Book Critique The New Deal

A frustrating factor of this book is that Badger doesn’t use footnotes, even with direct quotes. Instead he refers to specific authors, newspapers, and other works within the book. This loss is aided by his lengthy bibliographic essay and a list of abbreviations used within the book and their meanings. This list helps because it clarifies the specific organizations and groups used in the book. Within the book, Badger manages to mix together a number of different interpretations to present an account of both the New Deal and its historiography. Badger proposes a comparison of the reforms instituted and their unanticipated consequences. Many of these were the exact opposite of what the New Deal proposed, for example, the stronger establishment of big corporations, urban sprawl rather than revived inner cities, weak labor laws, and others.

“Happiness is not in the mere possession of money; it lies in the joy of achievement, in the thrill of creative effort.” Franklin D Roosevelt, an American political leader who served as the President of the United States from 1933-1945 who brought the country out of The Great Depression. Although some critics say that FDR worsened the country, he put an end to the problems of the country and helped escape the troubled situations of their rough time period especially while the citizens were dealing with the stock market crash, causing unemployment and money loss which then led to struggle of many families. The response of FDR’s administration to the problems of the Great Depression was effective because he established many New Deal programs,

The New Deal was a necessary program out in place which helped the nation and expanded the role of the government in a positive way. The nation was struggling in effect of the Great Depression and going through a hard time, and the New Deal helped the country out of it. Alone, the citizens of the United States would have never been able to pull themselves out of this mess, but the government stepped in and helped to fix the nation. The benefits of the New Deal can best be summed up with the three R’s: relief, recovery, and reform.

One of the key policies that were analyzed in the book was the New Deal. The New Deal is perhaps one of the most popular policies put into place, and is commonly the first thing to enter a person's mind when FDR is mentioned. The New Deal was thought up and established in order to battle some of the hardships the masses felt during the Great Depression. The New Deal attempted to help provide relief for the unemployed, recover of the economy, and reform of the economic and banking systems. The New Deal presented itself with as many as fifteen new programs and legislation, the majority of which were intended to the poor and the masses. Maney believes that the New Deal was to fix the mistakes the government made by causing the great depression "Under the auspices of the New Deal, the national government, while failing to bring full economic recovery, provided needed assistance to the unemployed and other disadvantaged groups and repaired some of the economic structural damage that helped cause the great depression." (Maney 47). Some of the key legislative acts that were implemented under the new deal were the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) "which offered the farmers the promise of higher prices" (Maney 49), the establishment of the Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) which was

When looking at the new deal in the 1930’s it is hard to say anything with conviction. From the start of the great depression to the war little was black and white. The reasoning you gave to the situation would probably give a clue as to where you fit in the status quo. However, this paper is about bringing to light if I think the new deal was successful or not. In my opinion yes the new deal was a success, though not entirely in the way intended.

In Document 4, it shows a sick man, representing America, receiving programs from FDR that were supposed to improve his health but didn’t. This document shows how FDR was wasting money and time on the poor by providing programs that are not improving the health of America. During the New Deal, as shown in Document 3, the expenditures in 1934 and 1935 went rocket high. This shows that the government is using too much money and causing deficits, and as long as these programs continue, the government will continue to incur losses. Document 7 states that the National Recovery Administration authorized lower pay rates for blacks. The Federal Housing Authority also refused to guarantee mortgages to blacks trying to buy houses in white neighborhoods. This shows that multiple New Deal programs indirectly supported racism and closed its windows on needy minorities. These documents reveal how the New Deal was just adding more pressure to the government and if not improving, damaging the society with unjust and insufficient

Shortly after the Great Depression began, society began to fail quickly. The stock market crashed, the unemployment rate skyrocketed, business’ and banks were closing and people were losing their homes they had worked so hard for. Although President Hoover was attempting to help society, he believed that instead of governmental interventions you should be self-reliant and would not fund welfare programs that may incentivize not working. Hoover’s “attempts” to aide the economy were not enough to turn it around, and people began to set their sights on Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the oncoming election. FDR made it his goal to ensure relief, recovery and reform were provided for the country to counteract the Great Depression and to make up for all of the years of negligence and non interference from the government, collectively called the “New Deal” 15 major laws were created in just the first 100 days he was in office, and his “New Deal” was coming into fruition and the governments role was now to step in and take care of it’s people, and to neglect them no longer.

