Bubonic Plague Dbq

Christian and Muslim responses to the black death were different. They believed in different causes, different treatments, and had different views on the plague. Although this may be true, they can be similar due to both thinking it is a punishment. However, Christian and Muslim responses were mainly different. To put it another way, both Christians and Muslims were both affected hard but handled it in their own way.

So how different were the Christian and Muslim Responses really? I myself think they were very different indeed in a way that the Muslims’ ideals were just a lot more peaceful than the Christians. The Muslims’ response to the Bubonic Plague was to simply accept it other than try to prevent it like the Christians. Muslims thought the cause was a blessing from God while Christians though they were being punished. The Muslims had a more positive view on the whole thing. Even they way Muslims thought they could cure the Black Death was to just accept it and

In the events of the Bubonic Plague, religions took a different response in this therefor Christians and Muslims are the two most researchers thought about during this time. This paper will guide you through what they did, how it affected them, and what they believed. Both religions thought up of some things that could prevent or get rid of the plague. Christianity thought it was a curse and Muslims said it was a blessing. Let's move on to the first point of this paper, Christianity.

The Christians and Muslims reactions to the Black Death were altogether different. In the first place, the Christians defied their religion and power. They gave in to greed and evil when the plague caused so many deaths (Doc. 6). Overall,

The plague was a disease that devastated Europe and the Christian population. Christians handled the plague very differently than the other groups it affected. The mortality rate for European Christians was an estimated 31%. (Robert S. Gottfried, The Black Death, New York: Macmillan Publishing, 1983.) They believed the plague was a cruel and horrible punishment on the men, women, and children of their society brought upon them by God.

Some Christians sought out minorities to blame for the Black Death. “The Jews were guilty of this crime as all around was said, wrote one European witness of the plague” (DBQ: The Black Death, 2010). Muslims did not respond to the plague like this. In reference to the Middle East one historian says, “In no case is there a direct causal relationship to be found between the Black Death and the active persecution of minorities, as in Europe” (DBQ: The Black Death, 2010). In other words, there is no evidence that minorities in the Middle East were singled out and blamed for causing the plague. In some cases Christians stopped focusing on God. One witness writes, “not thinking of death, nor of the past plague nor of their own salvation” (DBQ: The Black Death, 2010). On the other hand, Muslims were still devoted to their religion. “Men were crowding to the baths so that they might die in a state of complete purity”, recalls one Muslim (DBQ: The Black Death, 2010). Christians at this time were quick to blame others and some even abandoned their religion. Muslims stayed true to their beliefs and did not look for others to

Christianity and Islam are two major religions who responded differently to the black plague due to religious beliefs. Christians believed the black plague was a punishment for their sins where the Muslims see the plague as a blessing. While Christians prayed for the plague to end the Muslims were praying to Allah thanking him for the plague. Muslims saw the plague as a quick way to the afterlife if they were infected by it, where Christians seen it as a punishment which ended their life on earth. These are not the only differences between the two religions, there are many more that will leave you flabbergasted.

In addition to creating a social divide, the Plague also forced many people to reconsider where they were living causing a social “reorganization.” Despite the religious taboo against fleeing from a disease ridden area, many Muslims departed the infected cities for regions believed to be untainted. At the same time, a far larger number of rural Muslims

Christian and Muslim responses during the Black Death were different, but with a few similarities. Both Christians and Muslims proposed different reasons for the cause of the plague and also had different prevention methods for the plague. Even though there were many differences, there are also a few similarities, such as how both of them had similar beliefs at the time. Even with the few similarities,the responses between the two religions shows that Christian and Muslims responses are more different. Nonetheless, the evidence and responses by the living will prove that Christians and Muslims responses were different.

The responses to the Black Death by Christians and Muslims were vastly different from each

From China to North Africa and Europe, the Black Death left misery in its trail. Affecting both Christians and Muslims, the plague was given different responses from both religions. From a curse to a blessing sent from God, they tried to prevent it in similar ways, but both beliefs lead to very different thoughts and ideas.

In the middle of the 14th century, the plague razed the world from China to Europe. When the Black Death began to spread throughout Europe and the Middle East, it affected both Christians and Muslims in their respective regions. However, the both reacted in very different ways to this great plague. When looking at Christian and Muslim documents there is a distinct tone difference. While Muslims seemed to resort deep within their beliefs for comfort, Christians morals were broken by the expansive death and they looked for people to blame.

In times like these, many turned to their religions to fill in which they did not know. Document four explains that Christians believed the Black Death was the wrath of God. They believed God was angry with the people for their sins and they must pray for repentance to relieve the plague. The Muslims looked at it much differently. They believe that everything that comes from God is good; making the Black Death good. They believed that it was Gods will for that to happen so no prayers or sacrifices were necessary to relieve it and they must accept it.

The doctors from the medieval times were sure that this epidemic was due to unhealthy air and nothing else. There wasn’t any type of antibiotics to cure this disease, and because they believed it was contaminated air, they did not have any form of stopping it. Both Muslim and Christians While the citizens accepted the diagnosis, it did not stop them from making up their very own assumptions about what was happening to their people. The Christian people strongly believed that the cause of the Black Death was a way that god was punishing those who have sinned and needed to be justified. “Based directly on biblical and classical precedents, a conviction of personal guilt and a need for individual and collective expiation were engendered in faithful Christian.” As for the Muslim community, they did not believe that the Black Death was part of God's punishment

In response to the Black Death, Christians and Muslims developed similar scientific theories regarding the origin and prevention of the disease. Though located in different areas, the pandemic affected both groups nearly the same, killing nearly one-third of Christian and Muslim populations (Document 2). This parallel is likely because both societies established similar speculations of disease transmission and prevention techniques. Citizens of Europe and the Middle East determined that warm, impure air and celestial events were leading causes of the Black Death. Moreover, Christians and Muslims also agreed that drinking Armenian clay, building fires, and remaining indoors were the best means of illness prevention (Document 5). Although medical knowledge was minimal at this time, Christians and Muslims turned to science to control the Black Death.