preview

Ap Psychology Case Studies

Decent Essays

The researchers’ findings certainly appear to be accurate, but the reliability of certain cases studied is questionable. For example, ten of two hundred fifty-eight respondents reported that their phantom was perceived as being in a fixed position, and while some ideas as to why this may occur were postulated, a more specific study of this case would be helpful in their confirmation (Giummarra et al., 2010). Additionally, the researchers’ first-time finding that “approximately 4% of amputees experienced the proximal portion of the phantom only” will need to be repeated in order to be validated, and, especially, any suggestion as to why this may have occurred will require further investigation (Giummarra et al., 2010). The breadth and depth …show more content…

The researchers claim that this is not the case, and that their follow-up phone calls only served to limit the effects of these confounding variables (Giummarra et al., 2010), but only further study, which has taken into account those factors that necessitated the calls in the first place, will show whether this is, in fact, true. Other attempts to control confounding variables and biases included: submitting adjacent preexisting pain, coping, mood, depression and amputation surveys and using them to support or exclude data; and limiting the potential for human error in data perception by use of standardized statistical analyses and mathematical standards (Giummarra et al., 2010). The accuracy and reliability of this study, it being so broad, could have been improved in many ways; however, the biggest of these seems to be that the survey requires more fine-tuning of questioning. Trends among smaller proportions of the population need to be further examined using smaller scale, specialized studies, or they need to be extrapolated and tested for again among an even larger sample size, in order to see whether the presented correlations are consistent. This, however, would drastically increase the expensiveness of the study. The researchers concluded that the phantom limb can be generalized as presenting with characteristics similar to those which would present in

Get Access