Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud

Better Essays
Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud
Carl Jung (1875-1961) and Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) were two individuals whose theories on human personality would completely affect the way that people viewed the human mind. Carl Gustav was a practicing psychotherapist while Sigmund Freud created the discipline of psychoanalysis. The two men had seemingly identical beliefs about human behavior, but also had contrasting beliefs about concepts such as the ego, the psyche, and the state of unconsciousness.
Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud’s Theories
Sigmund Freud’s beliefs about personality were based on past experiences in an individual’s childhood. Freud stated that all human beings had three personality levels. These were the ego, the id, and the
…show more content…
The accuracy of Carl Jung’s theory on the Unconscious
Carl Jung was initially Sigmund Freud’s student. However, Jung did not believe in Freud’s assertions about past negatives being the only things that affected the unconscious realm of the human thought process. One of the main reasons why Jung’s interpretation of the human collective unconscious is more practical and constructive than that of Freud’s psychoanalysis is because Jung’s interpretation has positive aspects that help rather than heal. For instance, Jung’s theory seeks to psychologically explain the significance of the role that religion plays in the formation of unconscious thoughts. Jung’s theory holds that people are mainly shaped by experiences that they have gone through even as they strive towards self-actualization.
In addressing the significance of self-actualization within the collective unconscious, Jung demonstrated that it was his belief that the collective unconscious is an area that has constructive tools which help individuals to achieve their life goals (Nystul, 2006). Sigmund Freud’s belief in repressed negative memories being held in the collective unconscious was more indicative of the notion that the collective unconscious was quite destructive because it held all the things that people did not wish to confront. Another reason why Jung’s theory is more useful and believable than that of Freud is because Freud’s psychoanalysis
Get Access