Capital Investment Decisions: The case of Diamond PLC

CONTENT PAGE

PAGES

1.1 - Introduction...................................................................................................4

1.2 - Literature review............................................................................................4-6

2.1 - Advantages and disadvantages of Net Present Value....................................6-7

2.2 - Advantages and disadvantages of Internal Rate of Return............................7-8

2.3 - General formulas............................................................................................9-14

3.1 - Critical*…show more content…*

Financial literature indicates NPV is best for capital rationing, and 7/15 of firms indicated that IRR was their primary choice in case of rationing. This survey specifies that the IRR technique is most popular for the evaluation of mutually exclusive projects, even though most financial literature considers it to be inaccurate when compared to NPV.

The third article “Capital Budgeting Practices: A Survey in the Firms in Cyprus” investigates: 1. the methods used by the Cyprus companies to evaluate investments, and 2. the approach adopted to handle important estimation problems inherent to the use of these methods. It was found that 54.43% of projects evaluation is done by means of a simplified evaluation technique and that 36.71% of the companies use the payback period technique. Among the methods that take into account the time value of money concept, the NPV method is the one most companies prefer, and only 8.86% of them use IRR.

In this study Hatfield, Horvath, and Webster (1998) investigated the importance of payback, average rate of return, IRR, and NPV capital budgeting techniques for the performance and value measures of firms. They found that firms analyzing all projects have higher share prices on average. They also found, in contrast to the theory of finance, that the NPV technique is not maximizing the value of the firm. Their results indicated that it is best not to rely on any single capital

CONTENT PAGE

PAGES

1.1 - Introduction...................................................................................................4

1.2 - Literature review............................................................................................4-6

2.1 - Advantages and disadvantages of Net Present Value....................................6-7

2.2 - Advantages and disadvantages of Internal Rate of Return............................7-8

2.3 - General formulas............................................................................................9-14

3.1 - Critical

Financial literature indicates NPV is best for capital rationing, and 7/15 of firms indicated that IRR was their primary choice in case of rationing. This survey specifies that the IRR technique is most popular for the evaluation of mutually exclusive projects, even though most financial literature considers it to be inaccurate when compared to NPV.

The third article “Capital Budgeting Practices: A Survey in the Firms in Cyprus” investigates: 1. the methods used by the Cyprus companies to evaluate investments, and 2. the approach adopted to handle important estimation problems inherent to the use of these methods. It was found that 54.43% of projects evaluation is done by means of a simplified evaluation technique and that 36.71% of the companies use the payback period technique. Among the methods that take into account the time value of money concept, the NPV method is the one most companies prefer, and only 8.86% of them use IRR.

In this study Hatfield, Horvath, and Webster (1998) investigated the importance of payback, average rate of return, IRR, and NPV capital budgeting techniques for the performance and value measures of firms. They found that firms analyzing all projects have higher share prices on average. They also found, in contrast to the theory of finance, that the NPV technique is not maximizing the value of the firm. Their results indicated that it is best not to rely on any single capital

Related

- Better Essays
## Capital Budgeting Of Florida Department Of Education

- 1670 Words
- 7 Pages

Capital Budgeting in Florida Department of Education Introduction Capital planning and budgeting is a very vital piece in the Public Budgeting System process. It is an essential implement in the financial management practice and is effective in both public and private organizations. It is the method which consists of the determination and the evaluation of the investments and the possible expenses by an organization. As explicate by Lee, Johnson, & Joyce (2008), capital budgets help in determining how much of each form of investment is needed, and it supports an organization in assessing the available revenue which includes loans is required to finance those investments (p. 475). Capital budgeting is a central part of the universal

- 1670 Words
- 7 Pages

Better Essays - Good Essays
## Fin 571 Week 4

- 1710 Words
- 7 Pages

Net Present Value (NPV): NPV is known as the best technique in the capital budgeting decisions. There were flows in payback as well as discounted pay back periods because it don’t consider the cash flow after the payback and discounted pay back period. To remove this flows net present value (NPV) method, which relies on discounted cash flow (DCF) techniques is used to find the value of the project by considering the cash flow of the project till its life. To implement this approach, we proceed as

- 1710 Words
- 7 Pages

Good Essays - Decent Essays
## Investment Appraisal Techniques Used For An Investment Project On Behalf Of Fenland Foods Plc

- 1987 Words
- 8 Pages

The five investment appraisal techniques used for this report are the Accounting Rate of Return (ARR), payback period, Net Present Value (NPV), discounted payback and Internal Rate of Return (IRR). The results of the five investment appraisal techniques may not be similar because of differences in their approaches and calculations. However, it is advantageous to use more than one investment appraisal technique and understand the importance and problems of each method before making a final decision.

- 1987 Words
- 8 Pages

Decent Essays - Good Essays
## Cost benefit analysis CanGo

- 1095 Words
- 5 Pages

DeVry University Accounting 460 Professor: Ivy Bennett Group: B Veronica Guajardo Annie Lee Isolina Pagan Cost Benefit Analysis VIA Consulting has been hired in CanGo’s behalf to assist its management group in the decision making of the implementation of the new operating ASRS system, and we came out with the following financial information and data. CanGo started

- 1095 Words
- 5 Pages

Good Essays - Decent Essays
## Just One, Inc., Has Two Mutually Exclusive Investment Projects, P and Q, Shown Below. Suppose the Market Interest Rate Is 10 Percent.

- 1549 Words
- 7 Pages

P 3–4: Just One, Inc. Just One, Inc., has two mutually exclusive investment projects, P and Q, shown below. Suppose the market interest rate is 10 percent. The ranking of projects differs, depending on the use of IRR or NPV measures. Which project should be selected? Why is the IRR

- 1549 Words
- 7 Pages

Decent Essays - Decent Essays
## New Heritage Doll Company Write Up

- 1317 Words
- 6 Pages

DCF and Sensitivity Analysis The Company should maximize on cash management by capital rationing on the project accepted. NPV of the project should be implemented as it reflects the time value of money invested in the accepted project. Similarly this can be further elaborated by computation of IRR of both project proposal.

