-profit organizations, he is positioning IFFS to be a leader in nonprofit management practices. In our conversation with Koch, he shared that program evaluations are performed infrequently and when they are performed, focus on outputs more than outcomes. One program we discussed in detail is the Culinary Job Training Program (CJTP). This program provides unemployed or underemployed adults with culinary training as a segway to meaningful careers in food service. The courses are taught by a professional chef at the IFFS headquarters in Raleigh. Graduates of the CJTP program can also elect to take single topic/skill areas courses such as Line Cooking, Baking/Cake Decorating, Breakfast Cookery, Buffet/Platter Presentation, Deli, and Butchery for Continuing Education Credit. Koch and the IFFS Board are interested in cultivating performance metrics for the program. They currently assist in and track job placement and employment rates for the first 18 months after clients complete the program. The IFFS website says that more than 70 percent of CJTP graduates are employed 18 months after
The assessment is used to decide whether a program accomplishes the goals of the program and ensures stakeholders stay on task producing constantly improving results by inspecting all areas of the program, including determining needs, analyzing program costs, examining employee roles and their responsibilities, conducting an economic and efficiency audit, and deciding the next steps the program should undertake.
This program evaluation article by Duffy, Barry, Curry, Darragh, and Lees, reviews an initiative to improve the working relationship between Northern Ireland’s adult mental health services, and child protection services by reviewing a program called “The Champions Initiative” (Duffy, Barry, Darragh, & Lees, 2010). This was developed to facilitate a joint working environment to improve services and protection for children whose parent(s) may have mental health issues (Duffy et al., 2010). The Champions Initiative appointed a “champion” from each team of child protection workers, and mental health services, and their responsibility was to provide information, promote a joint working environment, and identify obstacles which would hinder good cooperation between the two teams (Duffy et al., 2010). The program evaluation assessed the levels of experience, training, confidence and awareness of the Champions, followed up with them in six months to assess the impact and the effectiveness of the program, and offered recommendations to
To ensure that my program evaluation is objective, credible and fair I would employ internal and external counselors or advisors as well as align my program evaluation with the standards and practices of the professional body of evaluators. These “advisors “may or may not include the program stakeholders, but would not negate the formal process of collaborating with key stakeholders. Rather, the purpose of my advisor team is to see and hear things I missed.
On Tuesday, October 3rd Monica Banks, a Wake Forest Divinity School student and a co-founder of New Communion, shared her experiences about her career/field of study and how it began to intermingle with food. Banks first began her career with a degree in business leadership and management and opening approximately 40 restaurant venues. After years of experience, she was looking for something more in life. After pursuing nursing she felt her calling was in the pastoral field and specifically surrounded food and poverty. As a second year student at Wake’s Divinity School, Banks was required to complete a group project, which led her the idea of the mobile pantry—now new communion. Banks felt such a passion for this project that she completed a grant application to United Way, which was eventually granted for the interfaith mobile food pantry. Banks took
The food service operation within each institution represents a major program area within the Federal Criminal Justice system. The Bureau offers a food service career for correctional cook supervisors in a fast pace and challenging environment. Cook supervisor receive full
The fourth nonprofit I analyzed is called GreaterGood which is an online website that sells a wide range of products that have been made across the world and uses the profit generated by sales to donate to a variety of different nonprofits that have a specific mission (Help, 2015, p.1). The specific nonprofits that GreaterGood donates to breast cancer, animal rescue, veterans, autism, diabetes, the rainforest, and the one that is specific to my area of analysis the hunger site. This style of nonprofit expressed by the GreaterGood charity is extremely unique because of the extreme differences in charities they are partners with. With the multiple charities they work with I would be confident in arguing that the GreaterGood-hunger site is a path-goal leadership style.
