preview

Carlyon Foster Segal's The Dog Ate My Indian Education

Decent Essays

The Dog Ate My Indian Education Education is a crucial part of our world. Every moment of everyday humans are learning. Whether it is learning a new word, how to do something or even a new show humans are being educated. Education and learning are incredible things. Carlyon Foster Segal’s essay, “The Dog Ate my Flash Drive and other Tales of Woe” and Sherman Alexie’s essay “Indian Education” differ in their perspectives of the difficulties in education through the format they were written in, the intent of the author and the Point of View. In Carlyon Foster Segal’s essay, “The Dog Ate my Flash Drive and other Tales of Woe” the story talks about excuses used by students for why they did not complete their homework. The excuses are sorted …show more content…

In the beginning Alexie is a young boy in the first grade. In the beginning Alexie writes, “My hair was short and my U.S. Government glasses were hornrimmerd, ugly, and all that first winter in school, the other Indian boys chased me from one corner of the playground to the other” (143). As we get twelfth grade Alexie writes “I walk down the aisle, valedictorian of this farm town high school, and my cap doesn't fit because I've grown my hair longer than it’s ever been.” (147) these two quotes show the changes that occur through Alexie’s time in school and his reasons for getting …show more content…

Alexie had a hard time growing up being bullied but still muddled through to become valedictorian and go to college. The reason behind Alexie sharing his hardships of going through school is to show it is not impossible to overcome the hardships that may come up during school and that once you leave it is nothing but a memory. Alexie shows his strength and success in this essay. Segal’s point of view is that students will do anything to get out of doing their work. The way this essay is written seems to show that she believes that students do not care much about their education. Her point of view being a professor is going to be a more frustrated state than that of a student. Alexie is the opposite of what Segal describes. Alexie is bullied and goes through hard times in school. Many things Alexie faces would hold students back from doing quality work. By the end of Alexie’s education he is incredibly smart and emotionally strong. He shows that not all students will make excuses for why their homework is not complete when

Get Access