- 1317 Words
- 6 Pages

Decent Essays - Satisfactory Essays
## Carhome Case

- 324 Words
- 2 Pages

Although CarHome project can generate positive free cash flow, it offers negative net present value (NPV) when discounted at weighted average cost of capital. This means that the shareholders’ wealth could not be maximised by accepting the project. In general, the company prefer shorter payback period. The discounted payback period of the project is 10.6 years, which is highly above the expected cut-off period of 6 years. On top of that, internal rate of return (IRR) is around 12% - 12.5%, which is below the weighted average cost of capital of 13.24% (as hurdle rate). The business managers are risk averse in nature. They prefer less risk to more risk for a given level of expected return (Pike et al, 2012). Consequently, it is too risky for

- 324 Words
- 2 Pages

Satisfactory Essays - Decent Essays
## The Super Project Case Study

- 1152 Words
- 5 Pages

The use of an accounting rate of return also underscores a project 's true future profitability because returns are calculated from accounting statements that list items at book or historical values and are, thus, backward-looking. According to the ARR, cash flows are positive due to the way the return has been tabulated with regard to returns on funds employed. The Payback Period technique also reflects that the project is positive and that initial expenses will be retrieved in approximately 7 years. However, the Payback method treats all cash flows as if they are received in the same period, i.e. cash flows in period 2 are treated the same as cash flows received in period 8. Clearly, it ignores the time value of money and is not the best method employed. Conversely, the IRR and NPV methods reflect that The Super Project is unattractive. IRR calculated is less then the 10% cost of capital (tax tabulated was 48%). NPV calculations were also negative. We accept the NPV method as the optimal capital budgeting technique and use its outcome to provide the overall evidence for our final decision on The Super Project. In this case IRR provided the same rejection result; therefore, it too proved its usefulness. Despite that, IRR is not the most favorable method because it can provide false results in the case where multiple negative

- 1152 Words
- 5 Pages

Decent Essays - Better Essays
## Case Study : Johnson Controls, Inc. Essay

- 1409 Words
- 6 Pages

There are several traditional methods that can be used in appraising investment decisions. For instance, the net present value method (NPV) which entails estimating the costs and revenues of a project and discounting these figures to get their present values. Projects with the biggest positive net present value are the ones chosen as they represent the best stream of benefits of investing in the project over and above recovering the cost of initiating the projects. The discount rate is another method which is similar to the net present value method but reflects more on the time preference. This approach may focus on the opportunity cost of

- 1409 Words
- 6 Pages

Better Essays - Better Essays
## Project Appraisal Techniques Essay examples

- 2565 Words
- 11 Pages

Project appraisal techniques are used to evaluate possible investment opportunities and to determine which of these opportunities will generate the best return to the firm’s shareholders. Therefore, it is vital for the firm if they wish to continue receiving funds from shareholders to employ the best techniques available when analysing which investment opportunities will give the best return. There are two types of project appraisal techniques: non-discounted cash flows and discounted cash flows. The Net Present Value and internal rate of return, examples of discounted cash flows, are in use in many large corporations and regarded as more effective than the traditional techniques of payback and accounting rate of return. In this paper, I

- 2565 Words
- 11 Pages

Better Essays - Satisfactory Essays
## Answers to Mini-Case Questions

- 1823 Words
- 8 Pages

( Answers to Mini-Case Questions BioCom Inc. This mini-case provides a review of the methodology and rationale associated with the various capital budgeting evaluation methods such as payback period, discounted payback period, NPV, IRR, MIRR, and PI. 1. Compute the payback period for each project. |Time of Cash Flow

- 1823 Words
- 8 Pages

Satisfactory Essays - Better Essays
## Capital Rationing

- 1452 Words
- 6 Pages

In contrast, when capital rationing constraints occur over multiple periods and when there are numerous projects, Baumol and Quandt (1965) suggest that mathematical programming may be used to evaluate investments. The linear programming technique is widely used as the model is specifically designed to search through combinations of projects achieving the highest NPV whilst subject to a budget constraint. However, Brealy et al (2008) note that a main disadvantage to using linear programming may be the models can be highly complex and costly.

- 1452 Words
- 6 Pages

Better Essays - Good Essays
## Compare and contrast the internal rate of return (IRR) and the net present value (NPV) criteria for evaluating investment proposals.

- 2568 Words
- 11 Pages

The internal rate of return (IRR) and the net present value (NPV) techniques are 2 investment decision tools that satisfy the 2 major criteria for the correct evaluation of capital projects. This criterion is that the techniques should incorporate the use of cash flows and the use of the time value of money. This makes them viable techniques for evaluating investment proposals.

- 2568 Words
- 11 Pages

Good Essays - Better Essays
## Capital Financing And Cash Management

- 1903 Words
- 8 Pages

CAPITAL BUDGETING for the LONG HAUL The primary reason executives initiate capital investment projects is value creation for stockholders. The objective of these investments is to create a higher total return consisting of dividend income and capital gains. Our initial question in corporate finance is to assess how new capital investments, like a factory, equipment purchase, or

- 1903 Words
- 8 Pages

Better Essays - Good Essays
## Financial Analysis Of A New Project

- 1338 Words
- 6 Pages

Financial analysis of a new project Introduction The following paper analyzes a project from financial perspectives using the capital budgeting techniques like Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR). Background My dad has a textile business, involved in embroidery and painting of the fabric. I have been visiting my dad’s

- 1338 Words
- 6 Pages

Good Essays