preview

Brutality Of Comanche Indians

Decent Essays

VanBuskirk 1 Kamren VanBuskirk Professor Kelly LaFramboise Anthropology 1113 1 December, 2016 The Brutality of the Comanche Indians I argue that the Comanche Indian people were some of the most brutal and cruel of the native American Indian tribes. The very name “Comanche” means “People who fight us all the time”. The word Comanche struck fear in the hearts those on the Texas frontier. The Comanche were famous for the raids they went on, and were feared by many of the settlers. Fighting was a large part of their lives. Warfare played a crucial role in the lives of the Comanche. The Comanche went to war for various reasons, including to gain stolen items, such as horses, goods, and even people that they kidnapped and held captive. In …show more content…

Infants were axed or speared, or hit against a rock to kill them. Females were raped and scalped. Some females and children were taken captive. Many captives did not make it out of enemy country. They were raped and killed on the trail, leaving bloody relics behind for their enemy. Torture included staking men out facing the sun with no eyelids and leaving them. They also used fire to torture. One account tells how they staked out some captured Tonkawa and applied fire to their hand and feet until they destroyed the nerves. They would then amputate the extremity and start the fire torture all over on the wounded flesh. They would cut their tongues out to silence screams. Scalps were almost always taken, many times while the victims were still alive. The dead were mutilated terribly. They cut off limbs, mutilated genitals, decapitated victims after scalping them, and eviscerated their bodies. They believed that this would cripple their enemy for …show more content…

There was a reason everyone feared the “Comanche moon”. When the moon was bright, such as a “harvest moon”, the Comanche were known to raid. However, on the other hand, it should be noted that many Indian women and children were also killed. The army would not only kill the men, but all of them. Also, since the Comanche were so know to commit these acts, almost any violent act was blamed on them. They may not have even committed some of the acts that they were accused of doing. Some have even suggested that whites invented stories to get people to go after the Comanche. One such instance may have been the Matilda Lockhart story at the council house fight in San Antonio in 1840. A Comanche band was supposed to be bringing all of its white captive, but they only showed up with one, Matilda Lockhart, a teenage girl. The story goes that she was horribly disfigured and mutilated, and her nose had been burned off her face. She told of other prisoners, so the officials were going to gold the peace council of Indians hostage until the others arrived. A fight broke out, and when it was all said and done, over 30 Indians were killed. The Indians were then said to torture and burn all of the captives they had to death, including young children. However, in documents and eyewitness accounts, the abuse is not well documented and some authors wonder if that was really the

Get Access