preview

Civilized Vampires Vs Savage Werewolves Persuasive Essay

Decent Essays

Is it possible for one monster to have an advantage over another monster? In her essay “Civilized Vampires Versus Savage Werewolves: Race and Ethnicity in the Twilight Series” author Natalie Wilson points out the difference between how white monsters and ethnic monsters are portrayed. Twilight is a book series about a human girl named Bella who must romantically choose between a white vampire named Edward Cullen or a Native American werewolf named Jacob Black. Wilson states that the white vampires in Twilight are glorified and portrayed in a good light. In contrast, ethnic minorities are portrayed negatively and often associated with animals. While many might consider Jacob to be more monstrous than Edward due to his negative attributes I do not agree. What makes …show more content…

Edward has a plethora of unearned advantages given to him because of the concept of white superiority. Additionally, Edward’s white skin and glorious looks make him perfect in the eyes of Bella. In her eyes he is the peak of superiority. She looks up to him. Edward could have easily convinced Bella into doing just about anything because of the perfection his whiteness grants him. For instance in the Twilight novel Eclipse, when trying to stop Bella from seeing Jacob, Edward confidently says “I’ll have to stop you.” (Meyer, 34). Bella wants to see Jacob but does not question Edward and in fact believes he will be able to stop her thinking “I was sure he was right.” (Meyer, 34). Edward is perfect and his judgments are final in the eyes of Bella. The fact that Bella thinks Edward is superior controls her life. Her admiration for him is excessive and strongly based on the advantages of the color of his skin. The concept of white superiority creates admiration towards white people that is at times unwarranted and unfair. Not only does Edward’s skin color give him more monstrosity but so does his

Get Access