Cannery Row As A Pastoral Novel Similar To Tortilla Flat
974 Words4 Pages
Alexander's excerpt drives his point that Cannery Row is a pastoral novel similar to Tortilla Flat but with deeper and more admirable sentiments. In his point of view, Cannery Row displays the marginal existence of the relatively primitive townsfolk in Monterey, with its pastoral aspects coming from detached, truth-hungry Doc. Alexander argues that the pastoral tone of Cannery Row is established in the short inter-chapter where Steinbeck renders Monterey as a microcosm with Mack and the boys’ orbits being more stable than those of the world. In addition, Alexander believes that Mack's famous apology to Doc for wrecking his lab 6recounts the outcast-renunciate status of the men.
Though as opinionated as any other literary criticism, Alexander justifies his standpoint with specific examples and allusions from the novel. The writing’s goal to uphold Cannery Row as one long “pastoral poem” is more precise and thorough than many other criticism’s with similar objectives. Alexander’s direct and confident tone makes his essay easier to read compared to other sources.
In Benson's article, he describes his belief that Cannery Row is a tribute to friendship, specifically to a man named Ed Ricketts, who some say Doc from Cannery Row vaguely resembles. He approaches the novel from three different perspectives: from the novel's literary context, its underlying naturalistic philosophy, and from the direction of Steinbeck as an artist. Also, Benson contends that Cannery Row