The New Deal period was a turning point in American politics. It was when the states voluntarily cease to claim much of their freedom from external control or influence. Also the President acquiring new authority and importance and the role of government in citizens' lives increasing. The New Deal was a bunch of expedient and populist systematic plans. Franklin Roosevelt had a general vision of what he wanted for America. He was prepared to drive through the structural changes required to reach his goals for the American people. Roosevelt never intended to overthrow the constitution, nor did he want to end capitalism and individualism but many people felt differently. Many felt as if he did. He wanted the American Dream just like whose who

In his presidential acceptance speech in 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt addressed to the citizens of the United States, “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.” The New Deal, beginning in 1933, was a series of federal programs designed to provide relief, recovery, and reform to the fragile nation. The U.S. had been both economically and psychologically buffeted by the Great Depression. Many citizens looked up to FDR and his New Deal for help. However, there is much skepticism and controversy on whether these work projects significantly abated the dangerously high employment rates and pulled the U.S. out of the Great Depression. The New Deal was a bad deal

Document C illustrates that the New Deal represents change, but not revolutionary change. This caused the role of the government to expand. While Document D states that some New Deal acts were at odds with others. One example of a program in the second new deal is the Social Security Act, which created a retirement fund for citizen, but this act failed to help farmers, and domestic workers. The Tennessee Valley Act was part of the new deal, which helped with creating jobs, by building dams. Document I stated “The most important [The] most important contribution of the Roosevelt administration to the age-old color line problem in America has been its doctrine that Negroes are a part of the country and must ·be considered in any program for the country as a whole.” The New Deal acts were somewhat effective, as they did help some. In the end it wasn 't the New Deals that got America out of the depression it was their involvement in World War 2. World War 2 caused the unemployment rate to drop, since the whole country’s economy transformed to benefit war effort.

Perhaps Franklin Roosevelt did not end the depression. Even so, his years in the White House were so important that his record and his personality remain controversial. For many he was a great leader. He helped millions of needy people. He revolutionized the role of government. His measures were slowly starting to pull the nation out of depression and might have finished the job if World War II had not occurred. He provided hope to the hopeless, help to the helpless and courage to a nation desperate for leadership. In the chilling atmosphere of fear that gripped the nation before Roosevelt's first term people seemed eager to follow any leader who promised action and an end to suffering. At a time when dictators around the world were persuading

Some presidents had their busy starts and ends. However, no one had it worse than the president who got us out of the depression, Franklin Delano Roosevelt. While FDR served twelve years as president, he was able to do many things to change America for the good, specifically during the Great Depression, when the United States needed it most. He created Social Security, jobs, and saved banks. If he did not step up with his plan, known as the New Deal, the U.S. would not be what it is today. Instead, we would still be in the depression. He saved generations to come, with the help of the New Deal.

According to “The New Deal,” people thought the New Deal was not working so they tried to fight FDR's policies and wanted the gov't to reduce its spending. When it did reduce its spending the economy ended up slipping again. FDR’s New Deal was not working so he tried to create a new plan that was much more aggressive.

At the end of the day The New Deal was a bad deal. If you’re going to try to help people all the way don’t just help a quarter the people. Also don’t become power hungry as soon you get power. I think these all lesson one can learn from the New Deal. If the New Deal didn’t happen the future would be a mystery. Maybe Word War II would

The Great Depression will forever be a highlighted event in our United States’ history. It was so chaotic and it came with numerous problems that people till this date seek ways to prevent similar events from happening. People at the time came up with different ways to stop a crisis, like the Great Depression, from happening, but this is not as easy as it seems. It is not easy pleasing everyone specially in a country as diverse as the United States. The New Deal was one of these ideas made as a response of the Great Depression, This new plan was brought to light by Franklin D. Roosevelt when he ran for presidency. Roosevelt “landslide” victory allowed for these New Deal to set sail, but along the way many things challenged his New deal. Different businesses and even some strongly supported individuals ended up challenging Roosevelt’s plans and actions.