preview

Big Slope Resort Case Study

Decent Essays

1. First, the U.S. Constitution has priority over all other forms of law. This includes federal and state statutes, common-law principles, and state constitutions. In the event of a conflict, the U.S. Constitution takes precedence. Second, a federal statute would take precedence over a state constitution. Finally, the state constitution is the last priority for this set of laws. The reason for this order is largely attributable to the supremacy clause of the U.S. Constitution which states that any form of federal law will take precedence over any state law, even state constitutions. In addition, the general priority among the sources of law, in order of precedence, is constitutions, statutes, and common-law principles. 2. Brett can file suit in three courts. First, he may file with the state court of Mississippi because the incident occurred within its borders. Second, he may file with the federal court in Mississippi. Third, he may file with the federal court in Wisconsin. The reason he can …show more content…

To prove the negligence of the Big Slope Resort, Ben and Jerry must prove five elements of negligence. First, they must prove the resort’s duty. In this instance, duty is clear as Ben and Jerry are business visitors for whom the premises should be reasonably safe. Second, breach of duty must be proven. The resort’s failure to inspect the lift for guests prior to the shutdown satisfies that requirement. Third, the breach of duty must have caused damages. Ben and Jerry suffered physical injuries as a result of being stranded. Fourth, the breach of duty must have been the proximate cause of the damages. In other words, the breach of duty must be closely linked with the resulting damages. For this case, the actions of the resort were the only cause for the injuries. There were no other factors separating the cause and effect. Finally, there must be damage or injury. Ben and Jerry suffered from frostbite and other injuries, which qualify for this final criteria of

Get Access