Capital Punishment is Wrong Essay

2406 Words 10 Pages
Max Soffar, whose mental illness left him particularly vulnerable to giving a false confession, stands convicted and sentenced to death for allegedly killing four victims during an armed robbery in a Houston bowling alley (Thorn, par. 2). The court overturned the conviction in 2004 because during his trial, lawyers failed to argue that Soffars confession contradicted the other evidence in the case, and he ended up on death row (Thorn, par. 4). From two unfair trials to a death sentence, the court ruled that the false confession given by Soffar should stand. In addition, his constitutional rights were not violated when his 2006 trial court judge refused to allow him to show that the only correct details in his fake confession were not the …show more content…
According to researchers at the Death Penalty Information Center, from the years, 1973 to the year 1999 there was an average of about 46% exonerations per year. From the years, 2000 to 2007 there has been an average of 12% exonerations per year (“Facts,” par 5). I believe that this is a good thing, because with the use of science, we save more lives. However, there still are cases were innocent individuals get put on the death row because of an eyed witness, who accuses the wrong person of committing the crime. Like in the case of Jennifer Thompson, a 22 year old college student who was raped in her dormitory said, “I can identify the man who raped me anywhere and anytime” (“Eyewitness,” par. 6). With her visual memory of the man who raped her, a detective captured a man named Ron Cotton who Thompson identified as the man who had done wrong to her. She even confessed more than three times that she was 100% it was the correct individual they had captured (“Eyewitness,” par. 9). Mr. Cotton was sentenced to death row and remained in prison meantime. For eleven years, he spent his life in jail and had no choice but to look forward to the day of his execution, until the real man who raped Jennifer Thompson turned himself in and the case was closed (“Eyewitness,” par. 14). According to the researchers at the Death Penalty Information Center, evidence shows that 138 death-row inmates have been exonerated out of 7,000-plus death sentences since the Supreme Court

More about Capital Punishment is Wrong Essay

Open Document