preview

Boys Don T Cry A Dichotomy Analysis

Good Essays

Power and sexuality have a rich and complex correlation. The dichotomies that we have studied in class help us relate these ideas in a manner they can be understood. In this course we define these dichotomies as deviant/normal, masculine/feminine, heterosexual/homosexual, and purity/corruption. This paper will extrapolate on these dichotomies based on what has been taken from the various materials presented in this course. The first dichotomy that will be expanded on is, what is normal and what we judge to be deviant. I find this dichotomy to be the most crucial one, on which we base judgements against others and consequently this is how power is established. I find that Scott Poulson-Bryant’s “Hung”, to be a good example regarding this topic. …show more content…

According to the Kinsey Scale, which argues that there is a scale between 1-7 of heterosexuality and homosexuality, and that there are very few individuals on the extremes of the scale. A good representation through a story about being stuck in the middle of this scale is the movie Boys Don’t Cry. In this film, Hillary Swank stars as a transgender, who starts falling in love with a girl in a small town. The movie sadly ends with Hillary Swank being raped and killed, which goes to show you the disgusting reactions of an intolerant society. Based on a true story, the movie really represents how society has dichotomized heterosexuality and homosexuality and you are either one or the other, just as with our gender. This clearly promotes the fact, that in our society, anything other than “normal” must be deviant behaviour. We cannot dichotomize this, because there are so many individuals in between, and it is impossible to fit all into two categories. In the film, we see that society cannot accept the fact that Hillary Swank was different, and that they had to punish her for being so. As a society it’s essential that we understand and accept these differences, because it’s very unlikely that most are on either extremities of the scale. It is strange that in modern society, it is slightly more acceptable to be a homosexual. As long as you …show more content…

Society is very shy to discuss matters about rape, and especially in North America, where we view it as something that doesn’t occur. This makes it unbearable for women, which were victims of rape, to go through this because it’s such a commonly unexpressed topic. A perfect example of this is seen in the play Ruined; in the play the women in brothels have been ruined, because they have been raped, are seen as corrupted and impure. The same goes for women in our society, because they are viewed as devalued, and are no longer treated with equality. This in turn allows the individual that was raped to adopt the hatred within them, which is devastating and undeserved. In Ruined, the women accepted be prostitutes because they felt there was nothing else out there for them which, unfortunately, is a common feeling amongst rape victims. In Sunitha Krishnan’s “The Fight Against Sex Slavery”, it is appalling to hear the stories she tells, as well as her own. The surprising thing is that she is not pleading for aid in liberating or stopping human trafficking. It seems what she needs is for society to accept and nurture those who are freed and want to live a regular life. She justly states that we have to move past this "culture of silence". Our society has this tendency to be indifferent regarding things that don't concern us directly and be quiet spectators. There are

Get Access