preview

Chaucer Against Women Unconstant

Satisfactory Essays

There has been an ongoing debate about the authorship of the poem “Against Women Unconstant.” As stated in The Riverside Chaucer, many of the most prominent scholars of Chaucer are divided about whether Chaucer did write this poem. Regarding this issue, Jay Ruud found piece of evidence within the poem that points to Chaucer’s authorship. He addresses the image of a mirror present in the poem and links it to Chaucer’s translation of Boethius’ The Consolation of Philosophy. Based on his analysis, I am inclined to believe his argument that the image of the mirror used in the poem lends further evidence to the fact that Chaucer did write “Against Women Unconstant.” As an extension of his analysis, I will look at the poem as a whole and comment on the other elements. I argue that the image of the mirror, along with other aspects of the poem, is consistent with the tone and style present in other works by Chaucer and use this internal evidence to support the case for Chaucer’s authorship of the poem. To begin, I will provide a brief summary of Ruud’s argument. In his paper, Ruud argues that the image of the mirror presented in “Against Women Unconstant” suggests a familiarity with Chaucer’s translation of Boethius’s The Consolation of Philosophy. In the second stanza of the poem, the author compares his lady love to a mirror, as no lover can make an impression on her. Ruud suggests that this line mixes the metaphor of the mind as a mirror and the metaphor of the mind as a

Get Access