preview

Boundaries Of A Dichotomous Gender System

Decent Essays

Title: What it Means to be Gendered Me- Life on the Boundaries of a Dichotomous Gender System
Author(s): Betsy Lucal
Date:1999

Keywords: social construction, Dichotomous Gender System, gender display, gender identity, two- and- only two
Research Question/Problem: Gender being a social construction and made up of only two genders causes there to be a Dichotomous gender system that causes problems in the life of Lucal due to her appearance.

Method/Approach: uses personal experience to examine how it supports and contradicts Lorber’s argument
Argument/Conclusion: Lucal’s argument is that the personal is political and that living in a world made up of two and only two gender systems can cause some problems to those like Lucal who identify …show more content…

-addresses Lorber’s argument and plans to describe how she agrees and challenges her view
-living with the consequences of inappropriate “gender display”
-how gender affects Lucal’s life and she focuses on social construction of women
-gender is a social construction that all of us do
-each time we meet a new person we make a gender attribution and based on appearance and mannerisms we make a distinction between men and women
-there is a dichotomous gender system; binary system(must be one gender or the other)
-women have to make themselves as otheree because the norm is male so unless you make yourself distinguishable as a women you will be considered male (such as in Lucal’s case since she does not dress feminine)
-Lucal feels like she is proving gender blenders wrong(she is contradicting Lorber’s argument)
-Consequences she encounters due to issues of identity and issues of interactions
-Based on societal norms she is challenged when encountered with credit card use, public bathrooms, and changing rooms
-benefits and downsides to being attributed to the wrong gender: she has different ways of dealing with it
-gender means …show more content…

Method/Approach: Describing the process between the egg and the sperm and shows how research gives gender attributions to the eggs and sperm.

Argument/Conclusion:Stereotypes of men and women go back to biology(the egg and the sperm). Egg is seen as passive and sperm as heroic and active in penetrating the egg. Feminist challenge is to understand cultural imagery implications in order to rob the men from their power in social conventions about gender.

Argument Outline:
-gender stereotypes attributed to the egg and the sperm
- male is seen as productive from puberty to adolescence and the female is seen as destructive and pre-stocked at birth and degenerates with time
-egg is seen as feminine (large and passive) and the male is seen as masculine(active/powerful)
-egg dependent on the sperm, seen as holy and needs rescue
-discovery that the sperm is weak and that the egg is active yet they still find ways to make the sperm seem as the dominant one by finding out that it releases a digestive enzyme that breaks down the

Get Access