preview

Case Study: Lawsuit Against US DOL

Decent Essays
Open Document

Lawsuit Against US DOL On June 1, 2016, The US Chamber of Commerce together with 8 other group trades officially filed a lawsuit in the US District Court Northern Texas against DOL and labor Secretary Thomas Perez on a number of grounds. Seeking to overturn DOL new rules mandating financial advisors to apply fiduciary standard of care in dealing with their client’s retirement accounts like the IRAs and 401 (k) retirement plans, the plaintiffs said that this new rule of the US Department of Labor will certainly undermine the interests of clients. However, the fiduciary rule took effect on June 7, 2016 and will be applicable on April 10, 2017 to IRA participants, brokers, investments advisers, as well as the participants’ beneficiaries and representatives. …show more content…

The court case also argues that this fiduciary rule which was released in April of 2016 have violated the first amendment right to free speech as it restricts communication between financial advisor and clients. The lawsuit also alleges that DOL have given them no adequate notice of the abrupt changes, thus, causing adverse consequences of its rule such as serious costs on the retirement savers as well as disruptive financial lost in the industry in general. This legal challenge also seeks to protect all other small investors, not harm them. But if the Department of Labor’s conflict of interest rule is implemented, it surely will, particularly small investors which it claims to …show more content…

The CEO of the Chamber’s Center for Capital Markets Competitiveness, Mr. David Hirschmann said that he expect President Obama to veto the existing resolution to terminate the said rule before its application next year. The plaintiff said the lawsuit aims to prevent the Department of Labor from exceeding its authority. The lawsuit is now asking the court to review whether or not the DOL overstepped its boundaries by developing a fiduciary rule which will leave Americans with only a few retirement options. They also said that the rule does not help the Americans to plan for their retirement, instead, it limits their access to affordable retirement advice besides “it” leaving the savers with limited saving options. Fiduciary advisors servicing small businesses will also stop servicing the retirement plans being offered by agencies which will significantly reduce the saving options to millions of employees and retirement plan members nationwide who are committed to their financial futures. The president and CEO of the Financial Services Institute (FSI), Mr. Dale Brown also added that they, like any other trade agencies has supported a uniform fiduciary standard ever since 2009, even before Dodd- Frank became law. The bottom line is that these various trade organizations is now asking the court

Get Access