preview

Case Study : Professional Ethics

Good Essays

Iwill be analyzing Case Study 2.3 from unit two in the study guide. The professional ethics issue in this case is: “Whether the doctor should lie to the family regarding the father’s ability to donate a kidney and begin a search for a cadaver kidney?” This is an important and controversial question, which is discussed in this essay. There are two possible answers, “yes” and “no” to this question asked, and each side is analysed. I will discuss both possible outcomes to the professional ethics question posed above.
The first possible answer here is “yes”, the doctor should lie to the family and begin looking for a cadaver kidney. The only reason the doctor would choose to lie in this case, is because the father came to him with his fear of donating his kidney. Especially, since the father is begging and pleading with the doctor to not inform the family, but instead find a cadaver kidney. Perhaps, there is a good possibility that a cadaver donor can be located that matches the daughter’s kidney. Furthermore, the doctor would alleviate the father’s fear of donating his own kidney, and the family would be none the wiser to the omission of the truth.
Another reason for lying to the family on the father’s behalf is because the doctor is quite certain the man’s wife will shame him into donating. Besides, the donation would not be arrived upon under voluntary circumstances, but against the father’s will. This could way heavily on the surgeon as he is prepping the father to go

Get Access