The setting of The Program takes place in the home and school of Sloane as well as the Treatment Center in a nation where there is an epidemic of teen suicide. Sloane’s school is full of anxiety like any other high school but even more so because the students are being watched by teachers, staff, and guards that will alert the Treatment Center officials if any of them exhibits signs of depression or harmful thoughts. Kids being dragged, screaming and with force, out of the halls and into the horrifying hands of the handlers creates an atmosphere of alertness, stress, and anxiety. Sloane’s home, rather than being comforting and a place to relax, is yet another place where Sloane is watched under a microscope by her parents who are constantly searching for any signs that Sloane could be getting sick. When any sign of depression could set off an alarm for her parents to send her away to treatment, Sloane acts incredibly anxious in her own home which makes the house as a whole seem to convey uneasiness. In the beginning of the book, Sloane’s house is full of pictures of friends and family and memories but after returning from the Treatment Center, the house is bare left with only decorations that are unable to bring up any depressing memories Sloane could have. The Treatment Center is under the watchful eyes of the Officials even more than the houses or school is under them. The
Overall this evaluation shows the continual disconnect with the EOF staff and this college. This evaluation fails to mention the true condition this EOF program was in, how the EOF program was viewed to the state, on the campus, and to the students before I walked on the campus. This evaluation chooses to portray an unfair image of me over the outstanding job that I have done in spite of what I have faced. In this report you don’t see the comments that the state director said about the program before I started working here and how the state director is extremely happy with the state of the program once I started working at this college. You don’t see how the stakeholders across the campus are ecstatic about EOF and the new direction it is going. Most of all it doesn’t mention the obvious changes that have happened with student engagement. As you go through the evaluation it makes me look immature and highlights the battles I had to faced taking on a declining program. This report fails to show that this condition put me in an unfavorable position. Nothing was normal about the condition of the program. I have worked in higher- ed for close to 10 years on three different campuses and
Improving program planning for the melanoma prevention: evaluation of a health education campaign for primary, requires critically considering the parents of those minor involved. One strategy for improving the planning when working with programs dealing with minors is a minor a consent form. The consent form should provide the overall goals of the program intervention and how are parents expected to get involved. Parental inclusion requires a great detail of information to know what is expected, where will the intervention action mainly occur, and what is required of parents to help make the changes occur in their children summer break (Fertman & Allensworth,
The GAIN program provides employment – related services to Cal-work recipients to help them find employment. The GAIN’s program philosophy is "A job, A Better Job, a Career." There are several components involved with this program to meet these goals. They are as follows: appraisal, job club/job search, assessment, vocational education training, and post-employment services, community service and assistance with mental, substance abuse and domestic violence treatment.
Providing the funds for the program budget are currently the responsibility of OMA itself, relying on fundraising efforts and nominal fees collected from facilities and families of participants. There are organizational restrictions that prevent the ASC from providing further funding and allocating additional time and personnel. Evidence collected on client experiences is lacking, and data that has been collected has not been analyzed or maintained in a database. This is a potential future threat as many funding agencies need to see program evaluation frameworks and evidence that the program is meeting its intended
The program that this student has designed and will test will not be in a “corporate” type building, it will be conducted within a classroom inside of a public school. This program will be centered on the idea in which both teachers and school administrators come together in helping to truly create a better future through their students, our future. In this classroom volunteers, teachers and therapists will meet to discuss the performance of children in that school. These volunteers would also help collect food and distribute this food to the children in need and their families. This classroom would be the base for educating both teachers and school administrators about healthy boundary crossings, such as when is it appropriate
The SELPS’s Evaluation and Promotion Committee has conducted its annual evaluation of Ms. Linda Ludwig for the period of January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2015. This annual evaluation covers only the period of her work as a term instructor for a sabbatical leave replacement during winter 2015 and as the SELPS Directory of Field Experiences during summer and fall 2015). This year is Ms. Ludwig’s third consecutive semester of fulltime employment at NMU.
My interest to participate in the summer immersion program comes from the passion that I have for caring for the vulnerable populations and my inheriting love for helping others. From the beginning of my nursing education, providing healthcare to vulnerable populations in different settings healthcare has always been important to me. I believe access to quality healthcare is a right that every person should have. My belief of healthcare for everyone has been my motivation for pursuing a career as a nurse practitioner (NP). I would like the opportunity to fulfill healthcare needs in people who do not have access to healthcare in low in come communities and countries by providing them
With the continuous changes in healthcare, evaluation of students’ clinical knowledge and skills relies on the need for continuous evaluation. Evaluation is the process of using data to make judgements about students’ individual performance. Evaluation of clinical performance provides data from which educators use to judge the extent to which students have acquired specific learning outcomes (Billings & Halstead, 2016). With the use of best practice evaluation methods, clinical performance can be evaluated to ensure quality patient care. Educators face a challenging task when providing evaluation that is fair and reasonable. Tasked with evaluating students in the clinical setting, educators can evaluate how students integrate theory and apply it to real-life situations. Observations of performance in the clinical setting should focus on the outcomes to be met and competencies to be developed (Oermann & Gaberson, 2014). Developing a clinical evaluation tool to determine whether students can think critically, prioritize problems, and complete patient care procedures correctly is essential. There are a variety of evaluation methods to use in nursing education. Depending on the learning outcomes to be measured will determine which tool best evaluates the students’ performance. Clinical practice is an essential and highly significant component of nursing education. Education programs are obligated to respond to government requests for well-educated healthcare professionals.