preview

Case Study: A Duty To Warn

Decent Essays
Open Document

A Duty to Warn an Uncertain Danger is a case where Ms L has been treated for pyromania and schizophrenia. She has spent five and a half years in a state mental hospital since she was eighteen as well as being arrested for arson on three occasions. Ms L is twenty-eight-years-old and just went to the hospital to deliver her fist baby. Mrs D, one of the social workers, recognized Ms L and her psychiatric history. Upon taking to Ms L about her pre-delivery, Mrs D found out that that she is going to stay with a Rabbi who opens his house to transients. Mrs D immediately wonders about Rabbi P about the potential danger him and his family wish be in. Knowing Rabbi P and the possible threat, Mrs D asks Ms L if she can have permission to talk to Rabbi P about the difficulties Ms L has experience over the years but Ms L refuses permission. …show more content…

and is it relevant that Mrs D came upon the confidential information about Ms L serendipitously, as a result of her previous employment in the local community mental health center? My opinion of the overall situation is that I feel Mrs D has no right to tell Rabbi P of Ms L’s history because Ms L refused Mrs D to tell Rabbi P about her history, It is Rabbi P’s choice to bring strangers into his house, there is no imminent threat and if Ms L is allowed to take care of her newborn child, she should be ok around other people. First, an important view that I feel doesn't allow Mrs D to tell Rabbi P

Get Access