preview

Christian Reading Non-Christian Literature

Good Essays

Although pagan (i.e. Roman) literature clearly contains valuable lessons on philosophy, logic, rhetoric, science, authority, virtue, etc., many argue that the mere fact that it is pagan should cause Christians to avoid it all together and receive an education elsewhere. If Augustine was grateful for his reading skills, which come from “early lessons in literacy,” why did he warn Christians against pagan literature (Confessions 1.20)? After understanding what St. Augustine thought and why he thought it, recognizing that a man should not be ignorant and that all truth leads to Christ, comparing Christianity with paganism as a whole, and knowing that Christ perfects all, one can conclude that Christians should continue to read pagan literature. …show more content…

pagan) works can be approached differently through comparison of Christianity and paganism as a whole, along with the idea that Christ perfects all. Chesterton writes, “The primary fact about Christianity and Paganism is that one came after the other” (Heretics 53). Therefore, the pagan Roman works remain pagan, but are also “pre-Christian.” Combined with the fact that philosophy’s dissatisfaction was completed by Christ, it follows that a Christian can uncover more depth in Christianity by studying pagan works with eyes of faith. Chesterton observes, “A pagan was generally a man with about half a dozen” religions (53). Augustine saw the “wholesomeness of the Christian religion” as satisfaction for the ancient pagan thinkers, who desperately tested these “half a dozen” religions in vain, one after another (City of God 2.28). This “wholesomeness” also offers overwhelming freedom. Chesterton writes, “It is a curious fact that the moderns have mostly rebuked historic Christianity, not for being narrow, but for being broad. They have rebuked it because it did prove itself the desire of all nations, because it did satisfy the cravings of many creeds, because it did prove itself to idolaters as something as magic as their idols, or did prove itself to patriots something as lovable as their native land” (The New Jerusalem 112). Chesterton believed the “Church was infamous because it satisfied the Greek intellect and wielded the Roman power” (112). Continuing the notion that Christianity perfects all, Augustine writes that if philosophers “have said aught that is true and in harmony with our faith, we are not only not to shrink from it, but to claim it for our own use from those who have unlawful possession of it” (Christian Doctrine 2.40). Augustine shows that if men like Moses received pagan knowledge, pagan works contain not only “false and superstitious fancies” but also “liberal instruction which is better adapted

Get Access