The Great Wall was first build by Qin and Han.The reason why they build the wall is because to keep the enemies away like The Mongols.However, the benefits of the Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs.
The Great Wall of China may have been helpful against a few attacks, but this build had too many costs. Losing thousands of lives is not the same as protecting a few. China was not familiar of the costs they would have had to face. China should have looked before they
The Great Wall of China is one of the most beautiful and biggest ancient structure. In ancient times it was very well maintained and now it is sort of maintained because 30% of the wall is gone. The wall shows pride and culture to china even though 30% of the wall is gone and now there are laws in place to protect and maintain the wall. However most of the wall if gone is from human damage.
When Emperor Qin took the throne, he ordered the general Mengtian to reorganise/extend the separate walls of the former states, reaching an extent to all 7 ‘warring states’. This was to provide a more stable form of protection for habitants in his empire. 300 000 captured soldiers and conscripts lived, worked and died in the remote areas of the empire. Slaves were also commissioned to take part in the construction of the wall. Little of the wall built by Qin remains today, as it has been rebuilt, maintained, and enhanced; the majority of the wall seen today was built by the Ming Dynasty (1368-1644). This structure is now a form of transporting to other states/a tourist attraction, and is labelled one of the ‘7 Wonders of the Medieval World’.
In Document A, the map shows the wall surrounding north china and created a barrier from the Xiongnu people. This shows the wall protected the Chinese people from the Xiongnu by preventing them from invading the land inhabited by the Chinese people. Also in Document A, it says watch towers estimated in the thousand, were placed 2 bow shots apart, stating that soldiers were constantly watching and staying alert for possible attacks. Document B discussed moving people to settle along the northern border, which would discourage invaders from the North. They would be less likely to invade, knowing there were people and troops in the area. Document D says Wu Di assigned thousands of soldiers to wall outpost and watchtowers to protect the merchant and caravans traveling along the trade routes. This allowed the merchants to travel with no fear because the wall protected them from being ambushed by invaders. Providing protection, is a huge benefit and was worth the
This gave a sense of security to incoming traders from across the land. They felt safe to go beyond these walls and to trade inside. It also helped to increase the economy of China because of the increase of productivity and trade. The main purpose of the road was to protect trade on the silk road. This was the main location of where trade took place in China. The emperor even extended the wall to protect it far enough on the silk road. A China highlights website states that “In the Han Dynasty, the emperor's extended the Great Wall far into western’s China to protect the Silk Road trade” (Pkl). This proves how important it was for China to have these walls even it was at such a heavy
To begin with, the wall protected the people of China. The wall was comprised thousands of watchtowers and they had pulley systems for raising fire signals, according to the map on Document A. Chao Cou (document b), an advisor to multiple Han emperors, was highly respected for his ideas about military defense and border security, also had recommended building the wall to protect the Chinese people from a threat.
◎ The Great Wall of China was started to be built by the Han and the Qin dynasty. They built the wall to keep the Xiongnu Mongols out of China. However the benefits of building the Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs. According to Document B it showed the Chinese had to pay tribute in silk bales to the Xiongnu mongols. This showed that even though the Chinese had built a wall to keep out the Mongols the Chinese still had to pay them tribute. To add on, as the Chinese added to the wall and made it greater and more massive the tribute they had to pay started to increase as the years went by. Another reason why the benefits of The Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs is The Great Wall caused many deaths. Another reason
GPS Satellites have calculated that it’s various sections on the wall, are 5,488 miles long. It took the Qin and Han 2,000 years the build the Great Wall of China. The Qin Dynasty started building the wall from 221-206 BCE, before the Han Dynasty took over in 206 BCE to 220 CE. The wall was built from 221 BCE to 220 CE. Qin started building the wall to keep the Xiongnu and to impress visitors. The wall was made out of dirt and dead builders. Huairou, China is where the Great Wall of China is. The Great Wall of china: did the benefits outweigh the costs? The Great Wall was not worth the cost due to the high mortality, harsh working conditions, and the Xiongnu tribute during the construction.
To begin, the wall provided more security for China. In other words, the wall was used as a shield. The wall was about 4,000 miles long acting as a barrier against the Xiongnu to the north (Doc.A). It appears that the wall was built so the sides of the wall would
Building the Great Wall was not worth the cost. The Great Wall of China is a long series of walls on China’s border that was built to protect them from getting attacked. The Great Wall was built to keep out the Xiongnu and other groups that attacked them. The Xiongnu was the main group that attacked China. People want the Great Wall built because it protects the Chinese states and empires. I believe they are wrong because it cost a lot of money and labor, it didn't work, and there was a ton of harsh working.
According to document B, “People [slaves, convicts, and willing peasants] should be selected to settle along the border areas… while getting prepared against possible invasion by the Xiongnu.”(Document B). Since there were always people along the Great Wall it would be difficult for the Xiongnu to enter China and harm the people within the wall. Therefore, the wall provided a barrier that was both difficult to get around or climb and was also heavily guarded. Overall, the Great Wall offered the residents of China a strong sense of protection from
The wall couldn’t stop Genghis Khan and the Mongols because they would go around the wall. They would also go under the wall. The wall still stands after all of the invasions and attacks. The great wall of China is the most known symbol in china.
It was the Ming Emperors, who restored the buildings of the Wall after ending the conflicts with invaders. During the Ming Dynasty, the wall was reconstructed, repaired and rebuilt, and new sections were also added. "Many dynasties reigned over China during this almost 2000 year project," and the final major renovations were done during the Ming Dynasty (par.3). The time needed to complete the Great Wall is much longer than that used to build the pyramids.
The Great Wall of China stretches about 5,500 miles long crossing deserts, mountains, grasslands, and plateaus. It took more than 2,000 years to build this incredible manmade structure. Many people died to build this wall. It displays the changes between the agricultural and nomadic civilizations. It proves that the superb structure was very important to military defense. It became a national symbol of the Chinese as a security for their country and its people. The Great Wall of China must be preserved at all cost because it is a historical symbol that made it possible for China and other nations across the world to prosper (UNESCO World Heritage Centre: The Great Wall).