preview

Catcher In The Rye Literary Analysis

Decent Essays
Open Document

In the Tribes of Palos Verdes and The Catcher In the Rye, both Jim and Holden struggle to find mental stability in their lives. J.D. Salinger expresses one of Holden's weaknesses in the statement,"I'm just going through a phase right now. Everybody goes through phases and all, don't they?"(15). When someone has a issue they often can’t say they have that problem and blame another reason for it. For Holden in The Catcher In the Rye, he blames his struggles on the phase he is going through. In reality the people that he calls “Phoneys” are the people he looks up to. Holden is the Phoney but he just can’t call himself that because he doesn’t want to admit he is one and they aren't. Jim’s problem is he can’t face the fact that he is becoming a …show more content…

Krista Comer portrays the ideas of surfers during the time period as, “images of surfers as rebelliously masculine, sensual, anti-materialist social dropout”(Comer). During the time period this book was written, surfers had a very big image. Medina and Jim are very close but their lives are opposites. These words that Comer write to describe surfers tell the story of both Medina and Jim just in two different directions. From the beginning to the end of the story Medina and Jim’s life did a swap. The reason their lives did this swap was because of the mental instability. In the beginning of the story Medina was the one with no mentor or someone to take care of her and listen to her. This caused her to mentally suffer and let herself get abused. Jim in the beginning of the book is the center of attention by his mother and everyone at school. Jim having all the attention allowed him to strive in the family, surfing, and girls. As time went on Jim started to push himself away from everyone and find his way to drugs. As Jim started to fill his body with drugs they took over his mind, leading him into a black hole with no way to get out. Jim was going down a bad path while Medina found herself climbing out of her depressed mind. Her new boyfriend Adrien allowed her to finally have someone to talk to, takecare of her, and love her the way she loved him. As Medina found her high point, Jim was at his lowest point. The only person left in his life was Medina, he had finally gotten tired of his mother, and was done taking care of her and stopped paying attention to her. Jim’s mind finally was no longer present and caused himself to take his own life. Jim and Holden’s lives are not the same, but they are similar. Medina’s life story shows the middle ground between the two of them. The only big difference that Medina has in her life is finding

Get Access